Review: In ‘Midsommar,’ evil doesn’t strike in the shadows

Florence Pugh and Vilhelm Blomgren in "Midsommar" ; Photo by Gabor Kotschy/A24

In Ari Aster’s “Midsommar,” the devil is not an ugly monster hiding in the shadows—he is in the daylight, dressed in a white robe and a crown of flowers.

The film takes place at a traditional festival of the summer solstice in the fictional commune of Hårga in Hälsingland, Sweden. Our protagonist, Dani (Florence Pugh), still grieving from a family tragedy, decides to tag along on what is meant to be an all-guys trip with her boyfriend, Christian (Jack Reynor), and his friends, all of whom are working on their theses.

Advertisement

Their arrival in Sweden starts with dancing, feasting and psychedelic mushrooms, but it gradually turns into a really, really bad trip—pun intended.

The film’s two-hour, 27-minute runtime draws out the horror to an agonizing length, much like the days in midsummer Sweden.

Upon their arrival, it seems like the festival will be exactly as Christian’s friend and Hårga native Pelle (Vilhelm Blomgren) describes, just “special ceremonies and dressing up.” Everyone wears white floral clothes, the gang is offered weird food and drink, and the elders lead the village in traditional chants and feasts. There are a few unexplained things here and there—Pelle makes a comment that seems to imply no one among the Hårga lives past 72, and the community is strangely nonchalant about a bear in a cage.

The film’s two-hour, 27-minute runtime draws out the horror to an agonizing length, much like the days in midsummer Sweden are drawn out to roughly 20 hours, with the few hours of “night” never getting darker than twilight. “Midsommar” lures the viewer, like its characters, into a sense of security with its bright colors, often-sweet score, beautiful cinematography and even comedic relief.

One almost forgets this is a horror movie, which makes the first gruesome human sacrifice rituals at Hårga even more horrific. Part of the horror is that, to the seemingly normal people of this village, nothing that is happening is horrific. When the visitors react with shock to these rituals, an elder is quick to respond that it is “a long, long observed custom.” To some of the outsiders, that is not a good enough excuse, but others, like Dani’s boyfriend, try to “acclimate” to what, for them, amounts to just a cultural difference.

Dani begins to question the commune after this event, but Christian, 2019’s movie boyfriend of the year, brushes aside how disturbed she is. Unlike Christian and his friends, she is not an anthropologist and is less willing to excuse the rituals. In this place of sunlight and summer, she is still haunted by the darkness of her winter loss. She is trying to process her still-fresh grief from her recent tragedy, but she is in a strange place with shocking traditions and no one who really listens to lean on. She starts to pack up and leave, but Pelle shows up for her where Christian fails and calms her down.

One almost forgets this is a horror movie, which makes the first gruesome human sacrifice rituals at Hårga even more horrific.

The film subverts the trope that bright and beautiful equal pure and good but dark and ugly equal evil and corruption, luring its victims with a seductive, pleasant appearance. The festival is a sharp contrast from the dark, snowy world Dani inhabits at the beginning of the film before she goes to Sweden. (There are many dualities in the film—night and day, winter and summer, death and rebirth.)

In this film, the human body gets defiled to the point where it resembles a Giuseppe Arcimboldo painting. At several points in the film, the imagery is so shocking and visceral that I was squirming in my seat. I saw this film twice in theaters, and both times I witnessed the strongest audience reaction I have ever seen in the movie theater. People were moving around, whispering, yelling in shock and even laughing in discomfort from what they were witnessing on screen. One wonders how the Hårga could possibly tolerate the horrors of human sacrifice that their tradition demands. Yet the Hårga defending their atrocities as part of their traditional way of life is a familiar fallacy. Watching the main characters gradually “acclimate” is surprising at first, but one has to wonder if our own culture is, to some degree, not so different. As the director himself put it, “the film’s thesis is [not] ‘lucky Americans, stay in America.’"

The final scene, at once cathartic, mesmerizing and stomach-churning, has stayed with me the most in the days since I have seen the film. The chaos of this scene contrasts a gratuitously grotesque event with striking camera work, vibrant colors, artful set and costume design, and a haunting, beautiful nine minutes of string orchestra. At the end, Dani is faced with a choice: Will she be tempted by the ways of the Hårga or will she snap out of it? Even without dialogue, this moment is the peak of Florence Pugh’s performance, which is stellar throughout the film, conveying so many layers of pain, catharsis and even joy at the same time. (Pugh and the director reportedly disagree on Dani’s degree of self-awareness in this scene, and in order for this film to be redeeming in any way, I choose to side with Pugh on this one.)

“Midsommar” prompts us to ask: What monstrosities are attractive and commonplace in our own culture? Are there ways that we sacrifice human lives in the name of culture and tradition? Americans almost worship guns, weapons of destruction, and the human sacrifice is high—tens of thousands per year in the United States. The rationalization of human sacrifice is perhaps the same, whether it is to protect the rights of a gun owner, purge evil spirits (as in the case of “Midsommar”) or make crops grow (as in “The Lottery,” by Shirley Jackson). Is it not like a death cult to accept no common sense compromises on the Secondnd Amendment tradition at the cost of 100 human sacrifices per day? Have we been seduced by the gun’s cool factor in a first-person shooter video game or action movie?

“Midsommar”makes the case that we do not have to fear the ugly and different. We do need to fear evil dressed up as beautiful and human. The film makes this point by including a deformed, mysterious boy, set up to be the great monster that this horror movie needs. The film subverts its genre when he turns out to seemingly harm no one. In a way, Reuben is just another victim of this commune’s traditions, intentionally deformed and disabled by inbreeding.

The real monster is everyone else.

rose-ellen caminer
4 days 5 hours ago

"Evil dressed up as beautiful and human".As in the beautiful and human; [human rights] "reproductive rights" movement which supports the ongoing holocaust [ literally ,as these capable -of -suffering- fetuses are, once killed, incinerated if not used for medical purposes]of the unborn,The evil and horror is underscored in how they will refer to these human fetuses as "tissue."Sorry[not]; though you nailed it regarding analogizing the human sacrifice -for- the- common -good, story of the film, to the second amendment ; where many kids have been sacrificed to that sacred -for -the- common- good 2nd amendment. you left out that [other ] elephant in the room.

James Mullin
3 days 4 hours ago

It is funny that the author sees gun ownership as the societal evil that is cast in a glowing light. To me it makes an incredibly uncanny depiction of modern Progressivism. Progressivism is cast by the Main Stream Media and our Universities (sadly even "Catholic") in a warm, glowing, loving light yet in reality is monstrous and near diabolical.

Oz Jewel
2 days 20 hours ago

There must be a book somewhere at America called "How to write sermons for the masses."

Take a work of art, quote the theme and the message and how it moooved you and then segue into the political harangue.

One of the names of the evil one is Lucifer. Angel of Light.

[Are you a smart, funny, spiritual person who wants to chat with other smart, funny, spiritual people about movies? Join America’s Catholic Movie Club on Facebook!]

Advertisement
More: Film

The latest from america

The role of caring for elderly family members is increasingly falling to mid-life adults. (iStock/kali9)
We can honor our parents by supporting a paid family leave program, one that is not limited to raising children but also recognizes the growing financial and physical burdens of caring for elderly family members.
Amy ZiettlowJuly 17, 2019
Fast food makes only one promise. That it is fast. Christ promises to feed us with food that will last.
Terrance KleinJuly 17, 2019
From left, Rep. Rashida Tlaib, D-Mich., Rep. Ilhan Omar, D-Minn., Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y., and Rep. Ayanna Pressley, D-Mass., respond to remarks by President Donald Trump after his call for the four Democratic congresswomen to go back to their "broken" countries, during a news conference at the Capitol in Washington, Monday, July 15, 2019. All are American citizens and three of the four were born in the U.S.
The Editors: These comments need to be called out as racist, xenophobic and sexist.
The EditorsJuly 16, 2019
People wait to apply for asylum in the United States along the border on July 16 in Tijuana, Mexico. (AP Photo/Gregory Bull)
“It is contrary to American and Christian values to attempt to prevent people from migrating here when they are fleeing to save their lives and to find safety for their families,” Cardinal DiNardo said.
Kevin ClarkeJuly 16, 2019