Whom do you trust to get the job done?

The most trusted institution in the United States, keeping watch in front of the least trusted institution. (iStock/inhauscreative)The most trusted institution in the United States, keeping watch in front of the least trusted institution. (iStock/inhauscreative)

Only 58 percent of U.S. Catholics feel that their religious leaders take responsibility for their mistakes at least some of the time, according to a new Pew Research Center report—a notable exception to the generally warm feelings towards U.S. religious leadership.

About three-quarters of U.S. adults said that religious leaders do their jobs well at least some of the time.

Asked about five functions of leadership positions, a significant majority of U.S. adults who responded to the December 2018 survey said that religious leaders performed four of them “well,” at least “some of the time.” The fifth criterion—the outlier—was religious leaders’ ability to admit and take responsibility for mistakes.


Overall, 50 percent of respondents felt that religious leaders admit and take responsibility for mistakes at least some of the time. Only 30 percent of religiously unaffiliated adults agreed with the statement, but the 58 percent among Catholics was the lowest of any major religious affiliation. It is unclear how these numbers have changed in the wake of the sexual abuse crisis since this survey is the first of its kind conducted by Pew.

Respondents were most likely to say that members of Congress had ethical failings.

The data on attitudes toward religious leadership was part of a larger study conducted by Pew on the question of institutional trust in the United States. The survey asked about numerous types of authority figures, including members of Congress, military leaders and journalists. Among these groups, U.S. adults felt that members of Congress were most likely to act unethically, with eight in ten responding that members of Congress act unethically at least some of the time.

Only 30 percent of the religiously unaffiliated said that religious leaders admit mistakes at least some of the time. That figure was 58 percent among Catholics and 68 percent among evangelical Protestants.

Military leaders were the most trusted to “fulfill key aspects of their missions” at least some of the time. Religious leaders were rated below police officers and leaders of technology companies but ahead of K-12 public school principals, journalists and local elected officials. Dead last by this metric were members of Congress.

Source: “Why Americans Don’t Fully Trust Many Who Hold Positions of Power and Responsibility,” Pew Research Center, Sept. 19, 2019.

[Want to discuss politics with other America readers? Join our Facebook discussion group, moderated by America’s writers and editors.]

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
JR Cosgrove
9 months 1 week ago

These numbers are pretty damning. But yet I bet the same people doing the rating could not point to another place in the world that is more ethical or more caring about their constituency


The latest from america

The latest letter is the most recent attempt by church leaders to convince Congress to support families who choose to send their children to nonpublic schools.
Catholic News ServiceAugust 06, 2020
Joanely Martinez displays a sign—"I want to go out...to run, to walk, to enjoy myself without violence, without fear"—during the women's march on March 8, 2020, in Mexico City. She said the government "does nothing" to protect women, who are demanding the authorities do more to stop the murder of women and girls. (CNS photo/David Agren)
Mexico has long been plagued by often brutal violence against women and children. Just under 11 women are killed on average each day in Mexico because of gender-based violence.
Jan-Albert HootsenAugust 06, 2020
Today we mark 75 years since the United States became the first nation in history to attack an enemy with an atomic bomb, leveling the city of Hiroshima and killing 140,000 people.
Ashley McKinlessAugust 06, 2020
Surveying the world from beneath the columns of the Academy of Athens, in Greece. (iStock/sarra22)
It is a myth that a degree in philosophy is “worthless,” writes Kristina Grob. Not only does it provide job skills, studying philosophy helps us to clarify the values guiding our lives.
Kristina GrobAugust 06, 2020