Click here if you don’t see subscription options
The EditorsNovember 10, 2003

Affordable housing for low-income families—seldom in the past few decades has this essential aspect of American life been harder to come by. Construction of new government-subsidized housing remains at a virtual standstill. High unemployment rates and increased nationwide poverty are exacerbating the scarcity of rental housing for those who are trying to get along on limited incomes. Such is the conclusion of Out Of Reach 2003, a report recently released by the National Low Income Housing Coalition, a nonprofit advocacy group based in Washington, D.C.

The report makes frequent use of the term “housing wage,” which is the amount a full-time worker must earn in order to afford a modest two-bedroom unit at fair market rent while paying no more than 30 percent of his or her income. (The fair market rent is the Department of Housing and Urban Development’s estimate of what a person would have to pay for modest but decent housing in a particular locality.) At the national level, the housing wage currently stands at $15.21 an hour. That is, a worker must earn $4.56 per hour just to cover the cost of housing alone. This figure represents an astonishing 37 percent increase since 1999.

The burden of high housing costs has weighed most heavily on people in low-paying service jobs, like restaurant and hotel workers. The households of many of them fall into the category of what the report refers to as “extremely low income,” people who earn less than 30 percent of their area’s median income. Thirty-two million people find themselves in this position. With average earnings of only $8.34 an hour, an extremely low-income household cannot afford the fair market rate on a two-bedroom home in any of the 50 states. Part of the problem lies in the growing loss of rental housing to home ownership—that is, former rental units that, once purchased, are no longer rentable. In big cities, too, gentrification has taken its toll on what were once affordable units. In New York City, for instance, many former tenement buildings have been renovated by owners who now charge several times what previous tenants had once paid.

According to the report, housing is least affordable in Massachusetts and California. In Massachusetts the housing wage for a modest two-bedroom apartment is $22.40. California follows close behind with a housing wage of $21.18. But in both states, the actual wage of many full-time employees falls below these two amounts. For these workers, finding any housing at all may require doubling or tripling up, or else settling for substandard housing. And paying the rent can still entail cutting back on other essentials, like food, which leads to growing dependence on soup kitchens and food pantries.

Even in Nebraska, which the report describes as “the least unaffordable state,” over a third of the residents cannot afford a two-bedroom unit at the fair market rent. Another recent report, from Harvard University’s Joint Center for Housing Studies, found that the number of people who must pay over 50 percent of their household income for rent has increased over the past few years by close to a million—thereby expanding the category of what HUD calls worst-case housing needs.

Minimum-wage workers have a particularly onerous time in paying for housing. The federal minimum wage has remained since 1997 at a shamefully low $5.15 an hour. If $4.56 of this amount were spent on housing, there would remain only 59 cents out of each hour’s pay to cover all other necessities. In 11 states, the housing wage is over three times the minimum wage. Although a few states, like California, set a higher minimum wage, many people are still unable to afford rental housing without spending more than 30 percent of their income. As a result, some who work end up in homeless shelters.

Section 8 tenant-based vouchers continue to be a significant help for those lucky enough to have them. They make up the difference between an apartment’s market rate rent and 30 percent of a household’s income. The program, though, serves only a fraction of the people who are eligible, and in many parts of the country long waiting lists are common. Congress is now working on HUD’s budget for fiscal 2004, but advocates fear that legislators may not provide enough funding to maintain the program at its current level, to say nothing of addressing additional needs—especially if the administration seeks to reduce voucher expenditures next year. The U.S. bishops spoke in 1975 of housing as “not a commodity but a basic human right.” It is a right presently denied to far too many low-income Americans.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
15 years 4 months ago
I commend you for your superb editorial “Low-Income Housing Crisis” (11/10), decrying the continuing lack of an adequate affordable housing supply in this opulent nation. While this problem has been entrenched in our economic order for decades, the recent downturn in business activity and staggering rates of job loss have exacerbated what was, for too many citizens, an already desperate situation.

We are told that the overall economy may be finally revving up again, but thus far this has been pretty much a “jobless recovery.” And in many parts of the country, like Washington State, unemployment remains persistently and distressingly high.

As you state correctly, the federal minimum wage has remained at $5.15 an hour for the last six years, which effectively bumps legions of the hardscrabble working poor from ever finding affordable accommodations. Thus a whole new wave of displaced, underemployed, poorly paid workers, as well as newly jobless citizens, some with whole families in tow, have now landed in the ever-swelling ranks of the disenfranchised.

How this spiraling calamity is ever going to get turned around while our elected leaders are willing to squander billions of dollars every month on the escalating quagmire in Iraq is beyond me. The folks who have given us three tax cuts and two wars within the last three years will never deal with this or any other instance of gross domestic injustice. A “regime change” in Washington is most definitely in order. Are the political will and collective concern sufficiently widespread to spark such a necessary shift?

15 years 4 months ago
Your editorial “Low-Income Housing Crisis” (11/10), uncritically accepts the conclusions of a housing advocacy group, responding to a supposed crisis, that are based entirely on arbitrary standards. They state that minimum acceptable housing is a “modest two-bedroom unit,” and for that people should pay no more than 30 percent of their income. The authors say these standards require an income of $15.21 per hour. That would amount to more than $31,600 per year, not including benefits, even for entry-level workers.

While “decent” housing should be available at “affordable” prices, these are totally unrealistic standards. Why do you support them? Had I written such an article for my high school Jesuit teachers, they would have put my youthful idealism into realistic perspective. What would Jesus do? Surely he would help the truly needy. But might he not ask, for example, what is wrong with a one-bedroom apartment for a single occupant? Or for two or more roommates to share housing? Or for unmarried young adults to remain with their parents a while longer? What about living in a boarding house? (It would be useful for America to explore why boarding houses are virtually extinct, despite the apparent need.) Jesus might also ask married couples, what is wrong with both partners working and halving the housing percentage bite? Jesus might go further and ask whether high minimum wages help some people but result in fewer employed, and whether rent control laws help the needy or the savvy, while such laws play havoc with housing markets.

As a faithful subscriber for over 40 continuous years, I have become increasingly distressed over your leftward drift. While the church and faithful expect you to be an advocate for the poor, you have moved into the Looney Left, rarely tempering social concerns with those of individual responsibility. I just cannot bear any more of this addlepated thinking, so please cancel my subscription.

The latest from america

FILE - Archbishop Gregory Aymond conducts the procession to lead a live streamed Easter Mass in St. Louis Cathedral in New Orleans, Sunday, April 12, 2020. The FBI has opened a widening investigation into Roman Catholic sex abuse in New Orleans, looking specifically at whether priests took children across state lines to molest them. The FBI declined to comment, as did the Louisiana State Police, which is assisting in the inquiry. The Archdiocese of New Orleans declined to discuss the federal investigation.
The FBI has opened a widening investigation into sex abuse in the Roman Catholic Church in New Orleans going back decades, a rare federal foray into such cases looking specifically at whether priests took children across state lines to molest them.
Pope Francis, flanked by three priests, somberly elevates the Eucharist
The “sense of mystery” Catholics should experience at Mass is not one prompted by Latin or by “creative” elements added to the celebration.
Pope Francis, greets Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., and her husband, Paul Pelosi before celebrating a Mass on the Solemnity of Saints Peter and Paul, in St. Peter's Basilica at the Vatican, Wednesday, June 29, 2022. Pelosi met with Pope Francis on Wednesday and received Communion during a papal Mass in St. Peter's Basilica, witnesses said, despite her position in support of abortion rights. (Vatican Media via AP)
U.S. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi met with Pope Francis on Wednesday and received Communion during a papal Mass in St. Peter’s Basilica, witnesses said, despite her position in support of abortion rights.
Noted primarily for his work on religious liberty, John Courtney Murray, S.J., provided much of the basis for theological and political reflection on the relationship between church and state on these shores through his voluminous writings.
James T. KeaneJune 28, 2022