Teens posted photos of a ‘Jews vs. Nazis’ drinking game. How should their Catholic school respond?

Adolescent misbehavior at St. Teresa’s Academy, a private, Catholic high school for girls in Kansas City, Mo., has created a mountain of trouble for administrators. First their students got them into hot water, then alumnae and parents turned up the heat. Those working at the school must feel pretty well-cooked now. The drama has yet to die down.

The trouble began when nine students at a weekend party played “Jews vs. Nazis” beer pong and posted a picture of themselves on Snapchat posed next to plastic cups arranged in the form of a swastika. The heading was “Girls Night!” When they refused to take down the picture, one student reported their conduct to school administrators.

Advertisement

As punishment, the girls at the party received a one-day, in-school suspension, were barred from extracurricular activities for a week and were required to notify the college of their choice of the incident. Some alumnae and parents were outraged that the school did not mete out harsher penalties, with most of the ire generated by the picture of the swastika—backwards as it happens, apparently out of ignorance—rather than by the drinking. There were rumblings that athletic ability and the affluent background of some of the girls involved may have led to undue leniency by school officials.

All of this is getting a lot of attention in the press, fed by alumnae and students turning to the media to vent. The Kansas City Starnewspaper reported receiving more than a dozen complaints from alumnae, parents and current students calling for the expulsion of the offending students.In a subsequent story, the Star ran a lengthy article about an African-American student at St. Teresa’s Academy who spoke about the racist slights she has experienced as a black student in a predominantly white school.

A public relations nightmare has unfolded for the school. The story of an elite Catholic girls school as a bastion of intolerance is nigh on irresistible, and the mediahasnot resisted. The story has gone viral, receiving national and even international press. In early October KCUR radio, which has covered the story extensively, aired a half-hour radio show on the beer pong episode, which was discussed as a disturbing example of hate speech.

Are teenagers playing a drinking game, in which teams line up beer cups in the shape of a swastika and a Star of David, hate-filled bigots? Before reaching for such a label, the most damning one can apply in this society, one might consider other adjectives that may more accurately describe the schoolgirls in the case. Take your pick from “thoughtless,” “culturally insensitive,” “historically obtuse,” “disrespectful,” “politically naive.” Teenagers are not, of course, known for sober reflection, careful behavior, historical perspective, respectfulness or political savvy. Besides under-age drinking, which none of the outrage seems focused on, what is the crime? Is it anti-Semitism, or is it stupidity?

It may be bigotry is the only sin our society recognizes as such. Stoning sinners is a popular practice in every age. Many in the wider St. Teresa’s Academy community have taken it up with zeal. The invective of some alumnae on the school’s Facebook page is scorching. Lost in the almost hysterical outcry over the incident is any sense of proportion. The Holocaust has been trivialized, and not only by teenagers playing flippantly with the symbols of a regime that killed millions. The teenagers failed to understand the gravity and power of the symbols they played with; the adults condemning them are confusing symbol for substance. They seem unable to distinguish between degrees of error, between mistakes of ignorance and crimes of intention.

Careless teens, a sensationalizing media and an overwrought public have dragged the name of St. Teresa’s Academy through the mud. Yes, school officials could have come up with more apt punishment for the drinking teens—I think they did go light on the them—but overall they have been more sinned against than sinning and steadfast in their insistence the school practice the Christian forgiveness it preaches. School authorities have been let down, not so much by the poor judgment of their students, which is to be expected from teens, as by furious alumnae and parents demanding they purge transgressors from the ranks.

This fall will be a busy time at St. Teresa’s Academy. There is a forum on hate speech and white nationalist groups for students to attend, a film about Holocaust survivor Sonia Warshawski, a visit from the Anne Frank Center for Mutual Respect, a book club being formed for parents and board members to read the book Some of My Best Friends Are Black and numerous other initiatives aimed at making students more sensitive to victims of persecution. All of that is well and good, but to encompass all that has gone on, a couple of classics could be added to the syllabus. The Crucible is one possibility; The Scarlet Letter is another.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Henry Smith
3 weeks 6 days ago

Given it was a private party one can wonder what right the school
had to punish the participants.

Given we are talking about teenagers we are really talking about
children - keep in mind their "average age" is about 8 years old.

Given it is a form of prejudice to be bigoted against Bigots that you
disagree with, one can wonder what to do about bigots you agree with,
the whole issue is a farrago.

Tim Donovan
3 weeks 6 days ago

For most of my working life as a Special Education teacher for six years and other jobs working with disabled. people, I've worked primarily with black people, many of whom were immigrants from Liberia, who fled their homeland due to a brutal civi l war. I have known people (friends, neighbors, and co-workers). of different faiths and cultures, and though I'm a white gay Catholic who, although certainly imperfect, I believe in Church teaching. I'm disturbed by the anti -semitic behavior of these teens. Although I certainly engaged in immoral behavior as a teen, I never had any negative feelings towards people of different races or religions. I think the school administrators responded appropriately. I think their efforts to educate all the students about the victims. of persecution is commendable.

Derrick Weiller
3 weeks 2 days ago

Nicely said, Tim.
Thoughtful; balanced; reasonable.

Anne Chapman
3 weeks 4 days ago

Yes, the administration did not do enough - a bare fingerslap. They are supposed to be teaching these girls, not just shrugging their shoulders and doing the minimum - kids will be kids. Well, that's the same type of thing we hear when the star football players assault a girl - boys will be boys. You too are taking this very lightly. These girls are getting ready to go to college. They are not naive little children. The girls showed no remorse it seems, when it was pointed out that the "game" and symbolism were beyond distasteful, but represented bigotry, they "refused to take down the picture".

You say the fall is busy at the school - But it is highly doubtful that any of the programs listed would have been scheduled without the publicly expressed outrage of alumnae and other parents, as reported in the media. It's too bad that none of this was part of the school's curriculum to begin with. It's also too bad that they apparently are not in touch with their minority students, have not asked them about how they are treated by fellow students. I have personal experience with elite Catholic schools, and the favor the teachers and administrators bestow on the children of the wealthy and influential is a black mark on some private Catholic education. Expulsion would have been too harsh, but the bare slap on the fingers essentially told the students that bigotry is not really a very serious sin.

There is a forum on hate speech and white nationalist groups for students to attend, a film about Holocaust survivor Sonia Warshawski, a visit from the Anne Frank Center for Mutual Respect, a book club being formed for parents and board members to read the book Some of My Best Friends Are Black and numerous other initiatives aimed at making students more sensitive to victims of persecution.

Overdue, but a start.

Ellen B
3 weeks 2 days ago

I saw many comments from current students & alumnae that drinking, per school guidelines, should have merited suspension. In fact, one of the examples given was of a student (in this school year) who was suspended for leaving campus to have lunch at McDonalds. There were also reports that the student who reported the incident was harassed. None of the reports mention the students telling their chosen universities about the incidents, in fact, the reports mention that nothing was applied to their permanent record.

It's unfair to describe the other students & alumnae of St Teresa's as "overwrought". In fact, this incident gives St Teresa's the chance to do better & to bring concerns about the direction of the school to light.

I'll save my pity for the 6 million who died, not the spoiled teenagers who know better.

Advertisement

Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

In response to a query from America, Steve Bannon said, “The daily examen has become a tool for me to lead a better, more fulfilled life.”
James T. KeaneNovember 17, 2017

America asked readers through our email newsletter and social media platforms what they do for their loved ones who have died. Seventy-eight percent of readers described how they memorialize loved ones with photos and other objects.

Our readersNovember 17, 2017
Hipsters love the authentic, the craft and the obscure—which is exactly why Catholicism, in its practices and its aesthetic, is perfectly suited for them.
Zac DavisNovember 17, 2017
As a Catholic, you continually search for the balance in your professional and spiritual life. Whatever balance you do achieve is far from perfect.
Brian FahertyNovember 16, 2017