Pope Francis tells Belgian Brothers of Charity no more euthanasia for patients

Activists protest against the proposed statutory amendment legalizing the euthanasia of young children in 2014 in Brussels. Belgium's Catholic bishops welcomed a statement by top medical professors, psychiatrists and ethicists, who rejected a recent proposal to allow euthanasia for patients facing "psychological suffering." (CNS photo/Julien Warnand, EPA)

MANCHESTER, England (CNS) -- Pope Francis has given a Belgian religious order until the end of August to stop offering euthanasia to psychiatric patients.

Brother Rene Stockman, superior general of the order, told Catholic News Service the pope gave his personal approval to a Vatican demand that the Brothers of Charity, which runs 15 centers for psychiatric patients across Belgium, must reverse its policy by the end of August.


Brothers who serve on the board of the Brothers of Charity Group, the organization that runs the centers, also must each sign a joint letter to their superior general declaring that they "fully support the vision of the magisterium of the Catholic Church, which has always confirmed that human life must be respected and protected in absolute terms, from the moment of conception till its natural end."

Brothers who refuse to sign will face sanctions under canon law, while the group can expect to face legal action and even expulsion from the church if it fails to change its policy.

The group, he added, must no longer consider euthanasia as a solution to human suffering under any circumstances.

The group must no longer consider euthanasia as a solution to human suffering under any circumstances.

The order, issued at the beginning of August, follows repeated requests for the group to drop its new policy of permitting doctors to perform the euthanasia of "nonterminal" mentally ill patients on its premises.

It also follows a joint investigation by the Vatican's congregations for the Doctrine of the Faith and for Institutes of Consecrated Life and Societies of Apostolic Life.

Brother Stockman, who had opposed the group's euthanasia policy, told Catholic News Service the ultimatum was devised by the two congregations and has the support of the pope.

"The Holy Father was formally informed about it and was also informed about the steps to be taken," he said in an Aug. 8 email.

The ultimatum, he said, meant the group's policies must be underpinned by a belief that "respect for human life is absolute."

Brother Stockman told CNS that if the group refused to bow to the ultimatum "then we will take juridical steps in order to force them to amend the text (of the new policy) and, if that is not possible, then we have to start the procedure to exclude the hospitals from the Brothers of Charity family and take away their Catholic identity."

He said if any of the brothers refused to sign the letter upholding Catholic teaching against euthanasia, "then also we will start the correct procedure foreseen in canon law."

The Belgian bishops and the nuncio to Belgium have been informed about the ultimatum, he added.

Brother Stockman, a psychiatric care specialist, had turned to the Vatican in the spring after the Brothers of Charity group rejected a formal request from him to reverse the new policy.

The group also snubbed the Belgian bishops by formally implementing its euthanasia policy in June, just weeks after the bishops declared they would not accept euthanasia in Catholic institutions.

The group implemented its euthanasia policy after the bishops declared they would not accept euthanasia in Catholic institutions.

The group has also ignored a statement of church teaching forbidding euthanasia. The statement, written and signed by Cardinal Gerhard Muller, former head of the doctrinal congregation, was sent to the Brothers of Charity Group members. A copy of the document has been obtained Catholic News Service.

The Brothers of Charity was founded in 1807 in Ghent, Belgium, by Father Peter Joseph Triest, whose cause for beatification was opened in 2001. Their charism is to serve the elderly and the mentally ill.

Today, the group is considered the most important provider of mental health care services in the Flanders region of Belgium, where they serve 5,000 patients a year.

About 12 psychiatric patients in the care of the Brothers of Charity are believed to have asked for euthanasia over the past year, with two transferred elsewhere to receive the injections to end their lives.

The group first announced its euthanasia policy in March, saying it wished to harmonize the practices of the centers with the Belgian law on euthanasia passed in 2003, the year after the Netherlands became the first country to permit the practice since Nazi Germany.

Technically, euthanasia in Belgium remains an offense, with the law protecting doctors from prosecution only if they abide by specific criteria, but increasingly lethal injections are given to the disabled and mentally ill. Since 2014 "emancipated children" have also qualified for euthanasia.

Increasingly lethal injections are given to the disabled and mentally ill.

The group's change in policy came about a year after a private Catholic rest home in Diest, Belgium, was fined $6,600 for refusing the euthanasia of a 74-year-old woman suffering from lung cancer.

Catholic News Service has approached the Brothers of Charity Group for a comment.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Tim Donovan
1 year 5 months ago

I commend Pope Francis for his staunch defense of vulnerable human beings. As an imperfect gay Catholic who in the past has violated church teaching regarding gay sex, I have found forgiveness and consolation through the Sacrament of Reconciliation with several compassionate priests. I understand the difficulty involved in caring for someone who is terminally ill. With the assistance of my parents and hospice staff, I did my best to care for my terminally ill aunt who died peacefully in a coma in 1994. I know two people who have the mental illness of schizophrenia. (One is my brother-in-law Thom's brother; the other is an acquaintance). As a retired Special Education teacher who taught severely disabled students, some of whom had behavior disorders, I found my job to be challenging but fulfilling, and I believe such people, though they often experience difficult lives, deserve the right to life. As someone who was encouraged to minor in psychology in college, I know that schizophrenia is a particularly cruel mental illness, but with medication, emotional support and love I think such people can experience worthwhile lives. Also, I have the mental illness of obsessive compulsive disorder, for which I had brain surgery and have been hospitalized, most frequently in a Catholic hospital osychiatric ward. I also in past years from time to time visited the psychiatruc ward to offer both spirtual and material support to the patients. I believe that human life is full of both joy and sorrow, but is worth the trials that we face; at least this is my opinion, as someone who had a friend who ended her life by suicide in 1994. It took me some years to recover from the tragic death of my friend. I also attempted suicide several times due to severe depression brought on by my sexual orientation. However, I'm glad that I'm still living, and find meaning in my imperfect life.


The latest from america

An extraordinary minister of the holy Eucharist distributes Communion during Mass at Transfiguration Church in the Williamsburg section of Brooklyn, N.Y. (CNS photo/Gregory A. Shemitz)
According to a report released by the Center for Applied Research in the Apostolate at Georgetown University on Jan. 22, just 33 percent of bishops in the United States think the church “should” ordain women as deacons.
Michael J. O’LoughlinJanuary 22, 2019

When the poet Mary Oliver died last week at the age of 83, my social media feeds blossomed into a field of tributes.

Lisa AmplemanJanuary 22, 2019
Most of the undocumented immigrants who are in the United States have overstayed a visa and did not cross the border illegally, according to a new analysis from the Center of Migration Studies.
J.D. Long-GarcíaJanuary 22, 2019
The church is my home because my home was a domestic church.
Katie Prejean McGradyJanuary 22, 2019