U.S. bishops approve third-party system for reporting abuse

Bishops use electronic voting devices during the spring general assembly of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops in Baltimore June 12, 2019. (CNS photo/Bob Roller) 

BALTIMORE (CNS) — A nationwide third-party system for receiving confidential reports of “certain complaints” against bishops took a step closer to being implemented during the spring general assembly of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops.

In a series of three votes June 12, the bishops voted overwhelmingly to authorize the implementation of a system that would allow people to make reports through a toll-free telephone number as well as online.


The system, which would be operated by an outside vendor contracted by the U.S.C.C.B., would be in place no later than May 31, 2020, under the proposal accepted by the bishops.

The plan met with widespread support during a 35-minute discussion on the second day of the spring assembly. The full body of bishops voted on three separate measures governing the implementation of the system.

[Don’t miss the latest news from the church and the world. Sign up for our daily newsletter.]

“We want to make sure the metropolitans are in on this, and we can only go as fast as the metropolitans can go on this.”

Anthony Picarello, U.S.C.C.B. associate general secretary, presented the proposal to the assembly at the request of Cardinal Daniel N. DiNardo of Galveston-Houston, Tex., conference president.

Mr. Picarello said the reporting system would fall in line with the requirements of Pope Francis’ “motu proprio”“Vos estis lux mundi” (“You are the light of the world”), issued in May. Among its mandates, the document requires dioceses and eparchies worldwide to establish “one or more public, stable and easily accessible systems for submission of reports.” It set June 1, 2020, as a deadline.

All reports would be funneled through a central receiving hub, which would then be responsible for sending allegations to the appropriate metropolitan, or archbishop, responsible for each diocese in a province and to the papal nunciature in Washington, Mr. Picarello explained. The United States has 32 metropolitans.

The metropolitans will be responsible for reporting any allegation to local law enforcement authorities as the first step toward investigating a claim.

In response to a question from a bishop, Mr. Picarello said reports of alleged abuse or complaints about how cases are handled by a bishop will continue to be taken by individual dioceses and eparchies.

Some dioceses already have reporting systems in place. The May 31 deadline was set to allow those systems and each metropolitan to align procedures to be able to accept the reports from the nationwide hotline, Mr. Picarello said.

Although the deadline for implementation is nearly one year away, Mr. Picarello added, the U.S.C.C.B. hopes the full system can be in place sooner.

“The last thing we want is to be accused of not being transparent of a system we are setting up.”

“I can assure the Executive Committee along with the Administrative Committee, we want this thing done as quickly as possible,” Cardinal DiNardo told the assembly. “But we want to make sure the metropolitans are in on this, and we can only go as fast as the metropolitans can go on this.”

The first vote concerned putting a nationwide reporting system in place; it passed 205-16, with three abstentions.

In the second vote, the bishops agreed that the U.S.C.C.B. executive and administrative committees would develop a more detailed proposal regarding how the system would operate. It passed 200-21, with two abstentions.

Details and cost estimates would be reviewed in September by the bishops’ Administrative Committee, which includes the officers and the chairmen of the various conference committees.

The same committee in November—prior to the bishops’ fall general assembly—would then review scripts and other relevant details after the selection of a vendor. The Executive Committee would continue to oversee implementation of the program.

The final vote—passing 220-4 with 1 abstention—committed the bishops to having the reporting system operational by May 31.

The proposal also calls for the online segment to contain a link that could be posted on any diocesan or eparchial website as well as the U.S.C.C.B. website.

Bishop Robert D. Conlon of Joliet, Ill., said publicizing the phone and online reporting system will be key. “The last thing we want is to be accused of not being transparent of a system we are setting up,” he said.

Cardinal DiNardo said the reporting system as well as follow-up on how well it is working will be subject to review in three years, as called for under “Vos estis lux mundi.”

Pope Francis’ document is a new universal church law that safeguards members from abuse and holds its leaders accountable. It governs complaints against clergy or church leaders regarding the sexual abuse of minors or vulnerable persons.

The Executive Committee presented a proposal for a third-party reporting system to receive complaints against bishops to the Administrative Committee in September. After being accepted, the plan was initially among a series of steps to respond to the ongoing sexual abuse crisis that was to be voted on during the U.S.C.C.B.’s general assembly last fall.

However, those votes were postponed at the request of the Vatican until after Pope Francis convened a meeting of the presidents of bishops’ conferences around the world to discuss a unified response to the crisis.

Oz Jewel
6 days 14 hours ago

Well, what do you know?
By NOT acting in haste and repenting at leisure (as howling jackals were demanding), we have a result which makes a lot of sense and ticks a lot of boxes.

J Jones
6 days 14 hours ago

You do not have to talk to people employed by the RCC who are going to use a script written by the Rcc. All that is going to happen is that these paid-for-and-scripted-by-the RCC will take the information requested by the RCC's script and pass it on to the RCC.

The RCC will then AS NOW decide if they should call the police.

The people on the phone are going to be note-takers at a call center.

They are NOT going to be investigators.

They are not going to follow up on anything.

They are going to type into data fields ONLY the information for which the RCC has created data fields.


Then and only then call these RCC-paid-for and -scripted notetakets who will do NOTHING but take the notes the RCC wants taken. And then we will be back to back RCC business as usual

Jim Spangler
6 days 12 hours ago

I agree, never trust the Bishops office or the Church to report anything. We need to look for any sign of abuse or misuse of finances and report it to the Police, Atty General, any outside source of achieving justice. There is no more room for trust or a moral compass to be found within the Roman Catholic Church!

shivani singh
6 days 3 hours ago

Whats the matters is that i would like to know .

Mister Mckee
5 days 23 hours ago

But we ain't really gonna do anything about it and neither can you!

[Explore America’s in-depth coverage of sexual abuse in the Catholic Church.]


The latest from america

In the four years since Pope Francis released his encyclical “On Care of Our Common Home,” both global and local reporting on the effects of climate change has only gotten more dire.
Jim McDermottJune 18, 2019
Protesters gather on a main road near the Legislative Council on June 16 as they continuing protest against the unpopular extradition bill in Hong Kong. (AP Photo/Kin Cheung)
Hong Kong has been rocked by mass protests against a proposal would allow suspects to be sent for trial in China’s Communist Party-controlled judiciary.
Verna YuJune 18, 2019
Four years later, various Catholic groups are answering the call from “Laudato Si’” as they try to help people close a gap between the spiritual life and ecological awareness.
Basilian Father Thomas Rosica speaks at a Vatican press briefing in 2015. (CNS/Paul Haring)
Rosica has faced allegations of plagiarizing the written work of several authors.