Why we shouldn’t try to bargain with God

Photo by rawpixel on UnsplashPhoto by rawpixel on Unsplash

In researching El Camino de Santiago de Compostela (known in English as the Way of St. James the Greater), a 500-mile walking pilgrimage across northern Spain that has been calling to me, I came across a reference to plenary indulgences in the Camino’s history. I had almost forgotten about indulgences, as they are foreign to my faith experience.

My grandmother had a thing about “first Fridays.” If you made it to Mass on the first Friday of the month so many times in a row, she said, you were guaranteed a fast-track to heaven. I remember asking her when I was 11 or 12: What if you do all those first Fridays and then murder someone? Do the Fridays override mortal sin? What if you do the first Fridays and don’t even believe in God?

Advertisement

I wasn’t being a brat. This concept of wheeling and dealing with God truly perplexed me. My practical brain could not reconcile an ironclad assurance of the soul’s fate with other, more abstract (and theologically sound) things I was learning at Catholic school.

This concept of wheeling and dealing with God truly perplexed me.

The indulgence granted for completing the Camino is not what calls to me. I am not sure which part of walking 500 miles does sound like a good idea, but I have learned that calls do not always make sense. I also know that my grandmother’s indulgences were a case of good intentions gone awry because I am pretty sure that we cannot bargain with God.

As I write about celestial bargains, I am remembering a moment with my dear departed mother in the neonatal nursery about 25 years ago. My twin nephews had been born two months prematurely. Under three pounds each, they looked like tiny, skeletal monkeys: They were still covered with the downy hair that is no longer present on full-term babies, and they had no meat on their bones. One was more endangered than the other on account of a collapsed lung. He was touch-and-go for a day or two, but then he stabilized.

“Thank God,” I said. No small number of prayers from the whole family had been whispered on behalf of these babies.

When we maneuver to make a deal with God, we are in essence saying that we know better than God.

“Thank God and, confidentially, you can thank me,” my mother said. “I told God I’d go back to church if this baby lived.”

“You can’t make bargains with God,” I said, these still being the days when I used to argue with my parents about theology. I was still sure I could enlighten them with my vast store of Catholic knowledge.

“I just did,” she said. “You believe what you want, but I made a promise. Now I have to go every Sunday so he won’t die.”

My mother eventually stopped going to Mass when her Parkinson’s symptoms got the better of her. If her theory was correct, I guess God let her off the hook because my nephew is still alive.

When we bargain with God, we espouse a God who keeps score, rather than the God who loves us no matter what.

We like to think we can bargain with God. The God of the Old Testament, after all, is quite the dealmaker: “I shall be your God, and you shall be my people” (Lv 26:12) and all that. Or we could take a cue from Abraham, who famously talked God into sparing the thousands of wicked no-accounts in the city of Sodom if there are even 50, no, 45, no wait, 40, or, how about 20, or wait, 20, or, this is the last one I swear, 10 worthy people who are not sinners! Abraham’s stalling tactic actually works with God. Why shouldn’t we try for a similar outcome when we pray?

Prayer is where we come face-to-face with our concept of God. Who is the God we believe in deep in our hearts? When we bargain with God, we espouse a God who keeps score, rather than the God who loves us no matter what, the God who is love, according to the first letter of John (4:8). When we offer to negotiate with God, we presume that we actually have anything that God needs, which is pretty presumptuous on our part. And when we maneuver to make a deal with God, we are in essence saying that we know better than God. Whatever crisis we are facing, we have a desirable outcome in mind, and we are going to bring God around to our way of thinking. Whatever God’s will for us may be, we have a counter-proposal. In fact, we have a list.

I wonder sometimes if my mother thought that the family who lost their baby in that neonatal nursery did not offer God a good enough contract.

My mother has gone to God now, as has my grandmother with her indulgences, and my day will come. I no longer think I am smart enough to make people believe in the God that I think they should. I accept that my own image of God has aged to a divine power more loving, more tender, more expansive, more forgiving, more merciful, more compassionate and more whole than my mind can grasp. I cannot get it, but I believe. On most days, I am at peace with the mystery of faith.

That is why I am going to invest in some sturdy walking shoes, while I work on letting go of my own expectations for God.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Bruce Snowden
3 weeks ago

The Great "I Am Who I Am" in the OT reminds us that, His words and thoughts are not ours, so at prayer if our words and thoughts fail to correspond exactly to God 's, we can pray until we are blue in the face and that prayer will not be heard. Conformity to the Will of God is the only way to pray. remembering that "No." or "Not Now," is as much of an answer as "Yes" or "What's your hurry?" With God whatever is going to happen in human tine has already happened in God time and we can't change the outcome. trusting God as a little child trusts his Father/Mother. In my old age I have finally learned to personally accept this message in peace, as "my hands are too short to box with God!" As the Commercial for LongHorn says, "You can't fake steak!" Don't hand God fake prayer. Give Him the real thing, no bargaining!

Frank Elliott
2 weeks 5 days ago

Certainly Abraham bargained with God to save any virtuous men living in Sodom and Jacob wrestled with the angel. God tell Job off when Job questions God, but can you find any similar example of God telling people not to bargain? Does your religion want people to be unable to reason critically in moral matters? It seems to me that Christ’s endorsement of the Sabbath as “made for Man” indicates that he demanded critical thinking in matters of religious law. Still, he was a jew not a catholic.

Andrew Wolfe
2 weeks 2 days ago

The Abraham example doesn't completely match, because Abraham made no promises to God of a quid-pro-quo if he saved Lot. Abraham was begging, not bargaining.

Stuart Meisenzahl
2 weeks ago

Andrew
The stakes in Abraham's "bargaining" were ALL the residents of Sodum ......if he couldn't find (10 down to 1) a single just person then ALL was lost...he was bargaining on behalf of the City. Bargaining with God is based upon the Judao- Christian recognition of God as The God of History .....one who is not passive but intervenes in the affairs of the world....who responds to prayers...who interacts with His creation.

Bruce Snowden
2 weeks 4 days ago

Hi Mr. Elliott, I'm not a Scripture expert, yet I feel quite certain that Abraham wasn't bargaining with God, applicable to the incident you mentioned, but was searching for clarity as to what God's teasing meant. Those who converse with God not necessarily kneeling in Church but maybe on the way to the Grocery store to pick up a six pack, are often puzzled by God's wordless tease. Maybe later it will come to you, maybe much later, tilling the soil of the heart as trust of God develops, as that's what God's tease is all about - growing in trust. So, likely God was fine tuning Abraham's trust preparing him for the "impossibilities" awaiting him down the road to the Promise Land.

Phillip Stone
2 weeks 3 days ago

We can abuse Him, we can argue with Him, we can question His goodness, tell Him we doubt whether He keeps his word, we can rage against Him for misfortunes and losses and moan to Him in our grief.
"Come to me and I will ..."
"Knock and the door shall ... "
Both Abraham and Moses DID bargain with Him, one achieved their objective and the other had God do a third option, of course we may bargain with Him.
We can be just as much a brat as you were.

Amy Fielder
2 weeks 2 days ago

I agree that God is not a vending machine. In previous times prophets were considered mediators between God and the community, as the community believed God was responsible for disciplining the errant, and that ‘God’s discipline’ was sometimes too severe. People suffer for various reasons, and often because of our neighbors, not because God is a disciplinarian. Although sometimes bad things happen to good people, neither is this God’s fault. At one point in my life, I came to the conclusion that ‘God owed me’ in response to a very big favor that I did on God’s behalf. Later I was surprised that God might have actually delivered on the so-called ‘debt’ to the point where I was now longer certain which one of us is now in debt to the other. Perhaps now I can see our relationship is actually a covenant, and not just a contract.

Will Niermeyer
2 weeks 2 days ago

How so very true. Major reason why I do not believe in these days of obligation for mass and sunday masses. We worship God whenever we come into his presence.

John Hartrich
2 weeks 2 days ago

I believe it's simply our human nature to be a 'quid pro quo' negotiator...sometimes even with God. He must get a good chuckle out of our 'art of the deals'. Thank goodness He's a God of love and compassion!

Advertisement

Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

Lucy Martin and her daughter together with other mothers and their babies attend a House Committee on the Judiciary and House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform hearing, to express their support to immigrants and their families and objection to the forced separation of migrant children from their parents, Washington, June 19 (AP Photo/Manuel Balce Ceneta)
Call your legislators, inform yourself or make a donation.
James Martin, S.J.June 19, 2018
Mourners grieve by the casket of Father Richmond Nilo on June 11 n Zaragoza, Nueva Ecija, Philippines. Photo by Ezra Acayan.
Church and political leaders alike expressed alarm over a growing culture of impunity. President Rodrigo Duterte’s frequent tirades against the Catholic Church in the Philippines are believed to have emboldened killers in the recent attacks against priests.
Nash TysmansJune 19, 2018
“‘What can I do?’ That’s what everyone needs to ask themselves. We can’t be paralyzed. We need to act.”
J.D. Long-GarcíaJune 19, 2018
The Safe Car Wash app has been developed to allow the general public to engage with the problem, it is a new tool that will enable the largest community intelligence gathering exercise ever attempted in the United Kingdom.
Tens of thousands—including children—may be trapped in illegal employment in U.K. construction, hospitality and agriculture sectors, in domestic service, and, sadly, in prostitution.
David StewartJune 19, 2018