Click here if you don’t see subscription options
Michael J. O’LoughlinOctober 10, 2018
  Pope Francis talks with Cardinal Sean P. O'Malley of Boston, president of the Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors, as they arrive for a meeting in the synod hall at the Vatican in this Feb. 13, 2015, file photo. (CNS photo/Paul Haring) 

Cardinal Sean P. O’Malley wants Vatican officials to read a series of investigative reports chronicling alleged mismanagement in the Diocese of Buffalo, where Bishop Richard Malone, a former auxiliary bishop in Boston, is facing calls to step down over his handling cases of clergy sexual abuse.

An investigative reporter for WKBW, Charlie Specht, sent his three-part series about Bishop Malone to Cardinal O’Malley, who heads the Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors.

Those reports contend that Bishop Malone did not take seriously allegations of impropriety made against two priests and that he allowed them to stay in ministry. The bishop is also accused of not being forthcoming about the number of priests who have been credibly accused of sexual abuse. The diocese initially reported the number to be 42, but it may be higher than 100.

Mr. Specht received a reply to his inquiry from a spokesman for the Archdiocese of Boston, who said the cardinal is “deeply concerned by the absence of recognition of the abuse experienced by the survivors and the responses or absence of response provided to survivors.”

An investigative reporter for WKBW, Charlie Specht, sent his three-part series about Bishop Malone to Cardinal O’Malley, who heads the Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors.

“It is the Cardinal’s assessment that the information in your reports should be reviewed by the Church authorities who have oversight and jurisdiction for the action or inaction of diocesan leadership in Buffalo with regard to the reports of abuse,” Terrence C. Donilon wrote to Mr. Spect, who posted the email on his Twitter account.

“For those reasons, Cardinal O’Malley will send the documentation of your reports” to the apostolic nuncio to the United States, Mr. Donilon wrote.

The Diocese of Buffalo released a statement on Thursday, saying that while Bishop Malone has “the utmost respect” for Cardinal O’Malley and that while he welcomes a review with the nuncio, he takes issue with the content of the television reports. 

“It is unfortunate that Cardinal O’Malley never contacted the Diocese of Buffalo to check on the facts and hear our side of the story,” the statement said. “The television reports provided to the cardinal’s spokesperson misrepresented the truth about how the Diocese of Buffalo did in fact respond to both child and adult victims of clerical misconduct. Every victim who reports abuse, whether abused as a minor or as an adult, is offered a meeting with a bishop.”

While Cardinal O’Malley is perhaps the highest-ranking church official charged with examining how the church handles allegations of sexual abuse, he does not have jurisdiction over other bishops and the commission he leads does not investigate specific claims. Instead, it makes recommendations to Pope Francis about best practices.

The commission’s mandate, and the role of its members, has caused confusion about where specific allegations should be directed, leading critics to say that the church needs more clear reporting structures.

The decision by Cardinal O’Malley to forward the reports to the nuncio appear to correspond to a pledge he made in September, when he announced that any allegations of sexual misconduct sent to his office would be addressed. He made that statement after revelations surfaced that his office in Boston received a letter in 2015 laying out allegations of sexual misconduct between former Cardinal Theodore McCarrick and other adults, three years before the retired archbishop of Washington was removed from ministry because of a separate charge of sexual abuse of a minor. Cardinal O’Malley said he never saw the letter because his secretary responded to it, as it concerned improper conduct between adults.

While Cardinal O’Malley is perhaps the highest-ranking church official charged with examining how the church handles allegations of sexual abuse.

In a Sept. 9 statement, the Archdiocese of Boston said Cardinal O’Malley “will now personally review all letters that come to his office related to the commission or are abuse related, even if they address matters outside his authority. He has made a commitment to refer those requiring attention to the nuncio to the United States and/or the Vatican.”

The sex abuse crisis continues to roil the Diocese of Buffalo, which is expected to be the central focus of an investigation of New York’s dioceses by Attorney General Barbara Underwood’s office. Earlier this month, Bishop Malone presided over a healing service in Buffalo, in which he admitted to making mistakes.

“I'm afraid that our way of handling that too often has been to quietly try to work with those priests and admonish them and maybe, maybe, maybe, they could have some limited ministry. I see now, that is wrong,” he said.

The turmoil in Buffalo comes at a time when dioceses throughout the United States are grappling with historical cases of sexual abuse and cover up. Law enforcement officials in at least eight states have announced they have either launched investigations into Catholic dioceses or intend to. A number of other dioceses, including all 15 in Texas, have said they plan to release complete lists of credibly accused priests on their own.

Cardinal O’Malley and Bishop Malone worked together briefly in Boston. The cardinal was installed as archbishop in July 2003, when Bishop Malone was an auxiliary bishop. Bishop Malone was installed as the bishop of Portland, Maine, in April 2004 and he took over in Buffalo in Aug. 2012.

Update: This story was updated with a response from the Diocese of Buffalo on Oct. 11.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Tom Bavis
5 years 9 months ago

Should they not be sending all the information to law enforcement?
Think about this. Remember the Jay report? Garbage in, garbage out. It's totally bogus, because it was based on statistics from the bishops. It appears they under report. Or as we would say, they lie. I continue to be stunned at the culpability of the bishops involvement in all of this. I'm hoping for a federal RICO investigation. Lock them up. By bad bishops.

John Patrick Riley
5 years 9 months ago

Investigate. Remove. Defrock. Excommunicate. Nothing less will suffice. Malone, Cupich, Tobin, et.al. must go.

J. Calpezzo
5 years 9 months ago

These two words render all Vatican pronouncements irrelevant: Roger Mahony

John Mack
5 years 9 months ago

Yikes! 42 to 100 sexually abusive priests in one diocese.

The latest from america

While theatrical and beautiful, I have come to understand that the Mass is not a show. It is a miracle.
Rebecca Moon RuarkJuly 12, 2024
An image from the new Netflix adaptation of "Avatar: The Last Airbender"
The new Netflix adaptation fails to capture what made the original not only beautiful, but also of great interest for Catholics.
Reed ProctorJuly 12, 2024
“The Godfather Part III” (1990) is the most explicitly Catholic entry in the series.
John DoughertyJuly 12, 2024
From the Newfoundland Quarterly in 1909: “The Orphan Boys at Mount Cashel, St. Johns, who sowed, reaped and threshed 600 bushels of oats this year at Mount Cashel.” (Wikimedia Commons)
A court-empowered third-party insolvency monitor has ordered the Archdiocese of St. John’s to pay over 104 million Canadian dollars (about $76 million) to 292 survivors of Mount Cashel who were victimized behind its walls.
Kevin ClarkeJuly 11, 2024