Review: When movies partied like it was 1999

Photo Composite (Ciaran Freeman/unSplash)

“We’ve got a problem. George is trying to pound David, and David is choking George.”

That was the call an executive at Warner Brothers received from the set of the 1999 film “Three Kings.” George Clooney and the director David O. Russell had finally come to blows.


Best. Movie. Year. Brian Raftery

Simon & Schuster $28.99, 416p

If you were in high school or college around 1999, Brian Raftery’s new book, Best. Movie. Year. Ever. How 1999 Blew Up the Big Screen, will probably strike a chord. Even if you don’t fall into that thin demographic slice, Raftery weaves celebrity interviews, box office statistics and pop culture milestones into a fast-moving and generally convincing case that 1999 was indeed the Best. Movie. Year. Ever.

In the course of just over 400 pages, Raftery cites “Fight Club,” “The Sixth Sense,” “Cruel Intentions,” “Office Space,” “American Beauty,” “Election,” “The Blair Witch Project,” “Being John Malkovich,” “The Matrix,” “Boys Don’t Cry,” “The Best Man,” “Three Kings” and “Magnolia,” among others, as signal cinematic accomplishments of 1999. He also includes “Star Wars: The Phantom Menace,” but I suspect that onscreen trainwreck would be better used in a counterargument.

Quibbles aside, Best. Movie. Year. Ever. succeeds in dropping the reader into the lives of cast and crew alike on these films. Readers get a taste of what inspired writers, directors and actors to labor to move projects from scripts and storyboards to the big screen.

If you were in high school or college around 1999, Brian Raftery’s new book, Best. Movie. Year. Ever. How 1999 Blew Up the Big Screen, will probably strike a chord.

Part of Raftery’s thesis is that movie executives were courageous in the years leading up to 1999. They bet large sums of money on interesting ideas. Most of them lost their bets when many of the films disappointed at the box office. But that makes 1999 even more significant: It is a year not likely to be repeated.

Box office success, however, is not the only evidence Raftery submits: What if a movie influenced others, if it became part of the cultural conversation or if it captured the zeitgeist of a generation? “Office Space” is a great example. It was not a box office success, but anyone who has ever worked in a sea of cubicles has probably quoted (knowingly or not) several lines from the movie.

While there are times when Raftery tries to score “geek points”—describing George Lucas’s beard as “Hoth-white” or throwing readers down winding pop-culture rabbit holes—he can be forgiven because his deep geeky knowledge is also what makes this book work. Tying together themes and highlighting connections among many of the year’s great films, Best. Movie. Year. Ever. makes me wonder: Why wasn’t I able to connect all these dots back then?

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Crystal Watson
9 months 2 weeks ago

His book sounds kind of like a 90s version of Ready Player One. My favorite films of 1999 ... The Matrix, The Mummy, Stigmata, The Insider, The Messenger. And The Deep Blue Sea (guilty pleasure).

Russell Scott
9 months ago

This is a very cool book. I read it for a long time. I took this book from my friend, in order not to buy. She really looks like The Matrix and a The Mummy. In college, I wrote an essay on him “my favorite book” and I wanted to write about this book, but then I decided to bathe the essay on and the writers wrote about another book that I also like very much. It was a book about rich people in Babylon.

More: Books / Films

The latest from america

Mary Magdalene’s actual history, as Margaret Arnold tells us, is much richer than we think. The tradition’s appropriation of Mary Magdalene is much more intricate and complex—as the saint herself is complex.
Kevin SpinaleFebruary 14, 2020
Noted philosopher and gender theorist Judith Butler discusses nonviolence, grievability and "radical equality" in her book "The Force of Nonviolence: An Ethico-Political Bind."
Ryan Di CorpoFebruary 10, 2020
For the title sisters in ‘The Grammarians,’ words are much more than words, and the rules that govern them must be upheld with a believer’s zeal.
Maurice Timothy ReidyFebruary 07, 2020
Lauren Duca counters the claim that Gen Z and millennial cohorts are detached from the political process with examples of people moved, primarily by the ascendency of Trump, to advocate for change.
Anna J. MarcheseFebruary 07, 2020