The Letters

Money in Politics

Re “America’s (Un)Civil War,” by Matt Malone, S.J. (Of Many Things, 11/26): Civility and compromise, perhaps, are joined at the hip. Politicians and candidates inclined to compromise could face election opponents backed by mega-money. Why would any politician or candidate intentionally incur the wrath of mega-money?


Chuck Kotlarz


Addressing Clericalism

Re “#ChurchToo,” by Lea Karen Kivi (11/26): How many young women were “chosen” by a priest for special attention, only to be abused? And years later, when they realized the violation, were too conflicted to take any kind of action against the men involved? Until the church begins to address false privileges of clericalism, these victims will never come forth.

Jane Steinhauser


Not in Favor

Re “A Statue of the Virgin Mary Will Be a Sign of Welcome on the U.S.-Mexico Border,” by J.D. Long-García (11/26): I travel the neighborhoods of South San Diego (near the site) and those of downtown San Diego, and I see the extreme poverty. There is so much good that could be done with the $2 million cost of the statue. Sadly, this is more a political statement than a work of charity.

Doug Kelchner


Legacy of Abuse

Re “A New Play Asks: What Is Owed to Abusers?” by Michael J. O’Loughlin (11/26): We know that many abusers were abused themselves as minors, so how many of the abusive clergy were themselves victims of clergy abuse? How do we reconcile the idea of mercy to the abuser who was himself a victim?

Letitia Roddy


One Duty

Re “The Catholic Mystique,” by Kaya Oakes (11/26): Both women and men have crucial roles in the church. Our society wrongly equates the ordained priesthood and hierarchy with power. Ordination bestows the duty of service, not dominance over the church and over others. All the baptized are tasked with the duty of evangelization.

Anne Chavez


Fighting Anti-Semitism

Re “The Moral Duty to Fight Anti-Semitism” (Our Take, 11/26): Yes we do have an obligation to fight anti-Semitism. As a father of four, I very much want my kids to grow up in a caring and tolerant society. That is reason enough to fight anti-Semitism. Did I mention that I love my country and want it very much to live up to its ideals? There’s yet another reason.

Joe Martino



Re “Heroic and Unheroic Poland,” by Monika Rice (11/12): It is extremely disconcerting to me, as a graduate of a Jesuit university, that this erudite order would be associated with this article. Ms. Rice focuses on worn-out anti-Polish canards that have been repeated ad nauseam. She might instead have exposed the fact that almost one-half of all hate crimes in New York City are perpetrated against Jews. The author would have you believe the Holocaust occurred in a vacuum in German-occupied Poland. Hitler ordered his troops to “kill, without pity or mercy, all men, women, and children of Polish nationality and language.” This article dishonors the memory of millions of Polish Christian victims.

Yvonne Kowalczewski

Boston, Mass.


Monika Rice Responds: I thank Ms. Kowalczewski for her comment. My article does not discuss Polish suffering under Nazi terror and, therefore, cannot logically dishonor the memory of its victims. Neither does it discuss the conditions of Nazi-occupied Poland; instead, it refers to the pogrom perpetrated by Polish inhabitants of Jedwabne against their Jewish neighbors in July 1941. Reinhard Heydrich’s order to the Einsatzgruppen to “trigger local pogroms” provides as much context for this crime in German-occupied Poland as is needed to understand that there were Polish “locals” who were able to be “triggered” to murder their Jewish neighbors. The fact that many vocal Poles prefer to resort to a red herring technique of a charge of “dishonoring the memory of millions of Polish Christian victims” is an ironic confirmation of the main argument of my article, quod erat demonstrandum.

Monika Rice


Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Tim Donovan
2 months 1 week ago

Re: "A Statue of the Virgin Mary will be a Sign of Welcome on the U.S.-Mexico Border" by J. D. Long-Garcia (11/26). My nephew John was born on December 12, the feast day of Our Lady of Guadalupe. Although Jesus is our Savior, I do believe in the veneration of His Mother, by honoring her with statues. However, I agree with Doug Kelcher that the $2 million cost of the statue could be better spent (on the poor, for example). I 'm sure that the Blessed Mother would prefer that money be spent on those in need.


The latest from america

In times like these, the “virtuous speech” counseled by St. Francis de Sales in his The Devout Life is downright countercultural
Peter J. VaghiFebruary 19, 2019
The engagement with intersectionality by moral theologians continues the historical process by which the tradition has always learned from ways of knowing outside of itself.
Bill McCormick, S.J.February 19, 2019
Arturo Sosa, S.J., the superior general of the Society of Jesus, today made public the four main reference points that are to guide the life and work of the Jesuits over the next 10 years.
Gerard O’ConnellFebruary 19, 2019
The ruins of the church where the constitution of Simón Bolívar’s “Gran Colombia” was signed. Photo by Antonio De Loera-Brust
Over one million Venezuelans have arrived in Colombia as of May 2018. Colombia is not a rich country, and helping to bear the burden of receiving thousands of Venezuelan refugees every day is the Catholic Church.
Antonio De Loera-BrustFebruary 18, 2019