Ultimate relief from mandate may lie beyond the courts, say plaintiffs

On the eve of the March 23 oral arguments before the Supreme Court in Zubik v. Burwell, best known as the Little Sisters of the Poor case, two plaintiffs appealed the case in the court of public opinion and hinted that a political solution might be their ultimate redress.

Robert J. Muise, a co-founder and senior counsel of the American Freedom Law Center, which represents Priests for Life, called the contraceptive mandate of the Affordable Care Act "clearly a case of material cooperation with evil," but conceded that the court may not rule in favor of the women religious and 36 other plaintiffs.


If that occurs, then it will be up to the election of a pro-life president—Muise didn't mention any candidates—who could end the mandate through either executive action or by extending an exemption for nonprofit organizations who object to the mandate on religious grounds. Churches already have the exemption.

"Ultimately," said Father Frank Pavone, national director of Priests for Life, "the solution is the elections and moving the elections in the right way."

They made their remarks March 22 during an afternoon news conference at the National Press Club.

The contraceptive mandate of the Affordable Care Act requires most employers, including religious employers, to cover contraceptives, sterilization and abortifacients through their employee health insurance.

The Department of Health and Human Services has offered what it calls an "accommodation" or "work-around" that allows objecting employers to acknowledge their opposition to contraceptive coverage by notifying HHS in a letter. This triggers an arrangement for a third party to provide the coverage.

Priests for Life and the other defendants regard that process as a burden on the free exercise of religion.

"Catholic faith, Catholic priests, Catholic objection, but the government is dividing us on the basis of what? Classification under the tax code," Father Pavone said.

John Quincy Masteller, general counsel for Thomas Aquinas College in Santa Paula, California, complained that the government has drawn the religious exemption "more narrowly than ever before," defining it as simply the right to worship without government interference. The Catholic college faces fines of up to $2.8 million a year if it does not comply with the mandate.

"This is not about what we do in church on Sunday," Father Pavone said. "It's also to be free in what we do in business every other day of the week."

Other appellants include East Texas Baptist University, Southern Nazarene University and Geneva College, a Presbyterian institution, and the Archdiocese of Washington, and the dioceses of Pittsburgh and Erie, Pennsylvania.

All cite the Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1993 in their defense.

RFRA, as the law is called, states that the government "shall not substantially burden a person's exercise of religion" unless that burden is the least restrictive means to further a compelling governmental interest. 

Participants in an evening prayer rally on the steps of the Supreme Court included, Alveda King, director of the Priests for Life African-American outreach program, Civil Rights for the Unborn.

"God is always with us," she said in a brief interview after having given testimony, prayed and sung at the rally.

"God is ever present. In times of darkness and in times of light," she told Faith Magazine, the publication of the Diocese of Erie, Pennsylvania. "We just have to stand firm. God is with us for justice, and for our religious freedoms in this land."

King, the niece of the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr., is a plaintiff in the Priests for Life case, one of seven bundled into the Zubik v Burwell case, along with that of the Diocese of Erie. She also planned to speak at a rally taking place outside the court as the justices heard oral arguments in the case the next morning.

Father Pavone said it was "historic that a member of the King family is once again defending civil rights in the U.S. Supreme Court."

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
William Rydberg
2 years 6 months ago
It's a shame in my opinion that American Catholic Intellectuals have ceased to discuss even the possibility of changing the political system. Work to save the American Republic and the Freedom for which it stands... Remember Catholic American President John Kennedy, a great American in my opinion. You know.... There is a French word called "Vendu" meaning "sold" that applies here which you folks from New Orleans would quickly understand. it describes the residue (legacy/lethargy) after selling out American Catholic values in exchange for federal government "strings attached" money and the attitude that no quest to change the System is needed. Rather, just select the lesser of moral evils. That Catholics should keep that "sin" talk to ourselves...so wrong! Which is why the "Vendu"s are in the tank for Hillary in 2016, with respect to Catholic Moral teaching. Where is the American Catholic Intelligencia? American Jesuits remember GC35, be change leaders! Listen to Pope Francis! Just my opinion in The Risen Christ, Blessed be the Holy Trinity


The latest from america

Father Michael Nixon and parishioner work a volunteer table at St. Dominic Catholic Church in Panama City, Fla. Photo by Atena Sherry.
Much like New Orleans’ Ninth Ward after Hurricane Katrina, the low-income neighborhoods east of Panama City, where St. Dominic is located, were especially hard-hit by the storm. Now residents here are desperate for help.
Atena SherryOctober 18, 2018
“I believe there are adequate, alternative options for true women’s health care out there, and Planned Parenthood is not needed,” said Alisha Fox, a health and wellness coach at a Catholic fertility center in Chicago.
Colleen ZeweOctober 18, 2018
 Ethiopian Cardinal Berhaneyesus Souraphiel of Addis Ababa checks out the name badge of Nathanael Lamataki, a youth delegate from the French territory of New Caledonia in the South Pacific, as they leave a session of the Synod of Bishops on young people, the faith and vocational discernment at the Vatican Oct. 5. (CNS photo/Paul Haring)
Cardinal Souraphiel highlighted the role globalization plays in connecting young people in unjust ways.
Michael J. O’LoughlinOctober 18, 2018
The pope said he would visit North Korea “if an official invitation arrives.”
Gerard O’ConnellOctober 18, 2018