Trump’s border wall ignores the realities of migration

  Religious and community activists gather in Nogales, Ariz., Nov. 12 to remember migrants who have died trying to cross the U.S.-Mexico border. (CNS photo/Jim West)

Since the beginning of his 2016 presidential campaign, Donald J. Trump has promised to build a wall along the U.S.-Mexico border. More recently, he has ordered 4,000 members of the National Guard to police the border. But these policies fail to address the fundamental reasons that people migrate. People continue to come seeking a more dignified life for themselves and their families.

Last year, the Kino Border Initiative, a binational migrant ministry in Nogales, Ariz., and Nogales in the Mexican state of Sonora, surveyed 7,756 migrants at our outreach center on the Mexican side of the border; 85 percent said that they migrated due to economic need. One woman from Central Mexico stated that she faced the choice of paying her rent or feeding her grandchildren. This reality drove her north to find a way to support her family.


These policies fail to address the fundamental reasons that people migrate. People continue to come seeking a more dignified life for themselves and their families.

At the same time, since the beginning of the Trump administration, the deportation of people already living in the United States has increased. K.B.I. survey data indicates that 35 percent of those deported to Nogales last year had been living in the United States for some time (as opposed to having recently crossed the border), up from 22 percent in 2016. One deported migrant could barely put into words the pain he was experiencing because of his separation from his wife and child in Arizona. He worries deeply about their ability to sustain themselves without him present. Motivated by love and with no legal path available to him, he is determined to cross back into the United States and to be reunited with his family.

Additionally, migrants continue to flee for their lives, especially from Honduras, El Salvador and Guatemala. The recent caravan of migrants from Central America coming north through Mexico is a microcosm of a much larger group forced to leave their countries due to endemic violence. A human rights advocacy group, the Washington Office on Latin America, confirmed in January that El Salvador, Guatemala and Honduras remain among the most violent countries in the world, with impunity rates for homicide at 95 percent. Migrants leave these countries in response to gang threats against their lives and horrific murders committed against their loved ones. In recent years, they have increasingly sought asylum not only in the United States but in countries like Mexico and Costa Rica as well.

Pushed by economic need, family separation and horrible violence, people make the difficult decision to risk their lives by coming to the United States. President Trump’s determination to build a wall, to send the National Guard to the border and to separate children from families at the border does not consider the complex realities that force people to migrate north. The United States would be better served by policies that address the root causes of migration while respecting human dignity.

In his 2018 letter to migrants and refugees, Pope Francis called for “welcoming, protecting, promoting and integrating” those forced to travel to new countries and encouraged direct encounters with migrants, which are mutually transformative. One student on an “immersion experience” offered by the Kino Border Initiative wrote later about his initial skepticism and resistance to coming to the border. But after speaking with deported migrants in Nogales and walking in the southern Arizona desert and finding items that migrants had left behind, he wrote that he began to recognize, cherish and value their humanity more deeply—to such a degree that he went home determined to volunteer with immigrants in his own community and to do what he could to make a difference to help them.

In his book Immigration and the Next America, Archbishop Jose H. Gomez of Los Angeles writes: “Immigration is about more than immigration. It’s about renewing the soul of America.” If we can respond more effectively to the fundamental reasons people migrate while respecting human rights, we will be on the path to renewing our own souls, both individually and as a country.

[Sign up for Convivir, a new newsletter from America Media. Each week, it will highlight news, culture and trends related to Latino Catholics. To receive this important expert analysis in your inbox, sign up here.]

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
J Cosgrove
5 months 1 week ago

What is it about Catholic countries that they impoverish their people so that they want to flee? Catholic countries have some of the highest homicide rates in the world.

But all we hear is that the Catholic Church wants to impose their system of Catholic social teaching on all of us. Maybe the Church should keep out of politics except to push for freedom of the people. They should stick mainly to salvation and not try to find a heaven on earth. Ironic but an emphasis on freedom will lead to better lives on earth but yet the Church fights against it.

Dionys Murphy
5 months 1 week ago

"What is it about Catholic countries that they impoverish their people so that they want to flee? Catholic countries have some of the highest homicide rates in the world." -- What is it about Catholicism that embraces the poor, marginalized and persecuted? Oh. The example of Christ. You should wonder more, perhaps (though I know it's hard as you are a Russian troll), what it is about Catholic countries that invites US Intervention that ultimately ends in failed states.

"Ironic but an emphasis on freedom will lead to better lives on earth but yet the Church fights against it." Your version of "freedom" is unfettered capitalism, which is simply slavery with a facade of big screen televisions.

J Cosgrove
5 months 1 week ago

(though I know it's hard as you are a Russian troll)

I told you I was an Irish/Swedish Jesuit/Christian Brothers/Servants of the Immaculate Heart of Mary trained troll.

I thank you. Again you make my case for me.

Stuart Meisenzahl
5 months 1 week ago

Mr Murphy
It's odd but it is your own comments that always seem fit squarely within the methods of trolls...stirring controversy over ethnic and economic differences...... you seem to haunt these pages to find Cosgrove as a foil for this purpose. You might give it a rest....simply shouting "troll" when you are at a loss for an argument or a reasoned observation is tiresome and certainly not enlightening.

John Corcoran
5 months ago

J. Cosgrove. Are you part of the Universal Catholic Church or just an American one?

Stanley Kopacz
5 months 1 week ago

Walls are a thirteenth century technology. They didn't work too well in the thirteenth century either. Idiocy for idiots.

J Cosgrove
5 months 1 week ago

Are the Israelis idiots?

Stanley Kopacz
5 months ago

Doesn't stop those rockets very well. A border wall won't stop illegal immigration. If I wanted to make an illegal extra buck, I know how to ferry them over. There's this thing they invented in 1903 called heavier than air flight. It comes in all kinds of shapes and sizes now.


The latest from america

 Ethiopian Cardinal Berhaneyesus Souraphiel of Addis Ababa checks out the name badge of Nathanael Lamataki, a youth delegate from the French territory of New Caledonia in the South Pacific, as they leave a session of the Synod of Bishops on young people, the faith and vocational discernment at the Vatican Oct. 5. (CNS photo/Paul Haring)
Cardinal Souraphiel highlighted the role globalization plays in connecting young people in unjust ways.
Michael J. O’LoughlinOctober 18, 2018
The pope said he would visit North Korea “if an official invitation arrives.”
Gerard O’ConnellOctober 18, 2018
Father John I. Jenkins, president of the University of Notre Dame in Indiana, comforts a woman while distributing Communion during Mass on Oct. 15 with the Colectivo Solecito near Veracruz, Mexico. (CNS photo/Matt Cashore, University of Notre Dame)
The women seeking justice for vanished loved ones in Veracruz, Mexico, won the Notre Dame award for human rights. University President John I. Jenkins co-celebrated a Mass near the unmarked graves of drug war victims.
Jan-Albert HootsenOctober 18, 2018
Salvadorans widely celebrated St. Romero as the Central American country's first saint. St. Romero was assassinated while celebrating Mass in March 1980 and remains a reviled figure for some on the political right.