What can Beyoncé and Pope Francis teach us about love?

Courtesy of Parkwood Entertainment via HBO. 

Two weeks after Pope Francis released “Amoris Laetitia,” another look into marriage and family life was released: Beyoncé’s “Lemonade.” On April 23, the singer released her sixth studio album as a one-hour HBO special. The album, which features music videos for every track, presents an unrelenting look into the singer’s 10-year marriage to Shawn “Jay Z” Carter. While comparing the world’s greatest living pop star to the leader of the Catholic world might seem like a stretch, both offer an important—often fundamentally different—look into love and marriage. And just as Pope Francis describes marriage as a means to gaze into the reality of God, Beyoncé’s brutally honest presentation of her marriage demonstrates how God is already present in pop culture and in a broken and redeemed marriage.

“A love that is weak or infirm, incapable of accepting marriage as a challenge to be taken up and fought for, reborn, renewed and reinvented until death, cannot sustain a great commitment,” Pope Francis writes in chapter four of “Amoris Laetitia.” In Beyoncé’s “Lemonade,” we explicitly see what it means to fight for—and be reborn in—love.

Advertisement

The album opens with “Pray You Catch Me.” The singer believes her husband has been unfaithful, singing: “You can taste the dishonesty, it’s all over your breath.../ Constantly aware of it all, my lonely ear/ Pressed against the walls of your world.” Her marriage, presented in stark contrast to her tightly controlled public image, is not perfect. There is distrust. There is heartache. There is the pain of a woman who no longer understands who her partner is, or what he is doing. She is vulnerable. She is broken. And she lays these insecurities in front of her audience.

In "Lemonade," self-love helps the singer move toward forgiveness. 

We then watch as the singer expresses her pride and anger. In “Hold Up” she proclaims, “They don’t love you like I love you.” And in “Don’t Hurt Yourself,” she yells, defiantly, “Who the f*** do you think I am?” and “When you love me, you love yourself/ Love God herself.” Beyoncé is, slowly but surely, moving away from the pain we first hear. In “Amoris Laetitia,” Francis states that self-love is significant because it is a “psychological prerequisite for being able to love others.” In “Lemonade,” self-love helps the singer move toward forgiveness.

Courtesy of Parkwood Entertainment via HBO.
Courtesy of Parkwood Entertainment via HBO. 

In the song “All Night,” we witness the conversion. Beyoncé sings: “True love breathes salvation back into me/ With every tear came redemption/ And my torturer became my remedy.” And, in the video for “Love Drought,” we watch as she wades through water, with nine black women behind her, all dressed in light blue garb. They join hands and lift their arms toward the sky. She sings: “you and me could move a mountain.../ you and me could calm a war down.../ you and me would stop this love drought.”

One of the most powerful themes in “Amoris Laetitia” is its focus on forgiveness. Francis states that forgiving is by no means easy, but it is paramount for a successful relationship bound by love and God, writing that “love also bears fruit in mercy and forgiveness.” Beyoncé has reached the point of forgiveness. She has baptized herself in these waters, she is a new woman, converted, capable of forgiveness, for she knows there is power in love.

Along with its depiction of love and marriage, “Lemonade” offers an explicit look into the experiences of black women. In the video for “Don’t Hurt Yourself,” we see scenes of various African-American women, as we hear Malcolm X’s famous line, “The most disrespected person in America is the black woman.” Whitewashing, which refers to the act of portraying characters or stories of color through a white lenses, is rampant in Hollywood. (We can turn to Scarlett Johansson in “A Ghost in the Shell” or Matt Damon in “The Great Wall” as examples.) Beyoncé places the focus squarely on the lived and shared experiences of black women in this country.

"Lemonade" and "Amoris Laetitia" demonstrate that love and marriage are messy. 

Nikole Hannah Jones, a staff writer for The New York Times, stated, “This was a very specific, particular type of femininity and type of struggle with love.” Throughout “Lemonade,” the singer takes her relationship with her husband and connects it to the larger shared experiences of black women. Candice Benbow, a doctoral student at Princeton Theological Seminary, created “The Lemonade Syllabus,” a tool that offers lists of works on topics like theology and womanism written by black women. Benbow said that following Beyoncé’s release, she wanted to continue “to introduce...other offerings from amazing Black women who tell...stories.”

For Yolanda Pierce, also at Princeton Theological Seminary, “Lemonade” is not just about the black, female experience—it is also about the ways in which these women live out their faith. Pierce describes the album as “equal parts ‘testimony service’ and Sunday morning worship.” It presents “the contrasting realities under which black Christian women live their religious lives,” Pierce claims, adding that it “gives [black women] a space to highlight the tensions of being a black Christian woman in America.”

And “Lemonade” is very rooted in Christian themes, from the baptismal water imagery to its emphasis on mercy, reconciliation and love. However, the album also borrows from other faiths, particularly “the traditional religions of the Yoruba in Africa and the Caribbean,” writes Pierce. She adds that this work shows “just one of the many expressions of faith that people of African descent brought with them during” the slave voyage from Africa to America. Beyoncé presents to her audience a Christianity that is diverse and syncretic.

Pope Francis reminds Christians that there must be “an effort to strengthen marriages, to help married couples overcome their problems” because the weakened marriages affect not just couples but “society as a whole.” While “Amoris Laetitia” provides Christians with a nuanced ecclesiastical look into marriage, Beyoncé provides a perspective from someone living and experiencing life in a marriage. From beginning to end, “Lemonade” and “Amoris Laetitia” demonstrate that love and marriage are messy. There will be moments of struggle when one might question love—and even question God. There can be moments of infidelity, moments which cause disappointment and heartache.

And that is O.K. It is not meant to be easy. Together, both works demonstrate that marriage and family life, when rooted in God and love, are not meant to be perfect. They are meant to be real.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Tom Fields
7 months 2 weeks ago

I am amazed that you would compare Beyonce to the Pope--or find her life or lyrics to be "redeeming". First----this is a woman whose lyrics are often "R" rated----at least---who sang about having her man--"Lewinsky" all over her dress in the back of the limo". I know that she is an Obama favorite---but for anybody raising children--especially girls--she is a horrible role model. And---there are far better studies of the Black female experience---although they are not millionaires.

Tom Fields
7 months 2 weeks ago

It just occurred to me----do any of the Priests at "AMERICA"---have any idea who Beyonce is??

Dominic Deus
7 months 2 weeks ago

Tom fields--First, thank you for taking the time to comment!

Aside from the fact that is not for us men to decide who speaks and how for some of the most tortured feelings in a woman's heart, Beyonce's artistry in conveying her empathy with marginalized women is nothing if not the musical illumination of Pope Francis' frequent and life long preaching of mercy. Just a couple of quick asides: 1) President Obama has two daughters and a wife who finds Beyonce' admirable, 2) Life is "R" rated, and 3) That would be "billionaire" with a "b."

I, Dominic, may be 500 years old, but I do know who Beyonce' is. ;-)

James MacGregor
7 months 1 week ago

The title of the article suggests sources of information on the subject (I.e., love) that are both irrelevant.

Vince Killoran
7 months 1 week ago

I'm still puzzling out this analysis but trying to keep an open mind. The snarky comments aren't constructive.

Therese Trinko
7 months 1 week ago

First off, I would like to say I was so happy to see this article because I both love Beyoncé and Pope Francis. I agree when you mentioned this is a bit of a stretch, but I believe a large reason why Beyonce is such a popular artist is her honesty, which is obviously very Christ like as He is the Truth. I would just like to comment on your last line which I may be misinterpreting, but which I read as an idea that we shouldn't strive for perfection, and rather accept "real" or natural, post original sin, imperfection. While we shouldn't despair, Christ does tell us to "Be perfect, as your Heavenly Father is perfect" (Matthew 5:48). If, however, I am misinterpreting what you said, I apologize for the correction. Thank you for finding and sharing goodness from a variety of surprising sources!

Fran Rossi Szpylczyn
7 months 1 week ago

As an older (late 50's- very late), white, Catholic woman, I will begin by thanking Olga Segura for writing this, and America Magazine for publishing this. What an important piece. If there is any hallmark of the Catholic imagination, in particular the Ignatian Catholic imagination, it would be the ability to see God in the most unexpected places. And in Beyonce and Lemonade, there is so much to be seen.

John Fitzpatrick
6 months 2 weeks ago

Since we are now to entertain the idea that Beyonce is emulating the Pope with her Lemonade album, then the Editors of this magazine should have no problem printing the lyrics from the song, "Don't Hurt Yourself" which appears on the album (polite sarcasm). I am certain Beyonce is an extremely talented performer and probably a good mother, spouse and person. That being said, don't you think it is a bit too cool to compare her to the Pope? Besides, our priority should be to grant Chuck Berry sainthood for writing "Johnny be Good."

Advertisement

Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

A 14-year-old boy receives medical treatment at Suez Canal University hospital in Ismailia, Egypt, Friday, Nov. 24, 2017, after he was in injured during an attack on a mosque (AP Photo/Amr Nabil).
The pope described the attack as a “wanton act of brutality directed at innocent civilians gathered in prayer.”
Gerard O’ConnellNovember 24, 2017
“The Senate proposal is fundamentally flawed as written and requires amendment,” said Bishop Frank J. Dewane in a Nov. 22 letter to senators.
Pope Francis greets people at the “Regional Hub,” a government-run processing center for migrants, refugees and asylum seekers, in Bologna, Italy, Oct. 1. (CNS photo/L’Osservatore Romano)
Although he named no countries, Vatican observers believe he is referring especially to political leaders in several western and eastern European countries.
Gerard O’ConnellNovember 24, 2017
For Thanksgiving, we give you an inside look into what Jesuit basketball teams to watch out for this season.
Olga SeguraNovember 24, 2017