A conservative Latina discusses racial tensions within the Republican Party

(CNS photo/Scott A. Miller, Reuters

This week’s guest is Dr. Ashleen Menchaca-Bagnulo, an assistant professor of political science at Texas State University in San Marcos, Tex. She joins the show to discuss her latest article for America: “I’m a Conservative Latina. Is there a place for me in Trump’s Republican Party after Charlottesville?” In her piece, Dr. Menchaca-Bagnulo explores the tensions of being a person of color in an Republican Party. “On the right there’s always been a tendency to have significant problems with race and with racial identity,” she says. Dr. Menchaca-Bagnulo argues this long-running problem is now a crisis for the conservative movement and the Republican Party.



Dr. Menchaca-Bagnulo cites her own personal experiences, as well as the experiences of her students and family, as evidence for the newfound sense of racism as acceptable. “We had students that were spat on after the election, students who had their hair pulled, students who were told to go back to Mexico,” she told America.

Nevertheless, Dr. Menchaca-Bagnulo makes clear she still considers herself a conservative. But she noted, “If the right is going to be arguing that the family is a fundamental unit of society and children need a mother and father, why are you going to deport parents of citizen children?”

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Don Honda
3 months 2 weeks ago

Google: Washington Post
opposition to immigration reform is a winning strategy for republicans

"By any measure, fears of (Illegal) immigration are driving many white Americans to the Republican Party. And, indeed, the Republican strategy on immigration appears to have been successful. Republicans now control the House and the Senate, the governor’s office in 31 states, and two-thirds of the state legislatures. They are winning the political war."

"An even bigger factor is that the ties of racial and ethnic minorities to the Democratic Party are tenuous. Research by Taeku Lee and myself shows that most Latinos and Asian Americans don’t feel like they fit into either party. In national surveys, those who refuse to answer a question about party identification, those who claim that they do not think in partisan terms, and independents make up the clear majority of both groups. All told, 56 percent of Latinos and 57 percent of Asian-American identify as nonpartisans.

Even among blacks, there are signs of ambivalence. Almost 30 percent of blacks feel
that the Democratic Party does not work hard for black interests."

Google: philly dot com
As Trump fades be smart about immigration

"Most Hispanics aren't single-issue voters when it comes to immigration. A recent Gallup poll found that among registered Latino voters, 67 percent are at least willing to support a candidate who doesn't share their views on immigration. And 18 percent don't consider the issue important at all.

What's more, many Hispanic citizens have little sympathy for immigrants who haven't played by the rules. Especially among Latino voters born in the United States, resentment of immigrants who have entered the country illegally can run deep. Forty-two percent of American-born Hispanics disapprove of President Obama's executive actions to prevent the deportation of illegal immigrants."

Google: The Daily Beast dot com
Reuben Navarette: No Joke: Trump Can Win Plenty of Latinos

Google: townhall dot com
Conservative Hispanic Leaders Poised To Endorse Trump

Google: slate star codex dot com
You Are Still Crying Wolf

"Trump made gains among blacks. He made gains among Latinos. He made gains among Asians. The only major racial group where he didn’t get a gain of greater than 5% was white people. I want to repeat that: the group where Trump’s message resonated least over what we would predict from a generic Republican was the white population."

Gee, No wonder why I fall into the Proud Independent group.


Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

Megan Sweas is this week's guest.
America This WeekJanuary 17, 2018

It is not the first time and it is unlikely to be the last time, but President Trump’s latest racist remarks about “shithole” countries has many of asking: Who are we? What do we stand for? Who do we welcome and why?

Zac DavisJanuary 12, 2018
Images: CNS, Illustration: America
On January 10, we spoke to Dr. C. Vanessa White.
America This WeekJanuary 11, 2018
Photo by Josh Applegate on Unsplash
Looking at the faces of people looking for God.
The EditorsJanuary 04, 2018