Mayor backs Cardinal on UK immigrant amnesty

The British media is today reporting -- favorably here, less so here -- that the leader of the Catholic Church in England and Wales is backing a call by London’s mayor for a pathway into citizenship for Britain’s 600,000-odd long-term undocumented migrants.

In reality, it should be the other way round: the mayor, Boris Johnson, has come round to supporting a proposal first mooted by Cardinal Cormac Murphy-O’Connor at a Mass for Migrant Workers in May 2006.


The story of how the Cardinal’s call became a national campaign which has secured the backing of London’s mayor involves declaring an interest: I have been the co-ordinator of that campaign by the UK capital’s biggest "broad-based" organisation, London Citizens.

Strangers into Citizens -- the campaign name --  took its inspiration from Catholic social teaching and the naturalisation campaigns of the US, notably the US bishops’ "Strangers no longer" document. But the example most cited by the campaign has been that of Spain, which in 2005 regularised 700,000 people in modern Europe’s most successful "immigrant amnesty".

In May 2007, Strangers into Citizens brought together faith leaders, trade unionists, politicians and businessmen in Trafalgar Square to address a crowd of 20,000 calling for the measure. Since then, the campaign has advanced further and quicker than many had hoped.

In April, prior to the London mayoral elections, London Citizens organized an assembly of 2,500 people drawn from the capital’s churches, mosques and schools to put to mayoral candidates the four priorities of Londoners on wages, housing, safety and immigration.

That is how Boris Johnson, the election’s victor, came to endorse the London Living Wage and the Strangers into Citizens proposals. Over the summer, he announced the new Living Wage rate -- amazing many on the Left. Last Friday, he earned the ire of right-wing newspapers when he said in a television interview the deportation of London’s 400,000 "illegal immigrants" is "just not going to happen"  -- and argued in favour of an "earned amnesty".

After a period of about five years, he said, individuals could "show their commitment to this society and to this economy" to earn the right to stay. (Interview here.)

On Sunday, meanwhile, the shortly-to-be-retired Archbishop of Westminster repeated his conviction that "after a certain time a way should be given for [long-term undocumented migrants] to receive citizenship here and so get the benefits of that." Since March 2008, this has been the policy of the bishops of England and Wales.

Both Cardinal and Mayor are courageously naming the elephant in the sitting room -- the fact that most migrants will not be deported. They are starting from realities, and proposing a humanizing measure in the place of the dehumanizing limbo of now.

They are both risking opprobium in order to identify with a vulnerable sector of the population; but there is a measure of self-interest in both cases. The Cardinal wants to identify with a central concern of an expanding group within his Church. The mayor wants to show he is close to the values of Londoners, who are far more immigrant-friendly than in the rest of the country.

That is why the attacks on them will not hurt them in the eyes of the people with whom they want to identify.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
10 years ago
I am under not illusions about our violent immigration system. Today's temptations are the same ones we have had for a very long time: power and money. Power, that extraordinary pleasure of ordering others. Or doing whatever you like. For a very long time, Americans have depended on cheap labor here and abroad. This is not a secret. I have seen it all my life. I was born in West Texas in 1945 and grew up there is the 40's and 50's. It is one of the major cotton growing areas in the world. It depended on cheap and back breaking labor that really should be called slavery. Our selfishness does not correct our selfishness. Transformation and conversion does. We don't conjure up our conversion. We need God's help and each others' help to change. Often we can't be helped till we actually know that we need to be helped. Desperation often precedes our willingness to change. It is important that the Christian community understands that its own selfishness will cause it to balk about transformation. It will balk silently and loudly, it will balk directly and indirectly. It is a struggle and selflessness does not come easy to human beings and human society.
10 years ago
In the United States, an opportunity to speak more forcefully for undocumented immigrants after the elections was not taken by the American Catholic bishops. Let us hope that they will be more forceful in the future for these immigrants. In the United States, the active involvement of the religious community has often been needed for wide-scale social changes from the abolition of slavery to the civil rights movement. It is still strongly needed. It is needed today to bring justice to undocumented immigrants. We have an underclass of about 12 million people who are in bondage to our violent immigration system. Our treatment of undocumented immigrants is selfish. My guess is we don't even know we are being selfish or don't know what to do about it because our social sin is really hidden from us.
10 years ago
When we talk about immigrants, let us distinguish between legal, law abiding immigrants and immigrants who are law breakers. We welcome the former and must not let the latter upset our rule of law. Yes, we should welcome new generations of immigrants to our shores and encourage them to assimilate into American culture, but all immigrants must come through the proper channels.


The latest from america

The act of planting a garden is the easier part: It’s the small daily acts of caring over the long haul that can be a challenge.
Elizabeth Kirkland CahillDecember 15, 2018
So what is it about these cheesy, mass-produced films that make them so irresistible?
Colleen DulleDecember 14, 2018
Last year, 'America' published “An (unconventional) Advent Playlist.” This is my (much more conventional) Advent playlist.
Molly MattinglyDecember 14, 2018
Jeff Daniels in ‘To Kill a Mockingbird’ (photo: Julieta Cervantes)
Two starry new Broadway productions have no qualms about speaking their mind.
Rob Weinert-KendtDecember 14, 2018