After backlash, Archbishop Nienstedt to leave Michigan parish

Following complaints by some Catholics and leaders of an organization for victims of clergy sexual abuse, Archbishop John C. Nienstedt is leaving a temporary position with a parish in Battle Creek, Michigan, the parish's pastor announced in a Jan. 21 letter.

"After discussion with the archbishop conveying the expressed concerns by the faithful people of our community, he offered to withdraw from the diocese and I agreed," wrote Father John Fleckenstein, pastor of St. Philip Catholic Church in Battle Creek, to the area's Catholics.


"Archbishop Nienstedt has a deep concern for the church, and in light of the unintended discord that his presence was causing, he decided that this would be the best course of action so the church can remain focused on its mission," the priest added.

Father Fleckenstein announced Archbishop Nienstedt's arrival to the parish Jan. 10 in his parish's bulletin. He noted that the archbishop would be assisting him with some pastoral ministries for about six months, which would allow the pastor to complete projects for the Diocese of Kalamazoo and attend to some health issues. He said he has known Archbishop Nienstedt for 20 years, since the archbishop was pastor of a parish in Royal Oak, Michigan.

Archbishop Nienstedt resigned as the head of the Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis in June following the Ramsey County Attorney's Office's filing of criminal and civil charges against the archdiocese alleging the archdiocese had not protected children in the case of Curtis Wehmeyer, a former priest. Auxiliary Bishop Lee A. Piche resigned the same day.

On the day of his resignation, Archbishop Nienstedt said he stepped down because his "leadership has unfortunately drawn away from the good works of (Christ's) church and those who perform them." He and Bishop Piche both cited the need to resign allow healing to begin in the archdiocese.

Following the announcement that Archbishop Nienstedt would be temporarily assisting Father Fleckenstein, some Battle Creek-area Catholics, as well as leaders of the Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests, known as SNAP, publicly raised concerns about nature of the criminal and civil charges, as well as an allegation made in 2013 that he had inappropriately touched a boy's buttocks during a group photo in 2009. Archbishop Nienstedt denied the allegation and stepped aside from ministry while it was investigated. 

Ramsey County did not file charges, and the archdiocese's investigation found the claim to be unsubstantiated.

"A very regrettable circumstance of Archbishop Nienstedt's presence within our community has been anger and fear," Father Fleckenstein wrote in the Jan. 21 letter. "I'm proud of the good works of our parishes and our Catholic schools as well as our valuable place in our community. I wish for us to continue growing and striving. My hope is that we can move forward together."

He said he wished Archbishop Nienstedt well and that "I know many of you do as well." He also said that the archbishop "shared with me the deep gratitude he has for the hospitality he received from so many of our parishioners."

In a letter published the same day to the Catholics of his diocese and especially those in Battle Creek, Bishop Paul J. Bradley of Kalamazoo apologized "for the hurt this situation has caused and the fears that have been raised."

"It would never be my intention to bring harm to our beloved local church. While I am personally convinced that at no time was anyone in danger, I acknowledge the concerns expressed," he wrote. "I pray that with this matter now resolved, we will all be able to move forward. I want to regain your trust where that has been damaged or lost, and continue to strengthen our local church here in the Diocese of Kalamazoo."

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.


Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

Asia Bibi's husband and her daughter Eisham arrive in the Vatican prior to a private meeting with Pope Francis. (Credit: Vatican News)
The pope said Rebecca Bitrus and Asia Bibi are models for a society that today has ever more fear of suffering.
Gerard O’ConnellFebruary 24, 2018
(Nick Ansell/PA via AP, archive)
Recent allegations about one of the United Kingdom’s biggest and best-known charities has driven increased demands from some quarters that overseas aid be reduced, if not abolished completely.
David StewartFebruary 23, 2018
Students who walked out of classes from Montgomery County Public Schools in Maryland protest against gun violence in front of the White House on Feb. 21 in Washington. (CNS photo/Kevin Lamarque, Reuters)
The desire for stronger gun control may not translate into more caution with gun storage among owners of firearms.
Kevin ClarkeFebruary 23, 2018
Of the estimated 14.5 million school-age Catholic children in the U.S., about or 55 percent are Latino. Yet 4 percent of school-age Latino Catholic children are enrolled in Catholic schools.
Maria Luisa TorresFebruary 23, 2018