While "Master of None" looks for love, "Catastrophe" finds it.

("Master of None." Image courtesy of Netflix)

“Master of None” follows Dev Shah (Aziz Ansari, who co-created the show with Alan Yang) as he searches for love through rose-tinted glasses—at times, literally. The show’s second season, now available on Netflix, opens in black and white with the flamboyance of a Fellini movie. We watch Dev traverse the cobblestone streets of Modena, Italy, to a pasta shop, where the camera lingers on the deliberate caress of flour and eggs, on their way to a new form. Although the series drops the black-and-white format in later episodes, the sumptuous aesthetic remains. Even as he endures terrible Tinder dates, Dev is crested by ambient light and sips expensive wine. The scene’s characters are dressed in perfectly complementary colors and subtly ’70s-inspired outfits.

When “Master of None” charts the stories of Dev’s friends and their families, the perspective remains willingly uncynical and visually alluring. This makes for charming protagonists and friendships but rather dull romantic relationships. Dev’s love interest, the unavailable Francesca, is a sweet, archetypical Italian beauty, but the show fails to explore her character in any depth. Francesca and Dev’s conversations mostly entail jibes about their cultural differences, with Francesca asking the meaning of words (“What is ‘lukewarm’?”; “What cashews is?”) and Dev probing her for explanations of Italian hand gestures and cultural talking points.

Dev
Dev and Francesca in "Master of None"

Watched alongside “Catastrophe”—also a writer-actor comedy about love against the odds—we see the type of relationship Dev aspires to, although it lacks the tasteful glamour of “Master of None.” In that series, available on Amazon Prime, Rob Norris (Rob Delaney) and Sharon Morris (Sharon Horgan) decide to marry after Sharon becomes pregnant following their one-night stand. In seeking to represent the wondrous institution of marriage, “Catastrophe” eschews Italian film references and instead allows its dirty jokes and flawed, affable characters to do the work. Although, like Dev and Francesca, Rob, an American, and Sharon, who is Irish, hail from different countries, their humor and relationship does not rely on these differences to convey their chemistry.

One of the most romantic scenes in “Catastrophe” takes place at the end of Season 1. On their wedding night, the newlyweds recline on the same hotel bed they slept in on their first meeting, exhausted. Sharon is heavily pregnant, and her husband Rob offers to cut her neglected toenails. His new wife, accepts, tearful with gratitude—what clearer sign that they are soulmates than a gesture like this? The moment is cut short, however, when Sharon senses the mild disgust with which Rob undertakes his job and then recoils in offense. The night descends into the couple’s greatest argument yet: Objects are thrown, insults hurled and Sharon walks out—gnarly toenails intact—only to return seconds later after her water breaks.

In the hyper-curated, beautiful world that Dev lives in, a scene that conveys the touching, ugly stubbornness of marriage seems totally impossible. The format of “Master of None,” at least as it stands in Season 2, is built for the pretty romance of autumn leaves and John Legend piano performances, leaving no room for an unseemly deed like cutting a loved one’s toenails. There is more room in the format to explore the complication of long-term friendships, but the series tends to skirt these issues when it comes to romantic relationships.

If Season 3 of “Master of None” envisions a future for Francesca and Dev, it will have to reinvent itself. This is something the show’s creators are aware of. When asked about whether or not there will be another season, Aziz Ansari told Vulture: “I need to live my life a little bit, maybe get in a serious relationship, have a kid, something, and then maybe figure [Season 3] out.” Ansari’s sentiment is echoed by his on-screen best friend, who in the show counsels Dev that relationships are more complicated than he thinks. “Your relationship probably wasn’t going to be this magical fantasy that’s in your head. It was probably going to be a shit show,” he says.

If “Catastrophe” is anything to go by, he is right. But, as Sharon and Rob show us, the beauty of marriage can show itself in those messy moments—no rose-tinted glasses required.

Kerry Goleski
2 months 3 weeks ago

Eloise! I love that you wrote on this-- I actually haven't watched catasptrophe yet but master of none is definitely a fun show to dissect. I completely agree that dev and Francesca's love is shallow and depicted cheaply--and maybe I am being overly charitable because I loved the first season so much--but I like to think Aziz ansari doesn't think he's showing real love but a phonenomenon that happens all the time, a desire for love that manifests itself in an unobtainable situation and thus is more romantic (in the persons mind). He even admits in the end that he just wants to be in love with someone. Thanks for writing!! I'm going to watch catastrophe now!!!

Eloise Blondiau
2 months 3 weeks ago

It's so great to hear your thoughts, Kerry! I'm totally with you—I think "Master of None" is crafted with Dev's shortcomings in mind, and I think it perfectly reflects that he's not ready for a real relationship, even if he thinks he is. I would love to see how Aziz Ansari and Alan Yang choose tackle a more complicated, sustained relationship in a later series though. I wonder how the aesthetics will change to keep up with a development like that. Also, "Castastrophe" is amazing, I hope you like it!

More: TV / Marriage

Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

A woman places a candle by floral tributes for the victims of an attack at Turku Market Square on Friday, in Turku, Finland, Saturday, Aug. 19, 2017. (Vesa Moilanen/Lehtikuva via AP)
“We carry in our hearts the pain of the acts of terrorism that in these last days have caused numerous victims.”
Gerard O'ConnellAugust 20, 2017
 In this Friday, June 9, 2017 file photo, a South Sudanese refugee boy sits on a mat outside a communal tent while his brother sleeps, at the Imvepi reception center, where newly arrived refugees are processed before being allocated plots of land in nearby Bidi Bidi refugee settlement, in northern Uganda. AP Photo/Ben Curtis, File)
The pope’s World Day of Migrants and Refugees message marks a break from past years.
Colleen DulleAugust 18, 2017
I’ve never even owned a dog. Isn’t that a prereq for parenting these days?
Ashley McKinlessAugust 18, 2017
Injured people react after a van crashed into pedestrians in the Las Ramblas district of Barcelona, Spain, Aug. 17. Terrorists killed at least 12 and injured more than 50 others. (CNS photo/David Armengou, EPA)
The pope denounced the attack as “a grave offence against the Creator.”
Gerard O'ConnellAugust 18, 2017