Humanity’s next great leap

It is no surprise that I spent a lot of time as a kid thinking about life on other planets. I am of the “Star Wars” generation after all—age 5 when the first film came out; 8 years old when “The Empire Strikes Back” hit the theaters; 11 with “Return of the Jedi.” Now, with “Star Wars: The Force Awakens” bringing my childhood heroes back to the big screen, my thoughts again return to contemplating the possibility of life in galaxies far, far away…

Through most of the 20th century, scientists theorized that our Milky Way galaxy was swarming with life—not just simple organisms but whole civilizations as advanced or more advanced than our own—on planets orbiting distant stars. While both these extra-solar planets (or exoplanets) and the civilizations upon them were theoretical at the time, it seemed inevitable that we would discover them in short order. After all, our Earth is just an insignificant speck tucked away in a corner of a vast galaxy of roughly 300 billion stars. Yet today, while astronomers have proved the existence of more than 2,000 exoplanets, our Milky Way remains remarkably and frustratingly silent.


The silence pulls at our collective imaginations. Our species craves interaction; our literature is defined by encounters. We have always sought companionship to fill the quiet. For ages we have looked at the vastness of the night sky and wondered: Can we really be alone? The sheer number of stars seems to confirm the mathematical likelihood that there are other intelligent beings out there. And yet, we hear nothing. No one has answered our calls, except in fiction.

Popular science fiction has often reflected the prevailing scientific theories about intelligent life on other planets. In the 1960s and ’70s, when the idea of widespread extraterrestrial intelligence was prevalent, television shows like “Star Trek” and “Doctor Who” and films like “2001: A Space Odyssey” and “Close Encounters of the Third Kind” were fictional versions of our greatest hopes in the search for extraterrestrial intelligence.

Where is everybody?

More recently, however, the reimagined “Battlestar Galactica” series on television and the Christopher Nolan film “Interstellar” display a lonelier universe that is more in keeping with the concerns embodied in what is known as “Fermi’s paradox.” In 1950 the Nobel Prize winning physicist Enrico Fermi was discussing the possibility of alien life with a number of fellow scientists, all of whom believed it must be plentiful. After the conversation drifted to other subjects, Dr. Fermi reportedly blurted out: “Where is everybody?” The “everybody” in question was extraterrestrial civilization. The physicist posited that if there were so many alien civilizations in the galaxy, there should be evidence of them all around. So why had we not yet encountered them, either by their visiting Earth or through some sort of broadcast picked up by our radio telescopes?

The Milky Way is around 10 billion years old. An advanced alien civilization, using ships that travel at even a fraction of the speed of light, could easily spread from its native solar system to numerous planets orbiting distant stars in just 10 million years—a sliver of time compared to the age of the galaxy. So the night sky should be abundant with evidence that we are not alone. Yet there has been no such evidence—not in 1950 and not today.  

Fermi’s paradox has led many people to conclude that the silent stars can mean only one of two things: Either we are indeed alone in the galaxy or there is some “great filter” that prevents most extraterrestrial life forms from either reaching sentience or our level of technological achievement.

Maybe the idea that we are unique in this universe is a comfort to some; for me, it’s an unsettling concept. Worse still is the possibility that a great filter like natural disasters, war, famine, disease or environmental degradation has prevented another civilization from reaching the stars—or will prevent us from doing it.

Fermi’s paradox is fascinating, but too many people who cite it assume that we have already somehow amassed enough evidence to conclude we are either alone or in a whole lot of trouble. But is that the case? We have been studying the stars with radio telescopes for less than a century and discovering exoplanets for just the last 20 years. There is a lot of real estate left in the sky to explore.

Precious Cargo

What we can say at this point is that intelligence like our own is looking to be a very precious commodity. And that means we, the plain old human race, are quite literally extraordinary. It means that we have already survived a number of great filters in our recorded history, and very likely in our prehistory, to stand here now, not only existing but contemplating our place and purpose in the universe. It also gives me hope that we will use the intelligence given to us to overcome the considerable filters still before us—not only the natural disasters and diseases, but also our own tendencies toward self-destruction and abuse—and to one day go out among the stars.

It is easy to knock the human race for our failings. We have got an awful lot of them. Just pick your deadly sin: wrath, greed, sloth, pride, lust, envy, gluttony. Our history provides more than enough ammo to think that our species will eventually succumb to any or all them. But it is hard not to marvel at the fact that a race as flawed as ours has survived all these thousands of years and continues to survive even as it struggles, however fitfully, with its own demons.

The answer to Fermi’s paradox may one day be revealed. We may be alone because no other sentient life has ever developed. We may be alone because no other civilizations had a chance to develop to the point that they could make contact. But this latter possibility does not predict our future. Past, in this context, is not prologue because our civilization and an alien one may not be analogous.

What we do know is that all manmade constructs end. Civilization as we know it may one day end, but that does not mean that humanity itself has to end along with it. Our history proves that we are as creative and as adaptable as we are destructive and brutal, and that we have used these more positive talents to literally reshape the face of this planet. We have flourished as a race because we can accept change as needed. Maybe a change of planets is a large leap. But is it any larger than the one made to the first fire-cooked meal or to the first harvest? Or to the acknowledgment that every person is your brother or sister? Each change has in common the leaving behind of one life and the taking up of another.     

If all that is true, we really better make sure we stick around. That means, in the short term, assuring that we take care of and defend this planet and all of the very precious living cargo upon it. In the long term, it means preparing our race to live on planets and in environments far different from the warm and comforting nest of our Mother Earth. For humanity to survive—for the one known sentient species in the galaxy to continue—we must become a spacefaring people. The stars need not be silent forever.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Hilary Claggett
3 years 1 month ago
Very well said! Calling Elon Musk!
Christopher Mari
3 years 1 month ago
Ms. Claggett, if Mr. Musk answers your call, ask him to save me a seat on his first flight to Mars!
J Cosgrove
3 years 1 month ago
our Milky Way remains remarkably and frustratingly silent.
I suggest that you read Eric Metaxas's book, "Miracles." Earth is so rare that there is no other planet even remotely like it in the universe. For example, if the Earth was just a tiny bit smaller, water which has a molecular weight of 18 would evaporate and there would be no life. If it was a timy bit bigger, methane which has a molecular weight of 16 and ammonia which has molecular weight of 17 would cling to the surface snuffing out all life as we know it. Maybe, there would be some other form of life not dependent on water but I doubt it. Earth has about 100 other incredibly unlikely characteristics that the only logical explanation is that it was made that way. The chances that a similar planet is somewhere else is so small that it would take hundreds of zeros after the decimal place to calculate the probability. Then there is life itself which given an existing earth is so unlikely that the zeros just keep piling up. So I would look to other explanations for life and why there is silence from the rest of the universe let alone the Milky Way. If there is a signal, then it was directly made by some intelligence that was created to be there and did not arise on its own.
Christopher Mari
3 years 1 month ago
Thank you so much for your book suggestion. Metaxas is a gifted writer. Amazing Grace, his biography of William Wilberforce, the British parliamentarian and abolitionist, is outstanding.
Jacob Freydont-Attie
3 years 1 month ago
Hey if you are really interested in Fermi's Paradox check out the new climate change documentary, The Cross of the Moment. I think your readers will be intrigued by how it ties science to today's moral issues.
Bruce Snowden
3 years 1 month ago
Mr. Mari, Could it be that one of Paul’s “eye has not seen” wonders in the NT on “eternal life,” the “new creation” in a word, “heaven” may be a planetary experience involving an everlasting romp among the stars? Where did Elisha go in his Fiery Chariot? Was it dropped off somewhere along the way, joining other meteor-like celestial features? If not, when he got to heaven wherever heaven might be, (I think it surrounds us!) what happened to his chariot? Or are we to understand that story only in an hyperbolic way? I wonder if through heaven’s transparency the stars are ever visible in the hereafter. Revelation uses star imagery in its messages, two come to mind at the moment, the Star of David and the Star of Bethlehem. God is above all else, consistent. It is mere speculation but I find it attractive to imagine that the Blessed in the life of the world to come may actually find residential lodging among the stars. O beauties ever ancient, even new, how late have I known thee, how late have I loved thee!” My apologies to St. Augustine for using his beautiful words in a way he never intended. Lots of question, very few answers.
Christopher Mari
3 years 1 month ago
Thank you for your very vivid response to my piece, Mr. Snowden. What you wrote here reminds me very much of C.S. Lewis' terrific trilogy of theologically flavored sci-fi novels, which begins with Out of the Silent Planet. If you've never read them, you'd be in for a treat. And yes, as you say, many questions. And many interpretations to Scripture. Which also reminds me of Augustine: “In matters that are so obscure and far beyond our vision, we find in Holy Scripture passages which can be interpreted in very different ways without prejudice to the faith we have received. In such cases, we should not rush in headlong and so firmly take our stand on one side that, if further progress in the search for truth justly undermines this position, we too fall with it.”
Bruce Snowden
3 years 1 month ago
Mr. Mari, Thanks for taking time to respond to my post. At 84 one feels there's much to say, even needs to be said and not much time left,but wonders who the heck cares! I'm gratified you do. To equate somewhat my lines to C.S. Lewis's writings is pleasing, making my "chicken soup" surprisingly flavorful, even though the "chicken" swished rapidly only once, in the water of the soup pot. Asked my wife to get me for Christmas the book you mentioned. Thanks too for the Augustinian quote, wherein I see my reflection as one who dabbles in obscurity. It is delightfully frightening, aware as I am that that pits of non-answers loom, also O.K. with me, as from my youth ??? always followed by ,,, never ... captured my imagination, paradoxically offering a type of shackled liberation prodding a deeper dig. Not so unusual as it seems to me a common human experience. Again, thanks!


The latest from america

Like most public writers, I was used to getting notes that were crude, crazy or even mildly threatening. Normally, I would say a quick prayer for these obviously troubled people and get on with my day. This time it felt different, precisely because the author wasn’t insulting or obviously deranged.
Rachel LuJanuary 21, 2019
In cities across the country, local activists marched in support of a progressive agenda centered on economic justice, racial justice and immigrant rights.
Brandon SanchezJanuary 20, 2019
Pope Francis has suppressed the Ecclesia Dei Commission, a significant decision with consequences for the Holy See’s relations with the priestly Fraternity of St. Pius X.
Gerard O’ConnellJanuary 19, 2019
Photo: IMDB
A new Netflix miniseries brings out the story’s aspects of adventure and conflict, with occasionally pulse-pounding results.
Rob Weinert-KendtJanuary 19, 2019