A fearless look at the tragedy of abortion

The Dutch Jesuit Ward Biemans has written a significant book on abortion. Indeed, it is quite rare to find this kind of evenhanded, broadly researched study. Biemans’s focus is on Dutch and British abortion history and law, but the book has important insights for people outside of these communities—especially in the United States, where the (often self-reported) data are comparatively poor.

The Heart and the Abyssby Ward Biemans, S.J.

Connor Court Publishing. 392p $40

A word must be said about the steady fearlessness of Biemans in this work. Eschewing political rules that constrain most academic writing on this topic, he feels free to follow the data and arguments wherever they lead him. For example, he critically reviews the literature on the relationship between abortion and breast cancer—carefully expressing concern, when warranted, about studies that may suffer from underreporting or reporting bias.

Perhaps the most powerful pro-choice argument rests on the claim that restrictions on abortion do not actually stop abortion from happening—they only make said abortions safer. Biemans devastates the foundations of this argument by invoking multiple studies to show the number of abortions in the United Kingdom and Netherlands increased dramatically after legalization.

Even if the United States had European-style social welfare and access to contraception, there would still be about 700,000 abortions each year.

Even if the United States had European-style social welfare and access to contraception, there would still be about 700,000 abortions each year. Financial reasons are significant factors leading to abortion, but Biemans’s research in the Netherlands demonstrates “relationship conflicts” are at least as important. He notes lack of moral formation in the culture and lack of counseling in the event of a difficult pregnancy. Sex education refuses to focus on the possibility, responsibility and even beauty of parenthood as a result of sexual activity. This while women are rarely counseled on abortion alternatives, and men are generally absent from the scenario altogether.

Biemans’s final conclusion that mothers and fathers ought to have mandated counseling before terminating pregnancy is a good reminder for those who focus on reducing the demand for abortion. While financial injustice plays a role, the formation of a virtuous people is the sine qua non of reducing abortion society wide.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Crystal Watson
1 year ago

"the formation of a virtuous people"

What that seems to really mean is indoctrinating people with a specific viewpoint that the author believes in. The idea that people who decide to have an abortion don't have ethics or virtue or even religious beliefs is untrue. There are many religious people and groups who are pro-choice: Catholics For Choice, The Religious Coalition For Reproductive Choice, and a majority of US Catholics support legal abortion in some or all cases.

Jim Lein
1 year ago

One thing legalization of abortions accomplishes is a much more accurate count of the number of abortions. There are educated estimates that the rate of abortions in economic depressions, such as the 1890s and 1930s, were higher than now, like a million in some years back when the overall population was much lower than now.

More: Books / Pro-Life / Abortion

Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

We collaborate with God’s grace and find conformity with Christ, by acknowledging our creaturehood, our temptations, our distractions and expectations, our doubts, our grudges, our compulsions, and by allowing “Christ to pray for us, with us, and in us.”
Ron HansenMarch 23, 2018
The familiarity of the language and the story in Andrew Krivák’s "The Signal Flame" is an homage to how people, be they siblings, friends, sons and fathers, mothers and sons or sons and lovers, communicate with each other, by word or gesture.
Paul AlmonteMarch 23, 2018
With Crispina and Her Sisters, Christine Schenk, C.S.J., has performed a singular service in making accessible additional sources about early Christian women.
Brian O. McDermottMarch 22, 2018
Review of Ross Douthat's latest book, "To Change the Church." While the church always strives to honor what Jesus said about divorce and remarriage, it has made pastoral accommodations since its earliest days.
Thomas P. RauschMarch 20, 2018