George M. AndersonDecember 20, 2010

Raised Protestant, I never had nuns as teachers in grade school. In fact, it was only after becoming Catholic at 30 that I began to gain a sense of their remarkable contributions. After I became a Jesuit, many of the sisters I met became personal friends. Among them is a member of the Sisters of Mercy, Eileen Hogan, whom I initially met through our shared prison chaplaincy work at Rikers Island. Eileen later went on to found Womencare, a mentoring organization that ministers to women leaving prison. In 2002 she and another Mercy sister began the Sister to Sister: All Africa AIDS Conference, a program that enables African women religious to gather and empower one another to develop strategies to address the H.I.V./AIDS pandemic that is ravaging sub-Saharan Africa. She and Sister Farley recently returned from Cameroon and Uganda after one of their several annual trips to Africa.

Sister Hogan’s congregation is representative of the many highlighted in an exhibit at Ellis Island, “Women & Spirit: Catholic Sisters in America.” It documents their achievements since first arriving here centuries ago. Immigrants themselves, they found a not always welcoming land where nativist sentiment viewed them, along with priests, as tools of Rome. Many faced severe hardships. Rose Philippine Duchesne, of the Society of the Sacred Heart, for example, arrived in Missouri from France in 1818, sailing up the Mississippi River to St. Louis and then settling in St. Charles. With slender resources, she and other immigrant nuns often literally had to beg for essentials in the way of food and shelter.

African-American sisters are also represented in the exhibit. The founder of one congregation, Mother Elizabeth Lange, a refugee from Haiti’s revolutionary violence, began the Oblates of Providence in Baltimore in 1829. When the superior of the Sulpician priests there asked her to send sisters to help at the seminary, she spoke in her reply of “the difficulty of our time as persons of color and religious at the same time.” In that early 19th-century period, the sisters were often insulted on Baltimore’s streets despite their religious garb.

During the Civil War, religious women played a major role in caring for wounded soldiers. The Daughters of Charity, for example, ran the federal government’s Saterlee Hospital in Philadelphia. A photo shows three dozen of them in front of the building, with a Union soldier at either side of the group. One wounded soldier, perhaps puzzled by the winged wimple of the nun caring for him said, “I don’t care what you are, but you’re a mother to me.”

The ministries of modern sisters are represented in the exhibit, too. We see a photo of several walking together in the 1965 march in Selma, Ala. One is Sister Antona Ebo, a Franciscan, who is quoted in a photo caption: “I am here because I am a negro, a nun and a Catholic and because I want to bear witness”—as indeed she and many others continue to do. We also see a photo of Dorothy Stang, a Sister of Notre Dame murdered in Brazil in 2005 defending the rights of indigenous people exploited by land-grabbers.

During my visit to the third-floor space, visitors of varying ages prayerfully made their way around the exhibits. But two who stood out for me were elderly sisters in simple dark blue dresses, standing before one of the enlarged photos, smiling as they pointed out to each other nuns they knew personally.

With the current anti-immigrant sentiment, the work of many nuns on behalf of the undocumented and other rejected people has become more important than ever. Whatever their varied ministries, sisters have been a gift to the world—a blessing to be remembered during this Christmas season.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Robert O'Connell
10 years 2 months ago
    I grew up in Des Plaines, Illinois; I am the youngest of four sons.  Our Father had died shortly after I was born and our Mother needed to work.  The Franciscan nuns at our parish, St. Mary's, let me start first grade when I was only 5.  My Mother drove me to my first day. I took my first bus ride to get home.  Unfortunately, I got into a fight on the bus and the patrol girl was obliged "report" me to the principal the next morning.  When this patrol girl came to my class in order to walk me to the principal's office my teacher, Sr. Marie Therese, O.F.M., walked to my desk, put her right arm around me, and said, "We will take care of this here."  I never heard another word about this.  I have thanked God for Sr. Marie Therese at least once every week ever since.

    Two of my older brothers went to Maryville, an orphanage, instead.  I saw very busy nuns take care of 600 children there.  My wife, who I met in first grade, went to St. Pat's, a Catholic High School for Girls run by mercy nuns.  I saw smart women laugh and teach as well as my Priests at Notre Dame High School for Boys.

    In 1959 the Discalced Carmelites opened a Monastery across the street from Maryville.  Mothers Agnes, Catherine and Marie Andre and all the dear Carmelites they lived with there have prayed for and with the world I know with an effectiveness as intercessors and examplary witnesses that I could never adequately describe.

    In 1961 some other nuns opened Holy Family Hospital in Des Plaines.

    I mention these things because I think the work of so many nuns has impressed me and meant more to so many people I know that I must publicly acclaim these dear, dedicated and saintly souls.  And thank God!


10 years 2 months ago
I was very moved by the exhibit when my daughter and I viewed it here in Cincinnati.
David Smith
10 years 2 months ago
We may remember nuns with affection - I certainly do - but in painting them as no more than Little Mothers, I think we do them a great disservice.  I'd venture to say that nuns have had far more positive influence over ordinary Catholics throughout at least recent centuries than the male clergy.  They've done and continue to do a tremendous amount of hard and fruitful work in the field.  Without them, the Church would be skating on far thinner ice than it is.

Priests and the laity should take special care not to consider the work of women religious of secondary importance merely because they aren't ordained.  I suspect that's a way of thinking far more common than we usually admit to ourselves.

The latest from america

Pope Francis is pictured with religious leaders during an interreligious meeting on the plain of Ur near Nasiriyah, Iraq, March 6, 2021. (CNS photo/Paul Haring)
Pope Francis' prayer at the interreligious meeting at Ur, Iraq on Saturday, March 6.
Pope FrancisMarch 06, 2021
Pope Francis receives flowers from children during a welcoming ceremony with Iraqi President Barham Salih at the presidential palace in Baghdad on March 5, 2021. (CNS photo/Vatican Media)
While churches and mosques have been built for centuries in close proximity to each other, the relationship between those who worship God inside these sacred houses of prayer has not always been as close.
We asked our editors and staff at America to share some of their favorite recipes as a corporal work of mercy: to (help) feed the hungry.
America StaffMarch 05, 2021
Dr. Anthony Fauci, the nation's top infectious disease expert, has called the Mississippi and Texas orders "ill-advised."