The convent film “Novitiate” has moments of beauty but gets lost in cliché

Melissa Leo as the fearsome Reverend Mother Marie St. Claire (Sony Pictures Classics)Melissa Leo as the fearsome Reverend Mother Marie St. Claire (Sony Pictures Classics)

During an early moment in “Novitiate,” a group of breathless and beautiful young girls—the latest group of postulants to the Sisters of Beloved Rose—are exchanging their origin stories. What made them join a religious order? One says that her mother always felt “one child should be sacrificed” to the church; another reveals that several close relatives are sisters, “so I guess it’s in my blood.” But it is Cathleen (Margaret Qualley), the Catholic convert with the purest belief, whose genuine devotion shames all those around her. “I just thought it was the most beautiful idea,” she says, “to be able to spend my entire life devoted to love.”

Oh, the irony. In “Novitiate,” director Maggie Betts’s surface-dwelling exploration of religious vocation and intramural Catholic politics, the order of Beloved Rose is portrayed as many things —a cult, a 12-step program and even, at times, a kind of terrorist organization. But love is not what motivates. “God is my motivation,” says the fearsome Reverend Mother Marie St. Claire (Melissa Leo), who regards herself as a conduit to the Almighty. Love—in the sense of agape, at least—is in short supply in this universe.


In “Novitiate,” the order of Beloved Rose is portrayed as a cult, a 12-step program and even, at times, a kind of terrorist organization.

Set in the early ’60s, “Novitiate” is yet another tale of the trauma suffered by the religious and their orders in the wake of the Second Vatican Council. We are told in a postscript that “the Church witnessed a mass exodus of nuns” following Vatican II and that 90,000 sisters “renounced their vocations and left their convents.” More important, the remaining sisters’ standing among the faithful was changed. In one of the many instances of foreshadowed theological doom scattered throughout Ms. Betts’s screenplay, one postulant says to another, in effect, won’t it be wonderful to know you’re special in the eyes of God? Vatican II will tell them that they are, essentially, not.

The reverend mother knows. She has been getting Vatican II updates from her archbishop (Denis O’Hare) for about three years, but her strategy has been to ignore the whole thing or at least keep it from the youngest of her cloistered underlings. (One older nun, who has apparently gotten wind of what is happening in Rome, appears at mealtime ranting and stark naked except for her wimple; the portents are simply too much for her to bear.) In Marie St. Claire, the stress of what may or may not befall her order manifests itself in her sadistic treatment of her weakest charges—Sister Sissy (Maddie Hasson), for instance, whom she bullies into a floor-crawling exercise in self-abasement. Ms. Leo is well-practiced at the art of playing hard, embittered women, but it is not her fault if the reverend mother still feels like a cliché.

Much feels this way in “Novitiate,” including the shattered girlish joy of the postulants, as they are marched through a process portrayed as soul-crushing and cruel. “Put your hand down,” the reverend mother says to the tender candidates before her. “Postulants don’t have questions. And you are free to go home.” She dismisses several for infractions real and imagined, including a rather predictable skirmish with lesbianism; her formidable nuns arrive during prayer time like ICE agents, ushering out the no-longer-wanted.

Cathleen’s calling, elevated to such a height it eclipses all those around her, seems to arise out of magic or mental illness or childhood trauma.

Cathleen, though the centerpiece of “Novitiate,” is something of a shallow vessel. Her calling, elevated to such a height it eclipses all those around her, seems to arise out of magic or mental illness or childhood trauma. In the opening scenes, her father exits the home in a torrent of violence and vulgarity, and her newly single Mom later accepts the offer of a scholarship at the local parochial school for her daughter. Being treated kindly by nuns is not usually enough to launch a lifetime spiritual vocation, but it is here, and her mother (a very affecting Julianne Nicholson) treats it with this film’s characteristic restraint. (“A nun?! What are you talking about? That’s just ****ing crazy, Cathleen.”) See what happens when you use bad language?

This is a beautiful-looking film, with beautiful-looking people and many moments of directorial acuity. When the youngest sisters are lining up to have their hair cut, for instance, and most look terrified, Cathleen wears a look of joyful anticipation; her fleeting physical contact with Sister Emanuel (Rebecca Dayan)—who, rumor has it, transferred out of the Sisters of Charity because they were not tough enough—are treated both tastefully and tenderly. And there is something lovely about the novitiates in their gowns, preparing to become brides of Christ. Will Cathleen leave Jesus at the altar? No spoilers here, but there is a coyness about “Novitiate” that makes a viewer not care so very much.


Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
H. Thomas Blum
6 months 3 weeks ago

Sounds as if the reviewer has some significant negative biases about Vatican II based on attributing the exodus of nuns from convents on Vatican II.

Henry Smith
6 months 3 weeks ago

Every director/writer has to take a stand, one you may or may not agree with. There are Mother Superiors who seem more sadistic than saintly and there are novices who seem more saintly than sound in mind.

Such is religious life, and secular life but at least there, save in
boot camp and freshman dorms, you can get away from those whose
peccadillos you find neither adorable or mystical.

Why did so many religious leave after Vatican II - a question well worth

Michaelangelo Allocca
6 months 2 weeks ago

"And there is something lovely about the novitiates in their gowns" -- REALLY??? I've given up on the chance that I'll ever again see a tv show or popular movie that knows the difference between a novice and a novitiate, but ... you're a columnist for AMERICA magazine!!! And more to the point: does America not have copy editors that could have caught that?

Jay Kay
6 months 2 weeks ago

I wouldn't be too quick to dismiss this based on the description I see here. There are a great many women who entered religious life, left and have given amazingly similar descriptions since--so similar it's really impossible to chalk them up to stereotype or the effect of disappointment. It's not only that I've read some of these accounts. I've talked to some of these women. This kind of thing was real.
I haven't seen the movie yet, but based on the description, it does not sound far off of some of the descriptions I've heard.


Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. with The University of Notre Dame President Rev. Theodore M. Hesburgh, C.S.C., Rev. Edgar Chandler (far left), and Msgr. Robert J. Hagarty of Chicago (far right) at the Illinois Rally for Civil Rights in Chicago's Soldier Field, 1964. (The University of Notre Dame Archives)
Every individual, organization, institution and structure in the church must do something to counter the intensification of the racial divide in our country.
Edward K. BraxtonMay 24, 2018
An official wedding photo of Britain's Prince Harry and Meghan Markle, center, in Windsor Castle, Windsor, England. Others in photo from left, back row, Jasper Dyer, Camilla, Duchess of Cornwall, Prince Charles, Doria Ragland, Prince William; center row, Brian Mulroney, Prince Philip, Queen Elizabeth II, Kate, Duchess of Cambridge, Princess Charlotte, Prince George, Rylan Litt, John Mulroney; front row, Ivy Mulroney, Florence van Cutsem, Zalie Warren, Remi Litt. (Alexi Lubomirski/Kensington Palace via AP)
A poll found that 66 percent of the British public declared they were not interested in the Windsor wedding.
David StewartMay 23, 2018
God simply is a triad of love: a going out in love, a return in love and thus, ever more, love itself.
Terrance KleinMay 23, 2018
The leaders sent a letter to President Donald Trump, administration officials and members of Congress.