The Letters

Deep Resentment

Re “The Perversion of Patriotism” (Editorial, 11/13): The true patriot is the one who is willing to put his or her life on the line for the principles upon which this country claims to stand. As a veteran who has done that, I deeply resent being used by worthless politicians whose only loyalty is to their own best interests.

Jack Chase
Online Comment


Too Much Idolatry

Thank you for publishing this timely and thoughtful piece. There has been too much idolatry and, one might add, self-serving nationalism, connected with these issues. The abuses to which the protests sought to draw attention never mustered as much passion as those who rail against the protests themselves.

Michael Pare
Online Comment

Up to the Bishops

Re “Family Counseling,” by Thomas Reese, S.J. (11/13): It is up to the bishops to implement “Amoris Laetitia” and educate the laity about this pastoral teaching. It is up to moral theologians to “develop” moral theology in light of the teaching of “Amoris Laetitia.”

Michael Barberi
Online Comment

Missing the Point

Re “Path of Duty,” by Catherine Addington (11/13): The online title of this article (“The Life of Catholic Foundress Cornelia Connelly Was Ruled by Men. Was Her Obedience to Them Holy?”) misses the point of Cornelia Connelly’s life. Her primary obedience was to God. If “ruled” by anyone, it was by the God she so dearly loved.

Ms. Connelly’s submission to men was by no means total. She defied her family to marry Pierce Connelly. She did conform to 19th-century ideals during the early years of her marriage; but after her conversion, her independent spirit gradually reasserted itself. As the founder of the Society of the Holy Child Jesus, she was often in conflict with clerics over her vision of religious life and of education. Cardinal Wiseman called her “bold” and “ungovernable.”

An eminently practical woman, she submitted when she believed that obedience was the best option to fulfill her mission or when she had no other choice. The context of her life is important. She had no legal rights over her children or her money; as a founder of a new religious order, she was under the authority of the local bishop and dependent on his sponsorship to finance and staff her fledgling ministry.

Her life would indeed be “pitiful” if blind obedience were the only hallmark. Instead, she worked tirelessly for what she saw as her mission from God with zeal, imagination and love—despite the many obstacles she faced.

Judith A. Talvacchia
Associate, Society of the Holy Child Jesus
Rosemont, Pa.

Complexity and Sophistication

Re “Voting for Trump, Loving Pope Francis,” by Jim McDermott, S.J. (11/13): Father McDermott's article avoided the clichés and caricatures produced by the left and the right. His profile of Trump supporters adds a much needed layer of complexity and sophistication to the portrait of Catholics who voted for him. We need more journalism like this from the mainstream media. Good work.

Gene Roman
Online Comment

My Neighbor

Re “Ten Ways Hispanics Are Redefining American Catholicism,” by Hosffman Ospino (11/13): This is so true. I am a white Catholic who began to be exposed to Guadalupe several years ago and have developed a special devotion since. I have also become terribly concerned about immigration issues and have begun to become active on this front, because these are the very people sitting next to me. My “neighbor” indeed!

Jennifer Rebecca Tomshack
Online Comment

Unfortunate Tone

Thanks for the continued coverage on immigrants and the Latino population with this interesting article. I agree that dialogue is a critical step in building a relationship. Unfortunately, the tone Mr. Ospino uses makes it seem as if the best way to make “us” feel less apprehensive about “them” (meaning foreign folks) is to engage in dialogue—yet he does not clearly lay out factors that contribute to the situation, such as class and race. Using words like invade doesn’t help. I hope Mr. Ospino would come to realize that this type of language reinforces negative attitudes about immigrants as invading hordes who must now be tolerated to be better understood.

Rudy Lopez
Online Comment

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
2 years ago

Re: Robert Shrum's book review of "What Happened". Was this a book review or an editorial? Why does everything need to be written from a person's political point of view? This was supposed to be a book review not a political commentary on the story itself. Was the book written well? Is the prose understandable and engaging? Will the reader have a better understanding of events through the perspective of the author?
Instead of focusing on the book Mr. Shrum focused on the election and it's outcome and his opinion of it instead of focusing on the prose Mrs. Clinton wrote describing her journey during the election. America magazine is supposed to be the Jesuit review of faith and culture. Yes, politics are a part of our culture but obvious political views should only be found in the editorial section. We need to focus more on objective reporting and leave our political preferences on the editorial pages. So much of our communication today, inside and outside the Church, is immersed in political references and innuendo. Can we lose the need to express our opinion with every keystroke? Must all of creation be categorized as right or left, blue or red? As men and women of faith we are succumbing to the same cultural influences as our secular brothers and sisters are. Is this the new "Signs of the Times"? Maybe America should reflect on how it is participating in the increasing polarization of our culture.
Deacon Steven Dove
Boynton Beach, Florida

Tim Schlax
2 years ago

Thank you for courageously addressing this daily conflict in our lives: how could our family and friends vote for this man for President? (Voting for Trump, Loving Pope Francis, November 13). It was intelligent, patient, and sincere in presenting the twists and turns required to justify, and minister to, his supporters. No one could have done better. Good try.

Tim Schlax

More: Letters

The latest from america

Theater critic Jose Solís surveys several productions of the holiday classic
Jose SolísDecember 06, 2019
Adrienne Warren and the cast of “Tina” (photo: Manuel Harlan)
The fall season has given us three wildly different case studies in Broadway’s pop/rock hybrids.
Rob Weinert-KendtDecember 06, 2019
The story of Catholics and the AIDS epidemic in the United States is often told as one of “gays versus the church.” But the reality was much more complicated.
JesuiticalDecember 06, 2019
Join us as we offer daily scripture reflections for the entire Advent season.
Elizabeth Kirkland CahillDecember 06, 2019