Women religious are seeking hope amid declining numbers

Sister Marcia Allen, a Sister of St. Joseph of Concordia, Kansas, and president of the Leadership Conference of Women Religious, delivers her address Aug. 10 to attendees at the LCWR assembly in Atlanta. (CNS photo/Michael Alexander, Georgia Bulletin)

Some 800 members of the Leadership Conference of Women Religious gathered in Atlanta for their annual assembly Aug. 9-12.

With the theme of "Embracing the Mystery: Living Transformation," the sisters considered where God is moving in today's world as they face smaller and graying communities.


"The whole assembly is about listening to the movements of God, not only individually, but collectively," said Sister Annmarie Sanders, a member of of the Sisters, Servants of the Immaculate Heart of Mary, who is LCWR's communications director.

In her presidential address Aug. 10, Sister Marcia Allen, of the Sisters of St. Joseph of Concordia, Kansas, called for "a new way of exercising hope" to envision a conference as the number of women religious serving the church continues to dwindle.

LCWR has approximately 1,350 members who are elected leaders of their religious orders, representing approximately 80 percent of the 49,000 Catholic sisters in the United States.

In an unsparing report to the organization's members, she shared numbers about the drop in women and men who serve the church in religious congregations.

"In the belief that something will come of the ravages of collapse, hope is forged," Sister Marcia said.

"We are keeping a brave face on it, but the truth is that the very thing that makes the conference possible is disappearing," said the LCWR president.

In 1995, there were 107,000 members of religious congregations, according to the National Religious Retirement Office, which requests statistics from men's and women's congregations each year. Twenty years later, in 2015, there were 49,000 members, according to the retirement office, with the majority being 70 or older. By 2025, the number is projected to be around 29,000, again with a majority at least 70 years of age.

While some congregations don't take part in the survey, Sister Marcia said the statistics show LCWR membership in nine years will not be larger, nor will most individual member congregations.

"Transformation is required. Remember, it is the new normal. We experience it all around us. We cannot escape it or pretend here in the conference that it is someone else's problem," she said.

This isn't the first time women religious have reconsidered how they live their vowed lives, according to Sister Marcia. She described the movement of sisters across the Plains to the American West in the 19th century during which the sisters replaced the ways of living religious life that had developed in the East. 

"The charisms hold, but we are challenged to something new," she said. "Traditions were reinvented. Charism survived, purpose survived, but all the customs and homey expectations of the East were left behind."

"In the face of necessity to survive and to serve in some meaningful way, a new life was, in fact, invented," she said. "Many of us are the results of these reinventions."

The ministries are vital in today's world, she reminded the leaders of congregations from across the country. By painting the scene with several vignettes, she led the group in the sprawling ballroom "through an exercise of hope that expresses our faith."

"Everything we have known about ourselves is but history at this point. It will turn out to be a hollow shell, a pyrrhic victory, unless we enter into the challenge before us," she said. She then led listeners in an exercise, encouraging them to consider the "horizon of expectation" to envision what a smaller LCWR would look like and how it would serve the members.

"This is the same thing that must be done at home in local communities," she said.

Looking to the horizon, aware of the current situation, she said, "I call this putting faith into the practice of hope."

Listeners in the audience walked away with new perspectives but said many of the congregations have wrestled with this issue for a while.

Sister Dawn Gear, who serves on the leadership council of her congregation, the Grey Nuns of the Sacred Heart, said the message delivered to the leaders in Atlanta isn't new, but it reinforces how congregations need to be aware of the situation and perhaps make hard decisions. Sister Dawn said the Grey Nuns recently sold their motherhouse outside Philadelphia to secure money to pay for care of aging sisters.

"It's like a family. We need to think about these things," said Sister Dawn, who was the founding principal of three Catholic schools in the Atlanta Archdiocese. "We didn't start this yesterday. But it's here."

Sister Miriam Harney, a member of the Sisters of the Holy Faith, works in Los Angeles as a grief counselor. She told The Georgia Bulletin, Atlanta's archdiocesan newspaper, that she appreciated the viewpoint of making decisions after community contemplation and listening to others' wisdom.

Decisions are reinforced by faith when religious communities "look out into the horizon and see what's on the periphery," she said, and are not just focused on immediate concerns.

Sister Catherine Patten, the provincial superior for the Religious of the Sacred Heart of Mary, said contemplation used by the community as a process to come to decisions is becoming a more regular practice.

"It's a particular way of viewing the world and doing leadership," she said.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Lisa Weber
2 years 5 months ago
Women religious have done some wonderful things, and serve as good examples. The truth of the matter is that women's leadership in the church needs to turn to laywomen. Laywomen are the vast majority of the women in the church and laywomen can best speak to the needs of the lives of laywomen. The barrier to religious life is celibacy in a same-sex community. Those who want to work in the church should not face barriers that will exclude more than 99% of the membership.
William Rydberg
2 years 5 months ago
Firstofff, we would be dreaming in "Technicolor" if we thought that there will be a recovery in vocations for the LCWR Congregations. In my opinion, these diminishing orders ought to hire reputable Chartered Accountants that will put together Plans for eventual dissolutions. First consideration ought to be for the long-term support for the elderly and infirm. Concurrently, a plan ought to be prepared that will outline exactly what to do with residual assets, if any. Don't want to have the public fiasco of the unfortunate "Katie Perry House Sale". Otherwise considerable Assets will be eaten up by Lawyer's Fees. in Christ,
Bruce Snowden
2 years 5 months ago
Maybe the more erudite will ridicule quietly, the following thought regarding possible reasons explaining the dwindling number of Religious Sisters. Why is it happening? Could it be that the Sisters have drifted to far from the original inspiration of the Holy Spirit, in other words from their purpose to exist, for the Spirit to continue supporting something not inspired or intended? I just don't know. What I do know is that Francis of Assisi got the assurance from the Lord, that as long as the Friars Minor remained faithful to the original purpose God had in mind for them, they would continue to exist until the end of time. There's no denying that Sisters do a great amount of good, for which all should thank them, grateful for what they now do and perhaps it should continue to be an incorporated part of their mission. But not at the expense of whittling away the precise mission for which they were Foundationally called. Is such a thing possible? Another factor may involve their dress code. It's fine to dress in a respectfully modern way, putting aside cumbersome Habits of the past. But don't you think that a short veil should be a must, some distinguishing sign letting all know that they are Religious Sisters? See with what pride and immediate definition uniformed individuals are recognized and acknowledged! Once a young girl turned down an invitation to consider the possibility of a Vocation as a Sister, with this flippant remark, "Why should I? They look just like me!" I hope this makes some sense and please, be assured, I do not want to offend any of our wonderful Sisters, just trying to offer perhaps, a little help, in solving the dilemma of their dwindling numbers.


The latest from america

Psychedelics can blur the line between science and spirituality—but Christian mysticism cannot be studied.
Terrance KleinJanuary 17, 2019
The extensive New York Times series in support of legal abortion unfolds as if the last 46 years of the abortion debate following Roe v. Wade never happened and did not need to.
​Helen AlvaréJanuary 17, 2019
In 1983, Sri Lanka descended into a bitter and prolonged ethnic conflict. Harry Miller, S.J., then almost 60, was thrust into a new role as witness, advocate, intermediary and protector not only for his students but for anyone in Batticaloa who sought his help.
Jeannine GuthrieJanuary 17, 2019
I have found that praying 15 minutes every day is an important form of self-care.
Michael R. Lovell January 16, 2019