Click here if you don’t see subscription options
Guy AlalufNovember 29, 2023
A girl lights a candle, as people gather for a vigil in Tel Aviv, Israel, Nov. 7, 2023, to mark the one-month anniversary of the deadly attack by Palestinian Islamist group Hamas on Israel. (OSV News photo/Evelyn Hockstein, Reuters)

Recently, we have been hearing Israeli and diaspora Jewish voices expressing disappointment at the Catholic Church’s reaction to the terrorist attacks of Oct. 7. The claim is that the pope has not sufficiently condemned the crimes of Hamas and, furthermore, that he has created a symmetry between Hamas and Israel in his comments. If that were not enough, apart from the pope, the church officials charged with dialogue with the Jewish people—first and foremost among them Cardinal Kurt Koch, head of the church’s Commission for Religious Relations with the Jews— have chosen thunderous silence, not responding at all to the horrific events that took place in Israel. The Jewish expectation was that as the fruit of the blessed process of dialogue between the Catholic Church and the Jewish people, the church and its leader would stand by our side in our fight against the terrorism of Hamas.

It is not my interest here to enter into a debate with the criticism that is being leveled, and there might or might not be some truth in it. Rather, I seek to present the issue within a broader context, that of interreligious dialogue between the Catholic Church and the Jewish people.

Interreligious dialogue, by its very nature, is expressed through formal institutions, whether they be those of the Jewish rabbinic establishment or those of the church. At the same time, precisely because the dialogue is developing in positive ways, it inevitably breaks through the formal frameworks that have been established and is practiced in the best possible way—through people rather than through institutions, and through those who do not need an official role in the dialogue in order to talk to one another. In other words, the most successful interfaith dialogue takes place between religious leaders who desire to talk to one another, rather than between those who are formally obligated to talk to one another.

The most successful interfaith dialogue takes place between religious leaders who desire to talk to one another, rather than between those who are formally obligated to talk to one another.

When we began to realize the extent of the horrors of Oct. 7, many of my Catholic friends contacted me immediately because of their deep concern. This concern was personal and human, and my friends also expressed genuine anguish for the Jewish people because of the tremendous crisis it was experiencing. Such concern, bursting from the heart, is dearer to me than a thousand official letters from senior bureaucrats in the church. On the night of Oct. 7, I discovered that my friends in the Catholic Church do not simply engage in diplomatic relations with me. Rather, they are truly my friends and friends of the Jewish people.

One good example of the kind of friendship I am referring to was provided by Cardinal Pierbattista Pizzaballa, the Latin patriarch of Jerusalem. He expressed himself in an exceptional way on Oct. 16, when he offered himself in return for the Israelis who had been kidnapped: “I am ready for an exchange, anything, if this can lead to freedom, to bring the children home. No problem. There is total willingness on my part.”

It was completely evident that his words were sincere, and the sorrow he expressed was completely authentic. In all of Cardinal Pizzaballa’s statements, even those in which he expressed his deep concern for the residents of Gaza and criticized the practices of the State of Israel (perfectly logical considering that he is the patriarch first and foremost of his Palestinian flock), he continued to harshly condemn the criminal acts of Hamas on Oct. 7 and to reiterate the position of the pope, calling for the immediate release of those kidnapped.

Friendship allows for seeing things differently and not letting that difference threaten the depth of a bond that is religious, theological and spiritual.

When Israelis and Jews from the diaspora ask the Catholic Church to publicly condemn the actions of Hamas and to support the State of Israel, they are not asking for an improved and deeper friendship. Rather, they are asking the church to engage in political and diplomatic actions. This demand indicates formality and distance between Jews and Catholics rather than friendship and intimacy.

However, I believe that it is precisely the authentic and spontaneous gestures of friendship, those that are public and those that are not, that testify to the intimacy of a friendship that has taken root in the past decades and that cannot be put into question every time we see things differently politically and diplomatically. Political alliances demand a strategic uniformity of vision, whereas friendship allows for seeing things differently and not letting that difference threaten the depth of a bond that is religious, theological and spiritual.

We must not forget that relations between the Catholic Church and the Jewish people constitute a long and winding road in a history that stretches back nearly two thousand years. This shared history too often has seen dark days, but now, I would dare to claim, it is seeing its best days. We must be very careful not to reduce our relations with one another to politics or diplomacy, even when what is at stake are events that have broad impact on the entire Jewish people. To negotiate positions on these events, we have politicians and diplomats, those of Israel and those of the Vatican. Interreligious dialogue, on the other hand, must strive to ever go deeper, to become more and more intimate and authentic, so that it can thrive over and beyond all political considerations, however important they may be.

The latest from america

A trend toward goods and components made by unionized American workers may mean higher prices for consumers. In photo: United Auto Workers members attend a rally in Detroit on Sept. 15, 2023. (AP Photo/Paul Sancya, File)
Geopolitical crises and the aftereffects of Covid are prompting the United States and other nations to find alternatives to globalization in education, trade and environmental protection.
Paul D. McNelis, S.J.February 26, 2024
“Americans should be against killing Israelis but also against killing Palestinians,” the political activist Mustafa Barghouti said in an interview with Gerard O’Connell.
Gerard O’ConnellFebruary 26, 2024
Pope Francis has canceled his appointments today after The Vatican press office announced he was experiencing “mild flu-like symptoms.”
Deacon Steve Kramer preaches on the First Scrutiny for the Third Sunday in Lent, Year A, and reflects on how four summers shuttling people around gave him a crash-course in listening skills key to his development as a preacher.
PreachFebruary 26, 2024