Click here if you don’t see subscription options
Emma Winters March 29, 2019

No matter what you think about the legality of abortion, “Unplanned” will get under your skin. The new movie, which opens this weekend, is a dramatization of the true story of Abby Johnson’s conversion from Planned Parenthood clinic director to pro-life activist. “Unplanned” invites an empathic response by showing the messy parts of Johnson’s life—including the two abortions she had in her early 20s.

“When I watched the film the first time…I was like, why did I decide to do this? This feels so vulnerable,” Johnson said before an early screening of “Unplanned” at The Sheen Center for Thought and Culture. This feeling of uncomfortable vulnerability reflects the experience of watching the movie. As Johnson’s story unfolded, I felt with her, and I felt it in my stomach.

“Unplanned” does not sanitize the reality of abortion. It shows us what Johnson saw when she assisted an ultrasound-guided abortion and what she experienced taking the abortion pill. Ashley Bratcher, the actress who played Abby Johnson, said the scene in which she portrayed Johnson suffering from the side effects of the abortifacient drug RU-486 was the most difficult to shoot. “I was so emotional in that scene that I literally started throwing up,” Bratcher said. “The filming process was grueling.”

God plans our steps from conception.

It was difficult to watch too. These graphic moments are not gratuitous but are aimed to subtly move people. And Johnson’s story offers a different way of discussing abortion—one in which it is possible to see how complicated the issue can be. Perhaps, the ardent pro-choice advocate can be convinced to entertain doubt, or the passionate pro-life protester can be persuaded to see the humanity of the Planned Parenthood employee.

A key motif in “Unplanned” is the fence that surrounds the Planned Parenthood’s parking lot, separating the clinic from those engaged in sidewalk prayer and protest. Despite the ideological and physical divide, Johnson, after years of prayers and pleas from members of the Coalition for Life in Bryan Texas, moves to join the protesters.

“This movie provides an opportunity for conversion for every single person,” Johnson said. “Even the person who is pro-life, how are you being active in the pro-life movement? Are you doing things that are effective?”

I watched the film less than a month after New York revised its abortion laws, removing abortion from the criminal code. It was screened at The Sheen Center, a Catholic arts organization aimed at “featuring humankind as fully alive.” It is next door to Planned Parenthood’s Margaret Sanger Health Center. It felt like there was an impossible divide between those two buildings.

But Johnson said she hopes skeptics will see the movie and welcomes criticism for the film. “I think there will be people that go to watch it just to see, who is this jerk?” she said. “But hopefully, prayerfully, they will go into the film and find truth, and it will really prick their conscience.”

Underlying Johnson’s story and the people who brought it to life is a real sense of providence. Johnson’s leaving Planned Parenthood was not the Coalition for Life’s only victory. The clinic Johnson worked at until 2009, first as a counselor and later as director, closed in 2013. The Coalition for Life became a national movement, now called 40 Days for Life. “Unplanned” is the story of these pro-life victories, based on Johnson’s book.

I signed on to really show people that this is God’s story.

“I had to constantly remind myself that it’s not about me,” Johnson said. “I signed on to really show people that this is God’s story, and that he allows this possibility of redemption and conversion for every single person.”

For Ashley Bratcher, the actress who played Abby Johnson, “Unplanned” quickly became more than just another acting opportunity. Bratcher stumbled into the lead role when a “random Instagram follower,” who was not in the film industry, messaged her: “I feel like God is telling me you are meant to play this role.”

Her first reaction was that this woman was crazy, but after some pestering, Bratcher checked out the role. She was drawn to Johnson because she was a “feisty” character. “When I looked up [Abby Johnson’s] story, I was wrecked,” she said. “After that, I was all in. I was compelled.”

She auditioned, and left to shoot the film in Oklahoma within hours of learning she had gotten the part. She told a few family members immediately but was hesitant to tell her own mother about the content of the film. Bratcher knew her mother had previously had an abortion in high school. “I didn’t want her to feel like I was judging her or that I loved her any less. I wanted her to know that this was a movie about hope and redemption.”

When Bratcher did tell her mother, she learned something that changed her outlook not only on the movie but on life itself. Bratcher’s mother confessed to her that she had gone to a clinic again as a 19-year-old seeking an abortion. She had changed her mind in the exam room, walked out and chose to be a mother. As a result of that choice, Ashley Bratcher was born.

“I never knew until after I accepted this role,” Bratcher said. “It was just such confirmation to me that God plans our steps from conception.”

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
John Donne
3 years 10 months ago

A very good article. However, I notice on the left column a related story:

Abby Johnson worked at Planned Parenthood. Now she is a leader of the pro-life movement.

Are there stories about people who are not leaders? Is there a relationship between being-seen and startling and newsworthy transformations?
I think it an interesting question.

Crystal Watson
3 years 10 months ago

"God plans our steps from conception"? So, no free will? I was a volunteer at Planned Parenthood and Johnson's version of what happens there is nothing like what I experienced there. It would be really refreshing if for once there was a movie about an unplanned pregnancy that wasn't a conservative religious pro-life propaganda commercial.

Michael Schaefer
3 years 10 months ago

There aren't a whole lot of pro-life movies out there, which partly explain why the US is so fringe left on abortion in terms of policy. Most volunteers at most charities are shielded from the reality of what goes on inside. Unless you are on the board, you usually don't see much.

JR Cosgrove
3 years 10 months ago

There is a concerted effort to bury this movie. Twitter had banned the account (latter reinstated after protests). The networks will not accept ads for the movie.

Crystal Watson
3 years 10 months ago

Perhaps that's because the byline for the movie could be "disgruntled employee switches sides to cash in on extremist pro-life wave in flyover states". Religious conservatives do love their repentant sinful women.

Bob Goodwin
3 years 10 months ago

Hi Crystal, Iwould be interested to know if you saw the movie. From what I gathered from the movie if Abby had stayed a volunteer she would never have seen what was going on and I would think most volunteers would never know! Her experience changed as she moved up to Director. And as a side: I believe in man’s free will.

Bob Goodwin
3 years 10 months ago

Hi Crystal, Iwould be interested to know if you saw the movie. From what I gathered from the movie if Abby had stayed a volunteer she would never have seen what was going on and I would think most volunteers would never know! Her experience changed as she moved up to Director. And as a side: I believe in man’s free will.

Crystal Watson
3 years 10 months ago

1) I worked one summer as a volunteer. Fist I worked in the office answering phoned in questions. Later I worked as an aide in the vasectomy clinic. I wasn't "shielded" from anything. There was nothing "secret" going on. Abortion is a legal medical procedure, not some arcane diabolical rite hidden from the public. Of course, unless you worked in the clinic you would not be watching a procedure - medical procedures are not public events.
2) I find it incredible that Johnson worked for PP and yet had two abortions herself. How is it possible she was unaware or uncaring about unplanned pregnancies, when the major job of PP is contraception?

Crystal Watson
3 years 10 months ago

And BTW, there are some questions about the accuracy of Johnson's story ... The Convert

Lach Satsuma
3 years 10 months ago

Excellent story ! Well, some americans wonder why Margaret Sanger is still being celebrated ? As a non-american catholic I wonder why our hierarchs still believe and almost all of our universities teach such an irrational and anti-scientific hoax as macroevolution ? Darwinism is the source and heart of all sorts of "Sangers" and "Singers" !

The latest from america

A Reflection for the Memorial of St. Thomas Aquinas, Priest and Doctor of the Church, by Rachel Lu
Rachel LuJanuary 28, 2023
Pope Benedict XVI is accompanied by Cardinal George Pell of Sydney as he greets World Youth Day pilgrims at a welcoming ceremony at Barangaroo in Sydney, Australia, in this July 17, 2008, file photo. (CNS photo/Paul Haring)
Pope Benedict’s German biographer, Peter Seewald, confirmed that nine weeks before he died, Benedict revealed that insomnia was the “central motive” for his resignation.
Gerard O’ConnellJanuary 27, 2023
Russian recruits called up for military service walk along a platform before boarding a train in Omsk, Russia, on Nov. 27, 2022. (CNS photo/Alexey Malgavko, Reuters)
While representing Ukraine as an ice dancer in the Olympics, I made friends with many Russians. And I hope that one day my daughter can greet them in their own language.
Siobhan Heekin-CanedyJanuary 27, 2023
Should James Cameron have involved more Indigenous creatives in making a movie rooted in Native American history?
Kristin WestonJanuary 27, 2023