Amazon Synod is a place of discernment that ‘must leave space for the Spirit’

Francisco Chagas Chafre de Souza, a leader of the Apurina in Brazil's Amazon region, speaks at a meeting of indigenous people from North America and South America at the Jesuit General Curia in Rome Oct. 17, 2019. Also pictured are Dona Zenilda with the Xucuru people of northeast Brazil, and Ednamar de Oliveira Viana, a leader of the Satere-Mawe people in Brazil. The meeting was a side event to the Synod of Bishops for the Amazon. (CNS photo/Paul Haring)Francisco Chagas Chafre de Souza, a leader of the Apurina in Brazil's Amazon region, speaks at a meeting of indigenous people from North America and South America at the Jesuit General Curia in Rome Oct. 17, 2019. Also pictured are Dona Zenilda with the Xucuru people of northeast Brazil, and Ednamar de Oliveira Viana, a leader of the Satere-Mawe people in Brazil. The meeting was a side event to the Synod of Bishops for the Amazon. (CNS photo/Paul Haring)

As the Vatican published the highly-anticipated small group reports at the Synod of Bishops for the Amazon region on Oct. 18, and a commission prepares to begin drafting the synod’s final document, members of the Vatican communications team emphasized that the synod is a place of discernment and not a battleground of ideas.

The synod is “not a discussion, not a parliament,” but there is “a spiritual dynamic,” said Giacomo Costa, S.J., the synod’s secretary for information, at a Vatican press briefing on Oct. 16. The biblical image, he said, is “the blind man who throws away his cloak to go to God,” and for the synod it means “to leave behind the safety of your arguments.”

Advertisement

“The synod is a path of discernment” that must “leave space for the Spirit,” Father Costa said, adding that no one knows what the synod will bring.

“If we are trapped in conflicts and details, we lose sight of the deeper reality which is calling us,” he said. “We are trying together to go beyond individual positions,” so we can “understand the deep truth of reality that is calling us to take steps.”

“If we are trapped in conflicts and details, we lose sight of the deeper reality which is calling us,” a synod participant said. “We are trying together to go beyond individual positions,” so we can “understand the deep truth of reality that is calling us to take steps.”

At the Vatican press briefing on Oct. 18, one synod participant explained the basis for this discernment and even invited everyone present in the briefing room to observe 30 seconds of silence in order “to contemplate God’s gaze on reality.” The church is called “to place ourselves with the Trinity, contemplating the great diversity of those who are born, die, rejoice, cry, those in peace, others at war,” said Mauricio López, the executive secretary of the Pan-Amazonian Ecclesial Network, or REPAM, which helped coordinate the extensive pre-synodal process of consultation with indigenous communities and other groups in the Amazon region.

Mr. López, who called himself “a son of Ignatian spirituality,” was referencing the “Contemplation on the Incarnation” in the Spiritual Exercises of St. Ignatius Loyola.

“God invites us to be part of this project, to take on the gaze of God toward reality, where Jesus invites us to walk with him,” said Mr. López.

In this synod, there is a “new ecclesiological perspective” where the “periphery is at the center.”

“The birth of something new is always painful,” Mr. López said later in the briefing. It is a gradual process unfolding since the Second Vatican Council in which the church places itself “closer to pain.”

“The Amazon can help us to be closer to God’s project for life [and to be] pro-life, from conception to death,” said Mr. López. “Let us think about the daily deaths, the daily murders of so many migrants who are trying to find meaning for life.

“The same is happening in the Congo Basin,” he said, adding that in Europe “there is a need for a greater synodality to give an answer to these daily deaths.” Mr. López said he has also heard about how indigenous peoples in North America are “affected by this dominating system.”

“We must not complain about listening to the word of the prophet” while failing to understand that “the time is now,” to act from a global perspective, Mr. López said.

Also at the briefing, Daniela Adriana Cannavina, S.C.M.R., of Colombia, the general secretary of the Confederation of Latin American and Caribbean Religious, said that men and women in religious life “must respond as mystics and prophetic persons in the context in which we work” and should offer “a new commitment to the urgent needs of renewing and strengthening our presence in the Amazonian context.”

Sister Cannavina, a member of the Capuchin Sisters of Mother Rubatto, added that the voice of male and female religious has increased over the course of the synod.

Reflecting their centuries-long missionary presence in the region, religious orders have a strong presence at the Amazon synod. Among the 185 voting members of the synod, 102 are members of a religious congregation, including 22 Franciscans, 13 Salesians, 10 Jesuits, seven Augustinians and six Redemptorists. Among the 80 experts and auditors at the synod, there are 20 female religious and 15 male religious.

Sister Cannavina said her small group at the synod had a “concern for giving women an increasingly strong presence” and that the “women’s diaconate” came up in discussion. In a synodal church, the role of women “must grow,” taking on greater leadership and pastoral activities, she said.

The various proposals in the synod include “various ministries for women as well as the diaconate for women,” said Bishop Mário Antônio da Silva of Roraima, Brazil. He added, “These are just proposals, not obligations,” and there’s “an opportunity for developing these proposals in the synodal spirit.”

This synod “is an opportunity to get in touch with life, forests, water, animals, minerals,” he said, “but most of all the communities” in Amazonia that are “full of wisdom” and have “answers to the challenges in the region.”

The bishop’s Diocese of Roraima, which is located in the northernmost state in Brazil, has 228,500 Catholics, only 49 priests and covers 86,635 square miles, the combined size of New York State and Pennsylvania.

The synod “is an opportunity to hear the voice of the Amazon and the plea of Amazon peoples,” he said, including both their joys and difficulties, so the church can discern how to “accompany the communities in the best way.”

In response to a question from Gerard O’Connell, America’s Vatican correspondent, about a proposal at the synod for the creation of an Amazonian rite, Italian Archbishop Salvatore Fisichella said this proposal needs to be understood in the context of “the evangelization work carried out by the church.”

“When the Gospel reaches a culture, it becomes inculturated and expresses itself through forms that the culture understands,” said the archbishop, who is the president of the Pontifical Council for the Promotion of the New Evangelization. “Some liturgical books have already been translated into some Amazonian languages, so the theological tradition is not something new.” For decades, there has already been an “Indian theology,” he said.

At this stage, the Amazonian rite is only a proposal, the archbishop added. “We don’t know if it will be approved” or “how this can be implemented.”

In the briefing, Father Costa emphasized the perspectives shared in the reports “are all personal” and “not even remotely” to be considered “a final summary report” or an official proposal of the synod. It is the final document, he said, that is offered to the Holy Father for his consideration and future action.

In the synod’s final week, a draft of the final document will be discussed in plenary sessions and small groups, and amendments can be suggested. On Oct. 26, the 184 voting members of the synod—comprised mostly of bishops, some priests and one religious brother—will vote on each paragraph of the final document. A supermajority of two-thirds is needed for passage.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Luis Gutierrez
3 weeks 3 days ago

The ecological crisis is rooted in the patriarchal culture of male headship (Genesis 3:16, Ephesians 5:21-33). As long as the church remains a patriarchal institution, calls for "ecological conversion" are not compelling. Given that the "impedimentum sexus" is not dogmatic, and is no longer credible, why ordain more married men?  Why not ordain celibate women?

It seems that the bishops have a mental block with regard to the ordination of women. Is it so hard to recognize that the church has been doing something wrong for 2000 years? If the church hierarchy is incapable of admitting theological errors, can we expect people to admit ecological errors? If the institutional church cannot experience a doctrinal renewal, can we expect secular institutions to experience an ecological conversion?

Jim Smith
3 weeks 2 days ago

To get his chosen people their own land which he promised, God used Abraham and Isaac and Jacob initially and Moses to lead them back to it, Patriarchs all.
Jesus called God His Father and taught us to pray that way too.

Looks like a full house of patriarchy.

Get over it.

Luis Gutierrez
3 weeks 2 days ago

My discernment is that the patriarchal culture is passing away, and this passing is a sign of the times. It is hard to imagine that the church should remain fossilized in the patriarchal culture in a post-patriarchal civilization. The "full house of patriarchy" is becoming a house of cards, not a house built on rock. Christ is the rock. Patriarchy is not the rock. Would Jesus, in today's world, choose 12 males to represent the patriarchs of the 12 tribes of Israel?

Tim O'Leary
3 weeks 1 day ago

Luis - the admonition above could well relate to your idée fixe, the only one you ever blog on. A heresy is not a mental block, no more than a scientific fact is a mental block. An inability to see a heresy or accept a scientific fact could be. God ordained that priests be men, in His calling of the patriarchs, in His design of the chosen people, in His selection of apostles (Mt 4:18-22, Mk 3:13-19; Lk 6;12-16; Jn 1:35-50), in the Holy Spirit's guidance of the Church for two millennia; in the sensus fidelium over that time; in the definitive and infallible teaching of Ordinatio Sacerdotalis. To paraphrase from the article above, you seem trapped in conflicts and details, and are losing sight of the deeper reality. You should try to go beyond you positions.

Christopher Lochner
3 weeks 3 days ago

"...get in touch with minerals..." is the most foolhardy quotation I've seen in quite awhile, although, it might be nice to get in touch with a powerful V8 engine. And since most of the issues at play are either organizational or political it appears to come down to who has the bigger Spirit. Ridiculous and juvenile! Is Jesus a part of this Church anymore or at all?? Or have we given over to the worship of secular leadership?

Jim Smith
3 weeks 2 days ago

We Anglo-Saxons and Celts gave up the spirits a long time ago but still like to hear of them in stories.
Fairies, gnomes, pixies, trolls, sprites, leprechauns and many others were just the Western European equivalents of their spirits of trees and animals and rocks and mountains,
We must not be so paternalistic and condescending, the pagan picture of the world of spirit is at odds with the Judeo-Christian picture and Holy Spirit can expect them to give theirs up the way we and our ancestors were.

Alan Johnstone
3 weeks 1 day ago

There is no crisis, neither ecological nor ecclesiastic nor faith.
Invocation of a crisis in the absence of such is a grave moral error, an effort to make change by violence, induction of panic, attempting to stampede the herd.

The human race is doing as commanded of Adam and Eve - increase and multiply and fill the face of the earth and we are nowhere near full yet.
Since the decent of the Holy Spirit on the apostles and Mary, both life and death have gone on apace.
Large numbers of famines and wars and volcanoes and storms and floods and fires and plagues and pestilence have followed one upon the other, People have been born and died, the human family continues being born, living and dying.
Nothing new under the sun.
The present community of faith, the Militant who belong to the one, holy, universal tradition with shepherds anointed into the male apostolic succession can expect to retain this situation unchanged.
Coptic, Maronite, Melchite and Russian, Greek, Serbian Orthodox already have significantly different cultures and have recently been joined by a Ziare rite in the Congo. Who knows what will come in the future?.

Since the Assumption of Our Lady into Heaven we have had Christ the King and Mary, Queen Mother ruling and reigning and there will be NO replacing them.

Charles Erlinger
3 weeks 1 day ago

Does anyone know of a succinct statement of the problem that the synod is intended to solve, or at least to make a contribution towards a solution? If so, thanks.

JR Cosgrove
2 weeks 6 days ago

Just what does the word "discernment" mean? Apparently it does not mean what the English definition of the word means. Maybe the Jesuits might want to try and define it. On another thread, it was defined as "walking together." Which is not what the word means in English.

[Explore America’s in-depth coverage of Pope Francis.]

Advertisement

The latest from america

Refugees and migrants at a camp on the Greek island of Samos, on Oct. 18.  (AP Photo/Michael Svarnias)
More people have been forced to flee their homes than at any time in recorded history, writes Kevin White of Jesuit Refugee Service. But there is good news about global initiatives to address the problem.
Kevin White, S.J.November 12, 2019
On Nov. 12, the U.S. bishops elected Archbishop Gomez to be the president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops on the first ballot.
J.D. Long-GarcíaNovember 12, 2019
Cardinal Daniel N. DiNardo of Galveston-Houston, president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, right, applauds as Archbishop Jose H. Gomez of Los Angeles acknowledges the applause after being named the new president during the fall general assembly of the USCCB in Baltimore Nov. 12, 2019. (CNS photo/Bob Roller)
Archbishop Gomez leads the largest U.S. diocese, Los Angeles, home to more than four million Catholics, and has been a vocal proponent of rights for immigrants.
Michael J. O’LoughlinNovember 12, 2019
Watch talks by James Martin, S.J., Sr. Peggy O'Neill and more here.
America FilmsNovember 12, 2019