Victims of clergy abuse to sue Vatican, seek abusers’ names

 In this Oct. 4, 2018, file photo, Attorney Jeff Anderson, left, accompanied by Manuel Vega, who says he was sexually abused by a priest, describes Vega's lawsuit against the Vatican at a news conference in Los Angeles. Several people, including Vega, are planning to sue the Vatican on Tuesday, May 14, 2019, and are demanding to know the names of thousands of predator priests they claim have been kept secret by the Holy See, according to Anderson. (AP Photo/Reed Saxon, File)

MINNEAPOLIS (AP) — Five men who say they were sexually abused by Roman Catholic priests when they were minors are planning to sue the Vatican and are demanding the names of thousands of predator priests they claim have been kept secret by the Holy See.

In a Monday news release announcing the lawsuit, Minnesota attorney Jeff Anderson said he wants to show that the Vatican tried to cover up actions by top church officials including former St. Paul-Minneapolis Archbishop John Nienstedt. The lawsuit being filed Tuesday seeks the release of 3,400 names of priests who were referred to the Vatican for "credible cases of abuse." That number was released by the Vatican in 2014.

Advertisement

The lawsuit comes less than a week after Pope Francis issued a groundbreaking new church law requiring all Catholic priests and nuns worldwide to report clergy sexual abuse and cover-ups by their superiors to church authorities. The law is part of a new effort to hold the Catholic hierarchy accountable.

But the new law stops short of requiring the crimes to be reported to police, and abuse victims and their advocates say it's not enough since it essentially tasks discredited bishops who have mishandled abuse for decades with policing their own.

[Don’t miss the latest news from the church and the world. Sign up for our daily newsletter.]

The plaintiffs in the new lawsuit include three brothers who were abused by former priest Curtis Wehmeyer as recently as 2012 in St. Paul, Minnesota. Wehmeyer pleaded guilty to criminal sexual conduct and child pornography in connection with his contact with two of the boys, who were 12 and 14. The brothers are not named in the press release.

Internal church documents show that church leaders knew Wehmeyer had engaged in sexual misconduct when they promoted him in 2009. The behavior included at least two occasions when Wehmeyer solicited men for sex. Yet, church leaders did not warn Wehmeyer's parishioners about his past, and a July 2014 church memo raised concerns that Nienstedt's "social relationship" with Wehmeyer had clouded his judgment.

Wehmeyer's arrest led prosecutors to file criminal charges against the Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis for failing to protect children. It also led to the resignation of Nienstedt, who came under fire for his handling of Wehmeyer's case at a time when his own sexual behavior was under scrutiny. Nienstedt was investigated following credible allegations that he engaged in misconduct and harassment, then retaliated when his advances were rejected. Nienstedt has denied the allegations, calling them "entirely false."

[Want to discuss politics with other America readers? Join our Facebook discussion group, moderated by America’s writers and editors.]

His successor, Archbishop Bernard Hebda, said last December that the Vatican suspended the investigation when Nienstedt resigned in 2015. And while Nienstedt remains in good standing with the Vatican, Hebda has forbidden him from exercising public ministry in his archdiocese.

Messages left with the Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis and the papal nuncio in Washington, D.C. were not returned Monday. An email sent to Nienstedt went unanswered.

The other plaintiffs are, Manuel Vega, a California man who says he was abused by a priest in Los Angeles, and James Keenan, who says he was sexually abused by a priest in Minnesota.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
THOMAS E BRANDLIN, MNA
3 months ago

Clean them all out! Start with the Pope. Why is Archbishop Nienstedt still in good standing with the Vatican? Further proof, as if we don't already have an abundance of proof, that the Pope and bishops are unwilling, and therefore incapable, of dealing with the problem. And, yet, they freely pay-out the money the People of God give to the Church for the salvation of souls - another injustice to the People of God.

THOMAS E BRANDLIN, MNA
3 months ago

Clean them all out! Start with the Pope. Why is Archbishop Nienstedt still in good standing with the Vatican? Further proof, as if we don't already have an abundance of proof, that the Pope and bishops are unwilling, and therefore incapable, of dealing with the problem. And, yet, they freely pay-out the money the People of God give to the Church for the salvation of souls - another injustice to the People of God.

THOMAS E BRANDLIN, MNA
3 months ago

Clean them all out! Start with the Pope. Why is Archbishop Nienstedt still in good standing with the Vatican? Further proof, as if we don't already have an abundance of proof, that the Pope and bishops are unwilling, and therefore incapable, of dealing with the problem. And, yet, they freely pay-out the money the People of God give to the Church for the salvation of souls - another injustice to the People of God.

THOMAS E BRANDLIN, MNA
3 months ago

Clean them all out! Start with the Pope. Why is Archbishop Nienstedt still in good standing with the Vatican? Further proof, as if we don't already have an abundance of proof, that the Pope and bishops are unwilling, and therefore incapable, of dealing with the problem. And, yet, they freely pay-out the money the People of God give to the Church for the salvation of souls - another injustice to the People of God.

THOMAS E BRANDLIN, MNA
3 months ago

Clean them all out! Start with the Pope. Why is Archbishop Nienstedt still in good standing with the Vatican? Further proof, as if we don't already have an abundance of proof, that the Pope and bishops are unwilling, and therefore incapable, of dealing with the problem. And, yet, they freely pay-out the money the People of God give to the Church for the salvation of souls - another injustice to the People of God.

THOMAS E BRANDLIN, MNA
3 months ago

Why does my comment appear five times?

Mister Mckee
3 months ago

The RICO class action lawsuit against the USCCB seems more realistic in terms of actual jurisprudence. All 80 pages here:
https://bloximages.chicago2.vip.townnews.com/tribdem.com/content/tncms/assets/v3/editorial/5/47/547fa2d4-e7b5-11e8-8acc-aba3ca0fa959/5beb8928f2054.pdf.pdf

Javier von Sydow
3 months ago

The article surprises me for the lack of comprehensive analysis, especially the legal analysis necessary for these kind of complaints, such as the fact that according to the article the complaint has not yet been filed and a discussion on the issues of jurisdiction and standing among others. More importantly is that misstatement of the recent directives given by the Vatican pertaining to reporting to local law enforcement. The Vatican can only publish directives that apply to people that fall within its jurisdiction and has no jurisdiction whatsoever on the different local communities, to which however it directs its members to comply with local law. Reporting a misstatement in the article is appalling for being a Catholic publication. Justice means to give to each his/her own; loop sided accounts do not constitute Justice and our God is one that loves Right and Justice.

[Explore America’s in-depth coverage of sexual abuse in the Catholic Church.]

Advertisement

The latest from america

‘Blinded by the Light’ captures the angst and joy of being a teenager.
Kerry WeberAugust 16, 2019
(iStock/mediaphotos)
A bill to restore Pell grants for those in prison would be an investment in human capital, writes Raymond Moylan, but more importantly it honors the principles of Catholic social teaching and strikes a blow against “throwaway culture.”
Raymond MoylanAugust 16, 2019
A man walks past a memorial on Aug. 7, 2019, for those killed in a mass shooting in Dayton, Ohio, four days earlier. Three U.S. bishops' committee chairmen issued a statement Aug. 8 to call on the nation's elected officials "to exert leadership in seeking to heal the wounds" of the country caused by the Aug. 3 and 4 mass shootings and urged an end to hateful rhetoric many see as a factor in the violence particularly in Texas. The Aug. 3 shooting in El Paso, Texas, was followed less than 24 hours later by th
Unlike other nations that prohibit or narrowly restrict ownership of high-body-count weaponry and ammunition, the United States is hindered in establishing effective gun control by federal and state constitutional roadblocks. Understanding these roadblocks is essential to devising a route around
Ellen K. BoegelAugust 16, 2019
“Yo Soy Taino” is a new live-action puppet film by the screenwriter and director Alba Enid García (photo: HBO).
“Yo Soy Taino” offers a brief and necessary look into the complicated history between the United States and Puerto Rico.
Olga SeguraAugust 16, 2019