Assumption: The Mother's Face

When Michelangelo’s Pieta was first unveiled, wags found two errors.  The Virgin, holding her dead son, is larger than he is.  By three feet, if they both stood up.  The artist answered that this distortion was done in the service of beauty.  The body of a fully grown man would look ungainly in Mary’s lap.  The second criticism was the Madonna’s face.  It’s that of an adolescent, perhaps the Virgin who conceived but certainly not the Mother who received her dead son’s body.  Responding to the criticism, Michelangelo quipped, “Chastity enjoys eternal youth.”  There’s some truth to his retort, and it lies at the heart of the feast of the Assumption.  It also has something important to say about our earth, about our care for her ecology. 

Like the Feast of the Ascension, the mystery of the Assumption is not about relocation in space.  Mary didn’t “go up” into space any more than Jesus did.  Both entered into the fullness of divine life, what we call heaven.  The spatial metaphor is imposed by our impoverished imaginations.


The mystery, which our faith confesses, has to do with our natural world, our place within it, and the effect of sin upon both.  And that’s why the Assumption has an ecological implication.  Because what is at stake in Mary’s flesh plays out in the world as well, though with a different result.

At the center of this feast stands the mystery of the human person, who is a unity of spirit and matter.  Like the angels, we are spirits, intelligences created to serve God.  But we are also animals, material creatures, which emerge from the world and are sustained by it.    

Sin affects the totality of the human person and our enveloping world as well.  It corrupts both.  Consider, for example, the human face.  Some of the lines upon our faces are due to nature itself. Sun and age will have their way.  But some elements of the face, its grimace, the tightness of the jaw, are the result of sin, or, at the least, the result of the cares and concerns, which sin has unleashed upon us.

The same is true of the enveloping world that surrounds and sustains us.  It has less energy today than when it was created, because it was designed to wind down into entropy.  It also has less fossil fuels today than it did, say, a century ago.  That’s a human effect.  Not of itself sinful, and yet, as we’ve accomplished it, sinful indeed.  Our wastefulness and our rapaciousness have removed fuels from the earth differently than we would have, and at a faster pace, than if sin had never entered our world.  The very idea that the world is simply ours to exploit as we see fit is itself a notion quite infected with sin.  And so the face of our mother the earth looks quite different than God intended.  It’s soiled, marred, clouded, heated, ravished and depleted.  Ecology has an ethical dimension; ethics can’t eschew ecology.

Because she never knew sin, Mary’s lived her life very differently than we do ours.  Like Christ, she probably bore the marks of sin in her flesh: lines of worry, or the marks of the chronically underfed.  But she was free from personal sin, so there was no incised scowl, no shoulders weighted with resentment. 

And because she never knew sin, Mary’s life closed in a way very differently than ours do. She didn’t enter the end—should one even use the word “death?”—as we do.  She went as the creator intended, like one falling peacefully asleep at the end of the day.

On this side of the grave, we can’t see the faces of Christ or his mother.  The claims we make about the beauty of their flesh are the converse of our own disfigurement.  It’s a bit different with the earth.  One need not look far to see what sin has done to her.  In many spots, it’s difficult even to imagine her original, unsullied splendor. 

Fortunately, we are given the grace to imagine a much improved ecology, one in which the effects of sin are slowed, and even, to some extent, reversed.  The future face of our mother the earth might yet look more like the creator intended. Whether or not Michelangelo was right about chastity enjoying eternal youth, the creator has given our mother the earth the ability to renew herself, if only we were more chaste in her regard.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Beth Cioffoletti
4 years 2 months ago
Thank you for this, Fr. Klein. Recently, at a public arboretum and research forest in KY ( I learned that the earth is not just sustainable (able to take care of itself), it also regenerative (able to heal itself). This is hopeful. I agree. We don't need to use the word "death" with regards to Mary, the mother of God.
Bruce Snowden
4 years 2 months ago
Very beautiful meditation Father Klein, on the "ecology" of Our Lady's Assumption into heaven. She is Star of the Sea, she is Mystical Rose and she stands on the Moon with a halo of Twelve Stars around her head. She is the Ecological Queen of the Cosmos. Lovely Lady dressed in Green, teach us how to "spray!" I mean teach your cosmological children how to respect Sister Earth as Francis of Assisi might say, preserving it from the destruction of insecticidal "silent springs" and other morally reprehensible ecological neglect, pronounce that "sins!" Lady in Green help us in Jesus' Name to make ever new the face of the Earth, in effect your face, everyone's face in continual "Assumptions" of renewed and new creations!


The latest from america

We need to recover and renew in our lives a vision of the church as a pilgrim people, already holy yet still sinful.
Brian P. FlanaganOctober 22, 2018
Rev. Martina Viktorie Kopecká at the Synod on young people (Credit: Vatican Media)
“I was surprised that they even listened to me,” said Rev. Martina Viktorie Kopecká. “I am quite young and a woman. I wore a white stole. They are not pushing me away.”
Luke Hansen, S.J.October 22, 2018
Two questions arise: First, is Dean Koontz to be listed among serious novelists at all? Second, what makes him a Catholic novelist?
Richard M. DoerflingerOctober 22, 2018
 10.17.2018 Pope Francis greets Cardinal Blase J. Cupich of Chicago before a session of the Synod of Bishops on young people, the faith and vocational discernment at the Vatican Oct. 16. (CNS photo/Vatican Media)
“We take people where they are, walking with them, moving forward,” Cardinal Blase Cupich said.
Michael J. O’LoughlinOctober 20, 2018