Graham Greene’s ‘The Quiet American’ argues that to write is to be political

(Wikimedia Commons)

“I had to find a measure my evil against.” So goes Graham Greene’s oft-quoted explanation for why he became a Catholic. Ever the contrarian, Greene hated being whatever he was labeled as—and rejected the claim of critics that he was concerned with a supernatural evil, saying his novels “are not about Good and Evil but about human beings.”

Greene was not a metaphysician. The Power and the Glory is pulpy Catholic fare: a priest on the run, in the heat of Mexico, whispering hope into a rural, folk Catholicism. “I don’t look for God up there,” Greene once said, “He’s down around here.”

I had to find a measure my evil against.

Down here. Embedded. Greene’s 1955 novel The Quiet American is narrated by Thomas Fowler, a British journalist living in Vietnam. But Fowler hates the word journalist: “I preferred the title of reporter. I wrote what I saw. I took no action—even an opinion is a kind of action.” Fowler claims to be the only objective voice in a tangled world. There is Alden Pyle, the young American C.I.A. agent who has read books on democracy and hopes to remake the East in an American image. There are the Caodaists—part Catholic, part Buddhist, part regionalists—the French colonizers and then the Communists. By the end of the book, we learn that Pyle’s American optimism is his undoing, and yet equally dangerous is Fowler’s feigned journalistic distance. Greene suggests that we can never be truly honest. No hands are clean.

At a moment when reporters and the entire culture and action of reporting are being criticized from all sides, The Quiet American feels painfully prescient. Early in 1954, Greene lived in Saigon as a correspondent for The New Republic. In his story for the magazine, he wrote that the First Indochina War “will be decided by men who never waded waist-deep in fields of paddy.” The Quiet American, as novels often do, adds even more complexity to that claim.

Greene’s complex novel is a scathing critique of the malleability of truth, the fallibility of perception and American ambition. Although Greene claims in a prefatory note, “this is a story and not a piece of history,” he wanted it both ways. We are left with a story about what it means to be engaged—or to do nothing in the face of evil.

It is strange to read Greene’s novel in the age of references to the amorphous “media,” as if all journalists are part of a cabalistic operation to suppress, or at least bend, truth. This is not to say that journalists are infallible; often the storytelling impulse to give readers a linear, causal narrative means forcing dots to connect. Fowler is correct: “An opinion is a kind of action,” and actions have consequences. For example, in May of this year, NBC News reported that the F.B.I. had wiretapped the phone of Michael Cohen, President Donald Trump’s former personal lawyer. That was a bombshell claim—implying that the F.B.I. had listened to every conversation. In reality, they had only been monitoring his calls—collecting the metadata of who was calling whom, but not the content of the conversations. The distinction is a big one, and that type of mistake hurts the credibility of other reporters (who are more meticulous).

Greene’s complex novel is a scathing critique of the malleability of truth and American ambition.

In The Quiet American, Greene’s genius lies in making Fowler both a wise observer and an imperfect character. Fowler carries the baggage of an old colonialist. He has paid for the sins of his forefathers with something like cynical exhaustion. His lover, a Vietnamese woman named Phuong, has fallen for Pyle. Fowler’s jealousy is teeming. His first-person narration constantly dismisses Pyle as more boy than man. Fowler recalls how they first met, Pyle’s “unmistakably young and unused face flung at us like a dart. With his gangly legs and his crew-cut and his wide campus gaze he seemed incapable of harm.”

Fowler, tired of it all, hates Pyle’s American idealism. Pyle “was do good, not to any individual person but to a country, a continent, a world.” Envy often blurs our ability to perceive, but sometimes it does offer precision. Pyle arrived in Vietnam convinced that “what the East needed was a Third Force.”

Fowler knew better. He knew that:

[Pyle] would have to learn for himself the real background that held you as a smell does: the gold of the rice-fields under a flat late sun: the fishers’ fragile cranes hovering over the fields like mosquitoes: the cups of tea on an old abbot’s platform, with his bed and his commercial characters, his buckets and broken cups and the junk of a lifetime washed up around his chair: the mollusc hats of the girls repairing the road where a mine had burst: the gold and the young green and the bright dresses of the south, and in the north the deep browns and the black clothes and the circle of enemy mountains and the drone of planes.

“Pyle believed in being involved,” Fowler writes, and as a reporter, he finds this troubling. Fowler even seems intimidated by Pyle’s wide-eyed optimism; “From childhood I had never believed in permanence, and yet I had longed for it.”

The Quiet American is a far less sentimental book than the ultimately pious The Power and the Glory, and Greene reveals Fowler’s hypocrisy. Fowler claims to have Phuong’s best interests at heart, but she is treated as an exotic object, a possession that has possessed him. “One always spoke of the third person as though she were not there,” Fowler writes. “Sometimes she seemed invisible like peace.” That peace is a fiction, and Pyle’s Third Force fumbles in its attempt to tip the scales of war.

When we write, when we report, we seek structure. We want to tell stories—that is what they are called in the business—and the best-loved stories are built on character, drama and plot. Fowler is on assignment in Vietnam to write about the war. In one scene, Fowler visits following a Vietminh attack in Phat Diem. A canal is full of overlapped bodies, “one head, seal-grey, and anonymous as a convict with a shaven scalp, stuck up out of the water like a buoy. There was no blood: I suppose it had flowed away a long time ago.”

By the end of The Quiet American, we learn that Fowler was very involved—with Vietnam and with Phuong’s and Pyle’s unfortunate end. About Pyle, Fowler says, “I never knew a man who had better motives for all the trouble he caused.” A great line; I think Greene delivered one-liners better than Hemingway (both reporters themselves, of course).

Involved or not, Fowler’s bias doesn’t get in the way of his clarity. When Pyle tries to convince him that the Vietnamese “don’t want Communism,” Fowler retorts: “They want enough rice. They don’t want to be shot at. They want one day to be much the same as another. They don’t want our white skins around telling them what they want.” Fowler knows his claim that he has no politics is false.

The Quiet American offers the truth that to write is to be political. When we hope to corral the madness of our world into a story, we polish the edges and exaggerate the heartbeats. We make the page a mirror.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Phillip Stone
2 years 1 month ago

OK, Greene was a flawed sinner and an indifferent writer. Yawn! What possible reality is there in his fictional characters, cardboard cut-out figures having little resemblances to real people?

The real Vietnam was peopled with a minority of indigenous who were willing to accept the promise of hope from atheistic Communism and the rest were Catholics and Buddhists very strongly against them.
Heroic efforts, expending much blood and treasure, brought the endeavour of establishing a democratic nation almost to the brink of success and scribblers back in the USA ruined it - multimedia is mightier than the sword, indeed.

During the many centuries in Christendom, the notions of treason, libel, sedition, perjury and blasphemy were recognised and included within the legal systems as grave crimes against justice and love.
Time they were all returned to the cultures and legal systems of the first world to balance the excesses of "freedom of speech

The liberty to speak truth to power, to declaim truth abroad, would not be constrained

Alan Martin
2 years ago

This article is actually a nice one it assists new web viewers and people who are wishing to learn blog writing. I have one top recommendation for best writing services for Essay Writing Service UK and Nursing Dissertation help

The latest from america

Wilton Gregory said he hopes Pope Francis will find him to be “supportive, encouraging and trustworthy” in his role as a cardinal, but his primary ministry is still to be the archbishop of Washington.
Join America Media as we prepare for the coming of our Lord with special daily Advent reflections on The Word podcast.
America StaffNovember 27, 2020
St. Francis’ poverty was not cold and brutal but actually, in a way, worldly. It was a poverty that anyone today searching for what is real and authentic might relate to.
Jason M. BaxterNovember 27, 2020
The image displays five photos of the five members of the prayer service's organizing committee: Moira Egan, a white woman in her 50s with dark hair (top left); Kathleen Friel, a white woman with short hair wearing glasses (top middle); Ricardo da Silva, S.J., a white man who is bald with a brown beard, wearing glasses (top right); Father John Mulreany, S.J., wearing clerical carb that is black, and glasses (bottom left); Allison Connelly, white woman, light brown hair and glasses (bottom right)
An New York City parish organized a fully accessible prayer service for people with disabilities, who even in the church are often forgotten on the margins.
Erika RasmussenNovember 27, 2020