Matt Malone, S.J.September 17, 2020
Joe Biden and President Trump (AP Photo/Brennan Linsley/CNS photo/Jonathan Ernst, Reuters)

Join Matt Malone, S.J., the editor in chief of America magazine, for a conversation in the comments section on Friday, Sept. 18, from 1 to 2 p.m. ET, about the magazine’s coverage of this historic election.

On Sept. 16, America published an editorial in which the editorial board registered an unprecedented warning about the threat posed by President Trump to the U.S. Constitution. “In ordinary times, [the] debate about Catholics and presidential candidates can be a healthy and spirited exchange about how Catholics should approach their civic duties in light of their deeply held beliefs,” the editors wrote. “But this is no ordinary time.”

As the president and editor in chief of America Media, I did not take this editorial decision lightly. Historically, America’s editorial approach to elections has been to focus on the issues instead of the candidates. The editorial’s title in the print edition, “No Ordinary Time,” reflects our view that the vital issue of the country’s constitutional order required a different approach in 2020.

[America magazine: Donald Trump is a unique threat to the Constitution]

I should add that this editorial is the opinion of America’s editorial board, but it is not the only opinion you will find at America. We are committed to hosting a conversation and debate that includes a variety of viewpoints. You will find other, different arguments for Mr. Biden here. And you will find arguments in favor of Mr. Trump. And we want to hear your views as well.

I invite you to share your questions about the editorial and America’s approach to covering this historic election in the comments section below. I will respond to as many of them as time allows. To get the conversation started, I have provided answers to some questions I’ve been asked since we published the editorial.


1. Who authored this editorial?

The editorial board of America Media is a group of Jesuits and laypeople who author the corporate opinions of America Media. As with all editorials in newspapers and magazines, it is unsigned.

2. Have the Jesuits said this?

No. This editorial is the view of America Media. While America Media is sponsored by the Society of Jesus, America Media does not speak on behalf of the Society of Jesus or for any other Jesuit-sponsored institution. The editor in chief, in collaboration with the editorial board, is ultimately responsible for all of America Media’s content.

3. Is this editorial an endorsement of Joe Biden?

The editorial is an endorsement of the Constitutional order established by our founders and developed over the course of the nation’s history. The actions of Mr. Trump represent an unprecedented threat to that order and the editors believe that this threat must be foremost in our minds when deciding how to vote.

4. Has America Media done anything like this before?

America’s approach is to address the issues instead of the candidates. In this unique moment in the country’s history, however, the critical issue treated in the editorial is inseparable from the character and actions of the sitting president.

5. Shouldn’t priests and religious stay out of politics?

The editorial board of America Media is composed of Jesuits and laypeople. The majority of its members are laypeople. The mission of America Media is to provide commentary about the pressing issues at the intersection of the church and the world. We have been providing commentary on church and public affairs for 112 years. It’s our job to have an opinion and to host yours.

The latest from america

Eric Krewson of The Chairman Dances (photo courtesy of Eric Krewson)
Eric Krewson and the band he headlines, The Chairman Dances, wrote a song that celebrates the friendship of Dorothy Day and Peter Maurin. And that song will shortly be on its way to the Vatican.
Renée Darline RodenNovember 29, 2021
Composer and lyricist Stephen Sondheim gestures during a gathering at Tufts University in Medford, Mass., on April 12, 2004. Sondheim, the songwriter who reshaped the American musical theater in the second half of the 20th century, has died at age 91. (AP Photo/Charles Krupa, File)
Sondheim’s stories and lyrics always seemed to be addressing you personally. You couldn’t simply watch his musicals. Eventually you had to contend with them.
Jim McDermottNovember 29, 2021
Phil Saviano, a clergy sex abuse survivor and whistleblower who played a pivotal role in exposing decades of predatory assaults by Roman Catholic priests in the United States, has died.