Catholic leaders gather to ask: Can Catholic social teaching overcome polarization?

Georgetown University in Washington hosted public dialogue about "Overcoming Polarization in a Divided Nation Through Catholic Social Thought.". (CNS photo/Tyler Orsburn)

WASHINGTON (CNS) -- Sister Teresa Maya grew up hearing her "abuela" say, "People understand each other by speaking to one another."

In her grandmother's wisdom, she said, lies a way to address the polarization that seems to affect every aspect of U.S. society today.

Advertisement

Fostering "encuentros," or encounters, on the personal level and people "really being interested in the other side of the story" would go a long way to encourage folks with different opinions to dialogue about all manner of issues with civility, she told an audience at Georgetown University June 4.

Sister Maya, a Sister of Charity of the Incarnate Word from San Antonio, is president of the Leadership Conference of Women Religious. She was one of four speakers at the public session of a June 4-6 invitation-only conference on "Though Many, One: Overcoming Polarization Through Catholic Social Thought."

Organizers said the conference was meant to be a starting point to bring about Pope Francis' vision of the church responding to human hurts and social challenges by living out the joy of the Gospel.

Joining Sister Maya on the panel were Helen Alvare, professor of law at George Mason University's Antonin Scalia Law School in Arlington, Virginia; Chicago Cardinal Blase J. Cupich; and Los Angeles Archbishop Jose H. Gomez, vice president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops.

Moderator John Carr, director of the Initiative on Catholic Social Thought at Georgetown, asked the audience to "check your impulses" at the door as far as trying to decide which panelists were "conservative" or "liberal."

He asked them to consider who among the speakers "has stood up for the dignity and lives of the unborn" and for women, the vulnerable, immigrants, the poor and families and "against violence in our communities."

Moderator John Carr asked the audience to "check your impulses" at the door as far as trying to decide which panelists were "conservative" or "liberal."

"It's really a trick question. Every one of these people has stood up for" all those groups, said Carr.

He asked the speakers what they see as "the major cause or cost of polarization" in the country and how the principles of Catholic social thought could help everyone work for the common good.

"The fear of the other has poisoned our souls. ... We've allowed it to divide us," said Sister Maya, who noted that as an immigrant herself, from Mexico, she brings "a migrant's view to this conversation."

She grew up with a deep fascination of the American idea that all people are created equal, that life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness are human rights that cannot be taken away. In entering religious life, she said, she was convinced Jesus held the clues to create a world where these truths would hold for all.

She still believes in this "narrative of human rights" but said it "is threatened because we live in a polarized society."

"We stay in our bubbles, with people we know," feeding our fears, when "we must realize we breathe the same air," she said. "Unless you can get to know the other, it can justify the most terrible thing. … The antidote to fear is hope."

"The fear of the other has poisoned our souls."

Archbishop Gomez said Pope Francis talks a lot about how his pontificate is "not only a change of era" but how this is "an era of change. Everything is changing."

The "simple and most obvious thing" contributing to polarization is "the internet," he said. It is making talking to each other more difficult. Secularization also a major factor, he said.

"We are used to a Christian culture," the archbishop said. "We assume that's the way it is, but the whole country is becoming more and more secular." He also took issue with the prevailing notion that faith and science are incompatible.

"This nation is saying, 'We trust science more than we trust faith,' like there's a contradiction between science and faith, and that's not real," the archbishop said.

Against this backdrop, it is "important to understand who we are, who God is, how we can relate to God," he continued. Catholics are called "to become missionary disciples, to go out of our comfort (zone) and be united as a people and bring the teachings of our Lord Jesus Christ to our people. Everything is based on God's plan for humanity, for each one of us."

 Catholics are called "to become missionary disciples, to go out of our comfort zone."

In addressing current social realities, he said, U.S. Catholics can learn from the church's approach in Latin America. He noted that Pope Francis, being Latin American, follows this "see-judge-act" method of discernment: Seeing what current social realities are, judging them in light of the church's social teaching, then acting to make those realities more just.

Cardinal Cupich also talked about fear as a major factor causing polarization, describing "merchants of fear" actively working in society today.

If you watch kids of different backgrounds playing together, you see "they are not afraid" of one another, the cardinal said. "We are taught to be afraid and we have to own that."

The cost of polarization, he said, "is the division we face in our nation. We are not just separated by ideas but into groups. That's the difference between partisanship and polarization. Partisans used to be able to get things done, to reach across the aisle. But we are polarized, we have our own sources of information."

Such division leads to lawmakers not getting anything done legislatively and people dehumanizing "the other" through rhetoric that is anti-immigrant and racist, he added.

U.S. Catholics can learn from the church's approach in Latin America.

"I think we often refuse to credit different 'gifts'" people bring to the discussion on issues, and so fail to learn from one another, said Alvare. Society being so materialistic also sharply divides people, which is coupled with the fact people are short on time and patience, she added.

"The shortage of time is very much related to economic life," Alvare added. "We don't have time to be patient with people" and listen to other views.

She described receiving violent hate mail in reaction to comments she has made on the human costs of the sexual revolution and how poor women especially are suffering the consequences of this revolution.

Alvare said sharp disagreement is good but people also need to have good facts and sources, and they must pay attention to "tone, tone, tone" when they talk to one another, she said.

"If you feel dizzy and out of whack" in this polarized society, she said, "Catholic social teaching insights would help account for what we're feeling and also (help us) find a way forward."

On moving forward, Sister Maya said that will not happen until the country has an honest conversation about "the unresolved issue of racism," which she said is "at the heart of U.S. polarization."

She also said these times call for "contemplative dialogue," and people need to learn tools to listen deeply for common ground, respect silence and employ an "economy of words." Sister Maya also said lessons on how to dialogue can be learned from how LCWR leaders before her and church officials in Rome, during the Vatican probe of the leadership organization eventually could find common ground and reach an understanding and respect for each side's views.

To move forward on the immigration issue, Archbishop Gomez said "what we all need to see" is that "immigrants are people -- men and women, children, boys and girls." Talk about the nation's legal principles is one thing, he said, "but we must "see these people are just like us" and are coming here "for a better life."

Carr asked if Pope Francis is bringing a new kind of leadership to applying Catholic social thought to today's realities or whether he is continuing the leadership of his predecessors.

Cardinal Cupich replied with a quote he said he has often heard that "captures the continuity": "John Paul II told us what to do, Benedict said why we should do it and Pope Francis says, 'Do it.' … Pope Francis is … really an activist pope wanting to make the church a field hospital."

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
JR Cosgrove
1 year 11 months ago

One has to ask what good will Catholic Social Teaching perform? It doesn't have a good track record as nearly all of Latin America, the most Catholic area of the world, is the most violent and poor. The author uses Latin America as a positive example. I am not sure that is a good idea.

It is interesting that all these immigrants are escaping Catholic Social Teaching in Latin America to come to the United States.

Christopher Lochner
1 year 11 months ago

"See-judge-act" , fine. And when Francis is wrong, then what? Oh, right, Francis is never wrong. A serious question: Are we to assume that the discernment of Pope Francis is incapable of resulting in error?

Phillip Stone
1 year 11 months ago

Oh dear, we seem to have people believing we were given a successor to Peter who is overturning centuries of error of praxis in the Vatican courtiers and bureaucrats and turning his ear to cultural Marxist social justice warriors believing in the perfectibility of humankind.

Did Our Lord intend His fellowship of believers to eliminate polarisation amongst human beings from then and down the ages?

Leave the dead to bury the dead.
I come not to bring peace but a sword.
render to Caesar ... to God ...

What is the other side of the story of a medically qualified person living privileged in the first world, enabled and equipped to heal, repair, console and comfort the ill but choosing to daily use knowledge and skill to kill baby after baby not yet born?
What is the other side of the story of the committed jihadi doing mass murder to the glory of his god?

In response to the headline, in one word, no!

rose-ellen caminer
1 year 11 months ago

We commit mass murder to the glory of OUR god, Americanism [lol].In the past to the glory of our Church .Much of what is jihad is perceived as justified defensive wars, as we unjustly have meddled over there. Some like ISIS are psychopaths ,many are western converts,. like gangs or thugs, disaffected people on the fringes of mental health and society. And God = God, Allah means God, Muslims believe and pray to God, whether you like that or not, believe it or not! You are bearing false witness , in stating otherwise.

Advertisement

The latest from america

This week on "Inside the Vatican," the hosts discuss the Holy See's opposition to a U.S.-backed proposal for Israel to annex up to 30 percent of the West Bank.
Colleen DulleMay 27, 2020
For the Catholic community, the penetrating vision of the Second Vatican Council identifies a clear pathway of public engagement and conscience formation.
Blase J. CupichMay 26, 2020
St. John Paul II greets Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew in 2002. Marking the 25th anniversary of St. John Paul II's encyclical on Christian unity, Pope Francis said he shares "the healthy impatience" of those who think more can and should be done, but he also insisted that Christians must be grateful for the progress made. (CNS photo/Reuters)
“One thing is certain,” Pope Francis writes. “Unity is not chiefly the result of our activity, but a gift of the Holy Spirit. Yet, unity will not come about as a miracle at the very end. Rather, unity comes about in journeying.”
Gerard O’ConnellMay 26, 2020
Pope Francis prays at a replica of the Lourdes Grotto in the Vatican Gardens in this 2013 file photo. Pope Francis will pray there May 30, the eve of Pentecost, leading the major shrines around the world in praying the rosary to implore Mary's intercession and protection amid the coronavirus pandemic. (CNS photo/L'Osservatore Romano)
The pope will pray at the replica of the Lourdes Grotto in the Vatican Gardens May 30, the eve of Pentecost, and will also be joined by several "men and women representing various categories of people particularly affected by the virus."