Nuncio reported McCarrick before he became D.C. archbishop, new book confirms

Former Cardinal Theodore E. McCarrick of Washington, pictured in 2017 (CNS photo/Bob Roller)

This week on “Inside the Vatican,” America’s Vatican news explainer podcast, producer Colleen Dulle and Vatican correspondent Gerard O’Connell cover new developments in the case of former Cardinal Theodore McCarrick.

Advertisement

A new book by two Italian journalists, Andrea Tornielli of Vatican Insider and Gianni Valente of the Congregation for the Evangelization of Peoples, examines the history of reports of abuse by Archbishop McCarrick and confirms, via anonymous Vatican sources, that Archbishop McCarrick’s abuse was reported to the Vatican before he was named Archbishop of Washington, D.C. in 2000.

In this episode, we also discuss which countries might offer asylum to Asia Bibi, the Pakistani Christian woman whose death sentence for blasphemy was recently overturned, though she remains in prison out of fear for her safety.

Last, we talk about what the recent disappearance of four underground Chinese priests will mean for the recent deal between China and the Vatican and the ongoing relationship between them.

Read more:

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Frank T
7 months 2 weeks ago

This would add more credence to the idea that 'saint' John Paul II wasn't bothered enough by the sexual abuse of young seminarians by McCarrick to do anything about it.
It also exposes Vigano's agenda against the Holy Father.
Maybe it is time for Vigano to be sent to Kansas to share accommodations with McCarrick.

Carlos Orozco
7 months 2 weeks ago

A person with the heart of a lion like John Paul II does not coward away from defending the abused. That does not mean he could not have been misled. What appears more than evident is the existence of a decades-old, secret, homosexual organization that has protected and protects abusers. Justice demands thorough investigations on past and present sexual crimes that have been blocked at high levels in the Vatican.

Frank T
7 months 2 weeks ago

Oh I see. The secret cabal of homo-hiders kept old JPII in the dark! Or maybe JPII was a homo-hider too...who cowered.
Either way, you seem to be looking for excuses and rationalizations.

George Trejos
7 months 2 weeks ago

Please stop the effort to put the blame of the sex abuse scandal on individuals with different sexual orientation. The abuse of minor children, whether boys or girls, is 'abhorrent behavior' irrespective of sexual orientation. The behavior and its cover-up has more to do with the hubris of clericalism that seeks to protect itself and the institutional structure that they established to empower themselves. The scandal resided throughout the whole Church and a conspiracy of a 'secret cabal' (borrowed from Frank T's comment) can't explain its wide reach. It was/is a grave problem in leadership! All bishops, including Popes, might do well to reflect on the Shakespearean's words of Cardinal Wolsey: Had I but served my God with half the zeal I served my king (substitute "ego"), he would not in mine age, have left me naked to mine enemies! And still the cover-ups continue.

All of us must work together and force the hands of our bishops to establish a more collaborate approach to leadership and transparency.

sheila gray
7 months 2 weeks ago

Amen

Carlos Orozco
7 months 2 weeks ago

Frank T,

JPII was no coward, just ask the Communists, the abortion or homosexual lobby, the warmongers and war profiteers. According to female friends, he was a man's man and chaste: the complete opposite of a "homo-hider" and their associated deviations.

JPII did misjudge some sexual predators, that led to their promotions. Similar misjudgements have been made by Popes before and after him. You slander the now saint, but do you know what information got to him on every single accusation of sexual abuse? Are there no sexual abusers within the Vatican bureaucracy with an agenda of their own? If JPII was protecting them, why has sexual abuse not been solved 13 years after his death or at least seriously dented? What concrete actions are being taken today to stop the infestation?

sheila gray
7 months 2 weeks ago

If only homosexuality was to blame!!! We would have been out of the woods a long time ago. The Crisis was caused by Secrecy. Pure and simple. Why is this so difficult for people to really face? Any organization 100% dependent on donations for its existence would do everything in its power to keep Abuse secret. Healing is the only rational way forward. I believe deeply that once The Church devotes itself on every level to aid and abet the healing of victims and survivors, then, The Crisis as we know it will be over. Prevention of future abuse is crucial. But no one, as far as I know, has started talking yet about Healing for Survivors, and what that would even look like. If we count all Church-related personnel, including priests and nuns from Religious Orders, I think there could be close to a million victims in the United States in the last 60-70 years. Remember, less than 10% ever tell anyone. We have a huge opportunity here that I think is being missed so far... Healing through Healing. It works.

Mike Houlihan
7 months 2 weeks ago

There was a consistent pattern in John Paul's malfeasance regarding clerical sexual abuse. Against advice he received from various persons in and out of Austria, he insisted on appointing Hans Groer, whose history of abusing seminarians was well known and widely reported, as Archbishop of Vienna and making him a cardinal. Similarly, John Paul honored Marcial Maciel as an "efficacious guide to youth" at a ceremony in Vatican Square even as Maciel's history as an abuser was well known. I can't read John Paul's heart or mind, but one things seems clear: he did not take advice or criticism well.

Alan Martin
7 months 2 weeks ago

This article is actually a nice one it assists new web viewers and people who are wishing to learn blog writing. I have one top recommendation for best writing services for Essay Writing Service UK and Nursing Dissertation help

Alan Martin
7 months 2 weeks ago

This article is actually a nice one it assists new web viewers and people who are wishing to learn blog writing. I have one top recommendation for best writing services for Essay Writing Service UK and Nursing Dissertation help

Alan Martin
7 months 2 weeks ago

This article is actually a nice one it assists new web viewers and people who are wishing to learn blog writing. I have one top recommendation for best writing services for Essay Writing Service UK and Nursing Dissertation help

Mark M
7 months 2 weeks ago

The homosexual predator McCarrick is still, even now, an archbishop in the RCC. Still living comfortably on your dime, faithful pewsitter. The bishop of Rome has no problem with this. Francis will try and wait this out if at all possible. History says so.

Reyanna Rice
7 months 2 weeks ago

Whether you like it or not, justice still applies even in the case if a McCarrick. No court of law, even at the Vatican, can take action based only on someone’s sayso. An investigation is being carried out. And no, Francis is not going to wait it out. He removed McCarrick from the College of Cardinals already. He has also proven he’s not “waiting it out” by removing numerous other bishoos. Note that in this country Flynn and Nienstadt are no longer heads of dioceses.. He’s also removed several bishops in Chile. As far as McCarrick “living comfortably on your dime”, do you suggest just putting an 83 yr old man on the street? Also it’s better to keep him under the control of the church until this is all sorted out. It may well be that Francis may keep him where he is the rest of his life. If he is convicted of abuse of a minor (and I believe the statutes of limitation have run out), it’s doubtful the courts will issue a prison sentence because of his age.

Mark M
7 months 2 weeks ago

The homosexual predator McCarrick is still, even now, an archbishop in the RCC. Still living comfortably on your dime, faithful pewsitter. The bishop of Rome has no problem with this. Francis will try and wait this out if at all possible. History says so.

Michael Houlder
7 months 1 week ago

"A new book ... confirms, via anonymous Vatican sources, that Archbishop McCarrick’s abuse was reported to the Vatican before he was named Archbishop of Washington, D.C. in 2000".
Whether the abuse was reported in 2000 or not, I do not know. But what I do know is that confirmation via anonymous sources, Vatican or otherwise, is not the confirmation of anything at all. I regret greatly that Collen Dulle used the phrase and that the editors allowed the incendiary phrase to be used.

Advertisement

The latest from america

America Media | A Jesuit Ministry
America Media won top awards for best magazine, best website and best podcast.
America StaffJune 24, 2019
Bishop Charles Thompson speaks after he is introduced as the new archbishop of Indianapolis in Indianapolis.
The Midwest Jesuits plan to appeal a decree by Archbishop Thompson of Indianapolis that Brebeuf Jesuit High School is no longer recognized as a Catholic school after the school’s administrators refused to terminate a teacher in a same-sex marriage as requested by the archdiocese.
“You don’t have to regulate your borders with cruelty and inhumanity. There’s no need for that.”
The Sacred Heart is an invitation to ask ourselves, “How did Jesus love?
James Martin, S.J.June 21, 2019