Are robots pro-life? The Vatican investigates.

Pepper, a humanoid robot designed to welcome and take care of visitors and patients, holds the hand of a new born baby next to his mother at AZ Damiaan hospital in Ostend, Belgium, June 16, 2016. (CNS photo/Francois Lenoir, Reuters)

VATICAN CITY (CNS) -- Even though today's modern tools and technologies are hardly human, the Pontifical Academy for Life is zeroing in on the world of robots and machines powered by artificial intelligence.

While the academy's focus is on the protection of human life and dignity, the rapidly shifting and radical capabilities of robotics are having an ever-increasing impact on human lives, people's relationships, communities and creation, said Jesuit Father Carlo Casalone, an academy member and consultant.

Advertisement

The need to reflect on the effects, opportunities and risks posed by artificial intelligence and robotics has led the pro-life academy to launch a special look at this complex field, adding robotics to its list of specialized projects, which already include palliative care, neuroscience, bioethics and human genome editing.

A major workshop on "Robo-ethics: Humans, Machines and Health" will be held at the Vatican Feb. 25-26 as part of this increased study; the workshop will focus on the use of robots and artificial intelligence, specifically in medicine and health care.

A major workshop on "Robo-ethics: Humans, Machines and Health" will be held at the Vatican.

The use of industrial and personal-service robots is on the rise, according to industry reports. They are being used in manufacturing, housekeeping, assisting with surgery and even caring for the elderly. People with reduced mobility can be assisted with brain control technology, which converts brain waves into digital signals that can command or control external devices, such as artificial limbs or machines.

Father Casalone, who studied medicine and worked as a cardiologist before joining the Society of Jesus in 1984, helped organize the workshop. He became a member of the pontifical academy in 2017 and works in its scientific section.

He told Catholic News Service in December that the workshop will bring together ethicists, health care workers and researchers, including Hiroshi Ishiguro, a Japanese robotics engineer who creates humanoid robots and promotes discussion about the essence of being human. His lab has developed the interactive "Actroid," a lifelike humanoid robot that can operate autonomously or be teleoperated and created an uncanny replica of Ishiguro known as the "Geminoid."

Father Casalone said the academy wanted the workshop to include experts like Ishiguro who could explain "what sort of vision" guides their work and so that members could "truly listen to what is going on in today's world and to engage with this historic moment in time."

"We are seeking to be fully aware of what's happening so that we know what is possible" in the rapidly advancing world of "cognitive machines" and to highlight the ethical, social, cultural and economic impact these tools may have.

For example, cheaper automated machine labor may threaten emerging economies, and mineral-rich African nations often see their resources extracted and exported without receiving the benefits in what has become a new "robot divide," Father Casalone said.

Using robots for military applications can be "very dangerous and very deceptive" if nations use such machines to cover up their responsibility and destroy others "behind the scenes," he said. Automated systems also can lead to "a sort of gaming mentality" when soldiers can control weaponry remotely, far away from its effects.

Home automation or "domotics" -- such as security systems or robot vacuum cleaners -- also presents certain risks, he said, if "houses begin to be built in a way that makes them more robot-friendly, more suitable for machines than for humans."

And the use of robots in assisting the elderly or infirm, while it "could be of great help," could also "risk triggering an attitude of delegating" the care of the most fragile and vulnerable in society "as if it were a task to be entrusted to machines" and not to fellow human beings, he said.

Similar problems may "also apply to the natural world," he said, for example, when using robots for farming and livestock "changes our relationship with animals" and nature.

Father Casalone said the answer isn't a stance against technology but "guiding development so that it respects human dignity and the common good as much as possible."

"It is about becoming aware of and agreeing about regulating these radically new possibilities we have before us, which are able to increasingly and more deeply affect living beings and the human body," he said.

The two-day workshop in February will not be proposing specific guidelines, he said, but rather will lay the groundwork for drawing up "some criteria, given what is at play with the emergence of these cognitive systems in our lives."

Throughout history, science and technology have invented or developed new capabilities that have taken the world by surprise and transformed our lives.

The radical and pervasive impact today's new technologies will have on human beings and their relations "demands greater oversight," public discussion and concern not just among experts or special interest groups, but by everyone, he said.

Throughout history, science and technology have invented or developed new capabilities that have taken the world by surprise and "transformed our lives," Father Casalone said. "So, we have to expect something new" will always be around the corner and be ready to respond.

Current controls on "the atomic bomb and its destructive potential," he said, show how human beings are capable of not using every new technology, "which means there are options for guiding development" so that it can better respect human life.

"This, in every case, is what we are committed to," he said.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Tim Donovan
7 months 2 weeks ago

My high school physics teacher, a Marianist brother, told us of his perception that scientific knowledge was neutral. But technology, how scientific knowledge was used, could be either moral of immoral. As a retired Special Education teacher who instructed children with brain damage, the possibility of robots assisting disabled people in their daily lives is appealing. But I don't believe it demonstrates respect for human life if the primary caregivers of vulnerable people weren't other people. Also, the fact that atomic bombs were only used twice in history shows that we can exercise moral control limiting nuclear weapons. But I'm gravely concerned that the use of robots by the military may very well contribute to a sense that killing those considered the enemy isn't a matter of personal responsibility. So, is the use of robots pro-life? I think it depends on how each one is used.

Tim Donovan
7 months 2 weeks ago

My high school physics teacher, a Marianist brother, told us of his perception that scientific knowledge was neutral. But technology, how scientific knowledge was used, could be either moral of immoral. As a retired Special Education teacher who instructed children with brain damage, the possibility of robots assisting disabled people in their daily lives is appealing. AaaaAaaaq

J Cosgrove
7 months 2 weeks ago

Maybe the Vatican will ordain some. That will solve the priest shortage. We could have Jesuit robots and Dominican robots. We could have traditional robot priests and reform robot priests. Brave new world.

Advertisement

The latest from america

Cardinal George Pell's conviction on child sexual abuse charges was upheld by a 2-1 ruling of an Australian court of appeal.
Associated PressAugust 20, 2019
Survivors of Cyclone Idai arrive at an evacuation center on March 21, 2019, in Beira, Mozambique. The African nation is one of three that Pope Francis will visit in September. (CNS photo/Denis Onyodi, Red Cross Red Crescent via Reuters) 
Pope Francis will visit Mozambique, Madagascar and Mauritius in his September trip, writes Vatican correspondent Gerard O'Connell, all former colonies facing development challenges.
Gerard O’ConnellAugust 20, 2019
Bishop J. Mark Spalding of Nashville, Tenn., center, listens to a speaker on the first day of the spring general assembly of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops in Baltimore June 11, 2019. (CNS photo/Bob Roller)
Reacting to the scandal of clergy sex abuse and cover-up 17 years ago, eight bishops offered a bold proposal to convene a regional synod for the church in the United States.
In this Feb. 26, 2019, photo, Cardinal George Pell leaves the County Court in Melbourne, Australia. Pell’s lawyers argued in his appeal that there were more than a dozen “solid obstacles” that should have prevented a jury from finding him guilty beyond a reasonable doubt of molesting two choirboys. The appeal court will give their verdict on Aug. 21. (AP Photo/Andy Brownbill)
Cardinal Pell would walk free if the three judges acquit him of the five convictions.