Cardinal Müller on Viganò: No one has right to demand a pope’s resignation

Cardinal Gerhard Müller, prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (2014 CNA/Daniel Ibanez)  

VATICAN CITY (CNS) -- People can disagree about problems and the best ways to resolve them, but no one should launch a formal accusation against a pope much less ask for his resignation, German Cardinal Gerhard Muller said.

Such public attacks put into question the church's credibility, he said in an interview with the Italian website Vatican Insider Nov. 27.

Advertisement

"I am personally convinced that Pope Francis is doing everything possible to oppose the phenomenon of abuse against minors and to foster a new spirituality among priests who must act with the heart of Christ and do what is good for all people, above all for children and young people," he said in a lengthy question-and-answer piece.

Asked about Archbishop Carlo Maria Vigano's public call for Pope Francis to resign because he felt the pope knew about the alleged sex abuse involving U.S. Archbishop Theodore E. McCarrick's but still failed to act, Cardinal Muller said, "No one has a right to indict the pope or ask him to resign."

Such discussions must never become "a public controversy with attacks that end up calling into question the credibility of the church and her mission."

"Clearly it is possible to have different opinions about existing problems and the ways to resolve them, but we have to discuss this," each according to his or her role and in a discreet way, the cardinal said.

Such discussions must never become "a public controversy with attacks that end up calling into question the credibility of the church and her mission," he said.

The former head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, which is charged with handling cases of clerical sex abuse, said, "We all have to cooperate in order to overcome this crisis (of abuse) that wounds the credibility of the church."

"Unfortunately, we have these groups, these 'parties' -- the so-called 'progressives' and 'conservatives.' We are all united in the revealed faith and not by the biases of political ideologies," he said.

One way the abuse crisis unfolding in the United States could be handled, for example, he said, would be for the pope to create a commission of cardinals he trusts to study the situation and then offer proposals based on "solid information."

Beyond the problem of opposing opinions, warring factions, propaganda in the media and mutual suspicion, he said, "we need a solid foundation of information. This is the only way we can make decisions for the future."

The cardinal was asked about the Vatican's request that the U.S. bishops postpone voting on several proposals to address abuse during their annual fall general assembly in mid-November. The Congregation for Bishops had requested that no vote be taken on proposals such as standards of episcopal accountability and conduct and the formation of a special commission for review of complaints against bishops for violations of the standards.

Cardinal Muller said bishops and the pope each have their own responsibilities, "but everyone must collaborate."

The church's existing laws are "sufficient" and "the norms of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith already exist," said the cardinal, who led the congregation from 2012 to 2017.

"All the bishops did not always collaborate with our dicastery. They did not inform (us) as it is established they do. First, we have to do what is already established and indicated as necessary and mandatory by existing norms," he said.

Cardinal Muller said bishops and the pope each have their own responsibilities, "but everyone must collaborate."

Once existing procedures are followed, then "one can collaborate in a fraternal and collegial spirit, and perhaps discuss if the tone" or tenor of any proposed text is adequate.

He said it would have been better to avoid debate and public controversy by having more discussions well beforehand in Rome and not at the last minute, especially with experts at the doctrinal congregation.

"The Holy Father is one person and he cannot take care of everything. This is why there are dicasteries of the Roman Curia, to collaborate with and come up with a well-developed proposal to bring to the pope."

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Tom B
4 months 3 weeks ago

Pardon me, but the People of God, Archbishop Vigano is a member in good standing, have the right to hold the Pope, the bishops, the priests, the deacons, and the religious sisters and brothers accountable. I'm with Archbishop Vigano that the Pope must resign or be removed. He has proven himself, at the least, incompetent and at the worst, a crook.

Jeffrey More
4 months 2 weeks ago

Public attacks on the Pope call into question the Church's credibility, says the Cardinal. True, but so do many other things, I think. For example, I've always thought that the resignation of Benedict bordered on the scandalous, particularly when he has continued to live for years, in apparent good health for the most part, in the Vatican. How does the Vicar of Christ on earth just quit, irrespective of his purported reasons? Then there's the matter of Francis's failure, despite the passage of at least three months, to refute Abp. Vigano's accusations. Citing the virtue of silence, and hinting that his accuser is a minion of Satan, is as damaging to the pope's credibility as the accusations are, in my opinion. Then there's the matter of the controversy over footnote 351 of Laetitiae Amoris. Why couldn't the pope respond to the Dubia submitted by certain cardinals? Why did he direct that his correspondence with Argentinian bishops concerning their interpretation of the footnote be included in the AAS? Why create even the possibility that some of the faithful might be led (however erroneously) to believe that the pope has changed Church teaching in such an unusual (and one might say unorthodox) way? Isn't that tantamount to giving scandal?

Advertisement
More: Vatican

The latest from america

Join Kirsten Powers, CNN analyst and USA Today columnist, and Rev. James Martin, S.J., Editor at Large of America Media and New York Times best-selling author, for a live show celebrating the 100th episode of Jesuitical.
America Media EventsApril 24, 2019

Some three months before Neil Armstrong stepped off the ladder of the lunar module and left his footprints upon the surface of the moon in July, 1969, and uttered those immortal words about it being but “one small step for man” and yet “a giant leap for mankind,” a young, brown-haired, freckle-

Joseph McAuleyApril 18, 2019
You give us hope when we’re reporting on challenging issues in the church.
James Cappabianca April 18, 2019
For decades, Lopez has sought to re-establish our ethical relationships with the land and the other creatures who dwell on it. But Lopez, like many authors, struggles against labels.
Vincent J. MillerApril 18, 2019