Catholics cite God, not homilies, as reason for attending church

A Mass is celebrated at Star of the Sea Catholic Church in San Francisco. (iStock/yhelfman)A Mass is celebrated at Star of the Sea Catholic Church in San Francisco. (iStock/yhelfman)

Compared with other Christians in the United States, Catholics are more likely to attend church to please other family members—and are significantly less likely to go because they “find the sermons valuable.” Those were among the findings of a Pew Research Center poll released in August. Pew interviewed 4,729 U.S. adults, including 844 self-identified Catholics, last December to find out why they regularly attended church or stayed away.

Almost half of all Catholics who do not attend Mass regularly say a very important reason is that “I practice my faith in other ways.”

Among those who rarely attend church, 37 percent of all adults and 47 percent of Catholics chose “I practice my faith in other ways” as a “very important” reason they did not attend church. Only 28 percent cited a lack of belief in religion as a very important reason; nonbelievers were disproportionately young, male and highly educated, and they identified more with the Democratic Party. Protestants were more likely than Catholics to say, “I haven’t found a church I like,” and people under 30 were most likely to say they “don’t have the time” to attend.

Advertisement

Most adults who attended church at least monthly chose “to become closer to God” as an important reason, but Catholics were much less likely than other Christian groups to say, “I find the sermons valuable.” Men were more likely than women to say they attended church to please spouses or family members (22 percent versus 12 percent). Among age groups, those under 30 were most likely to say they attended church to “socialize” (30 percent) and least likely to say they went to be part of a community of faith (52 percent).

Among Catholics, 36 percent chose “I find the sermons valuable” as a very important reason to attend church, compared with 76 percent of evangelical Protestants.

Adults under 30 who regularly attended church were also the least likely to say they often experienced “a sense of God’s presence” there (63 percent versus more than 80 percent for other age groups). However, older groups were more likely to say they attend “for comfort in times of trouble”; it may be the case that life experience strengthens belief and creates an openness to spirituality.

Source: “Why Americans Go (and Don’t Go) to Religious Services,” Aug. 1, Pew Research Center. The margin of error was 3.7 points among non-attenders, 3.0 points among regular church attenders and 7.8 points among Catholics. Both non-attenders and attenders were divided into religious groups, including Protestant denominations that have historically had mostly black congregations, by self-identification. Because respondents could give multiple answers, column totals in the accompanying charts add up to more than 100.

 

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
J Cosgrove
11 months ago

The reason to go to Mass besides being an obligation handed down by God (third commandment) is that God is there for our taking. Homilies are a great addition and some of the best ones explain the scriptures and the faith. But they are not the reason for attending.

Phillip Stone
11 months ago

King David was convicted of grave sin by taking a census as described in 1 Chronicles 21 and following.
It is also not made clear there why it was such a wrong thing to do.

Was it doubt about the sovereignty of God presiding over the affairs of his chosen people; was it attempting to get knowledge that really only belonged to God?

Surely living as a disciple of Christ does not necessitate knowing what our neighbour is up to, and why.

Tim Donovan
10 months 3 weeks ago

I agree that we should attend Mass as God taught us in the Ten Commandments. As I go to the Sacrament of Reconciliation each month to receive forgiveness for my sins, I believe receiving Jesus worthily in the Eucharist is of tremendous importance. I also find comfort in praying for my intentions as well as other people in need whom I know. Finally, although the celebrant's homily isn't essential to the reverence that should be a crucial part of every Mass, the quality of the priest explaining the Scriptures and the faith is important to me.

Advertisement

The latest from america

To listen carefully to an arguing group is to gain a peculiar glimpse into the desires and anxieties of that group.
Pádraig Ó TuamaSeptember 20, 2019
When I was a boy, I considered becoming a nun because I didn’t want to shave part of my scalp
Ronnie SirmansSeptember 20, 2019
It is a great set up for a television series—and yes, the comparisons to Scully and Mulder are warranted.
Nick Ripatrazone September 20, 2019
Some Catholic schools are implementing dual-language programs, part of an effort to reflect the reality of life in the church in the United States.
J.D. Long-GarcíaSeptember 20, 2019