Migrants, part of a caravan of thousands from Central America, trying to reach the United States, walk next to the border wall Dec. 8, 2018, as they try to cross into the U.S from Tijuana, Mexico. (CNS photo/Carlos Garcia Rawlins, Reuters)

WASHINGTON (CNS) -- Dominican Sister Donna Markham, president and CEO of Catholic Charities USA, challenged the group of students, professors and clergy in her audience March 12 at Georgetown University's Dahlgren Chapel to a thought experiment.

Making them visualize the story of the good Samaritan, she asked them to graft it onto their own lives, imploring, "Who is lying by the side of the road?" and later, "Am I one of the priests or Levites who passed by?"

It is this reflection that Sister Markham wants Catholics, and indeed all people around the country to keep in mind when thinking about the plight of immigrants and refugees worldwide. "Tending to the suffering ... is not easy work" she said, adding that we must all "confront (our) biases" if we are to truly do the work of Christ.

Sister Markham admitted that her sheltered suburban upbringing initially prevented her, as it may prevent many in the United States, from recognizing the struggles of the most desperate.

"I come from a homogenous suburban background. ... I never had contact with people who had to run for their lives," said Sister Markham.

But her experience, and her heart, changed when she and her convent took in a young Romanian couple in the '90s that was fleeing persecution in their homeland. Both the man and the woman were bursting with potential, the man an engineer and the woman a concert pianist.

And both had suffered unspeakable torture at the hands of their government.

When Sister Markham's convent welcomed them at Christmastime and she slowly discovered the humanity of the couple, she was forced to re-evaluate what she thought about refugees up to that point.

"I had harbored a bias," Sister Markham related, "that refugees had come for ... a handout." She now realized that she was lucky to have met people whose stories of suffering were so similar to those of Christ: "I am privileged to hear the stories of those ... who have lost everything."

And this encounter energized her for the rest of her life. She continued to help immigrants throughout her career, and now presides over Catholic Charities USA, which, with its network of local affiliates, is one of the primary providers of care and housing to asylum-seekers in the United States and runs programs for them at over 4,000 sites, including important ports of entry, like McAllen, Texas, and Nogales, Arizona.

She lamented that the United States has recently been making the window of opportunity for asylum-seekers increasingly narrow, as the rules for who can apply for asylum constantly fluctuate and asylee ceilings continue to drop. She revealed that Catholic Charities would be "lucky" if 5,000 are admitted this year.

But, amid the uncertainty, she maintains faith in the humanity of people across the globe.

She finished by sharing a story of "transcontinental human goodness," a story that she counted herself fortunate to have taken part in.

Two brothers from Honduras, Carlos and Edwin, were on the run from their home country when gangs sought to do them harm. Carlos, who had been shot in the back three times, was paralyzed and was pushed in a chair by his brother throughout the entire 2,000-mile journey to the southern border of the U.S. The journey took one year.

When they arrived at Nogales, Sister Markham conveyed that "they were terrified" of being returned to Honduras, and every month they waited in detention the clock was ticking down to their deportation. But Catholic Charities was able to place them with Dominican friars in Chicago, who with Sister Markham's help were eventually able to find them a place in Canada.

Referring to the love of the brothers and the love of all across the U.S. and Canada who had made their trip a success, Sister Markham commented, "This is what our life is about ... we have to welcome the stranger. ... I would say these are the faces of the Christ."

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Richard Bell
2 years 3 months ago

Well, what causes people to think the putative refugees come for a handout is their traveling more than 1,000 miles from Honduras to the United States instead of seeking refuge from hometown violence much less far away. The reason seems only that the nearby refuges offer smaller handouts.

Dr.Cajetan Coelho
2 years 3 months ago

Immigrants - they all are distinguished ambassadors of the Good News.

Tim Donovan
2 years 2 months ago

Like Sister Markham, I grew up in a "homogeneous, sheltered, suburban" existence, although there was a small enclave of black people in my overwhelmingly white neighborhood.. Years ago, I cared for disabled men in a group home. Several of my co-workers were from Liberia. They had fled from a brutal civil war, and sought a better life in our nation for themselves and their families. They were good, hardworking people, so I hardly think they were simply looking for an easy handout. Our nation has for generations appealed to immigrants, who believed that ours was a land of opportunity and success. (Of course, there has always been some bigotry. For instance, in Philadelphia and other cities, many businesses had signs on their doors with the announcement, "No Irish Need Apply."). However, despite such negative attitudes from some natives, our nation has generally been seen in a positive light. I think that, despite President Trump's hostile attitude towards Mexicans and other immigrants from Latin America, that most such people are (like my co-workers from Liberia) good men and women who are willing to work hard to contribute to our society. There are always within any group some people who will take advantage of the system, but I don't think that most Latin Americans are seeking to live in our nation merely to get an easy hzndout. By the way, I'm a former long-time registered Democrat of more than 25 years (I'm now 57) who still supports most if the policies of the party. However, about 10 years ago I reluctantly registered as a Republican, primarily because I could no longer abide the radical Democratic position on the violence of legal abortion. In my view, as a moderate-to-liberal Republican, I primarily voted for President Trump because he favors laws to end the legal killing of almost 1 million unborn human beings annually in our nation for any reason.

The latest from america

America Media received 56 awards from the Catholic Media Association on June 11 for its groundbreaking coverage of events at the intersection of the church and world across print, digital, audio and video.
America StaffJune 14, 2021
After a year of being kept off the Way of St. James due to pandemic-related travel restrictions, soul-searchers hoping to heal wounds left by the coronavirus are once again strapping on backpacks and following trails to the shrine in the city of Santiago de Compostela.
A priest raises the chalice and Communion host in this illustration. (CNS photo/Bob Roller)
Such debates don’t really happen elsewhere in the Catholic world.
Matt Malone, S.J.June 14, 2021
In April 1962, Archbishop Joseph Rummel of New Orleans not only denied Communion to three Catholics in his archdiocese; he formally excommunicated the three, who vehemently opposed his efforts to desegregate Catholic schools.
Peter FeuerherdJune 14, 2021