'Welcoming' or 'Providing for' Gay and Lesbian Catholics: What's getting lost in translation?

The tug-of-war at the Vatican over calls for the Catholic Church to be more open to gays and cohabiting couples intensified on Oct. 16 as conservative bishops sought to rein in or renounce draft language they feared might condone lifestyles not in accord with church teachings.

The lobbying at the two-week summit of church leaders—a synod on family life that is set to wrap up Saturday with a final report—was epitomized by the retranslation of a headline from “welcoming homosexual persons” to “providing for homosexual persons.”

Advertisement

In the text, the line “Are we capable of welcoming these people, guaranteeing to them a fraternal space in our communities?” was changed to, “Are we capable of providing for these people, guaranteeing … them … a place of fellowship in our communities?”

The change in the English version was not made in the Italian original, where the term “accogliere,” which means “to welcome,” was kept.

The Vatican’s chief spokesman, the Rev. Federico Lombardi, said the first document was only a “transitory text” and suggested there were errors in translation.

“We did something very rapidly,” he told journalists when questioned about the change.

Many hard-liners, including U.S. Cardinal Raymond Burke, have claimed that the report was biased and did not take account of their views.

Lombardi said conservative Cardinal Gerhard Mueller, head of the Vatican’s Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and a staunch opponent of changes, denied saying he had described the report as “unworthy” or “shameful.”

Adding to the confusion was the release of reports from the synod’s 10 discussion groups reinforcing a more traditional line on marriage, homosexuality, cohabitation and Communion for divorced Catholics.

One group, led by South African Cardinal Wilfrid Napier, said members were concerned “about an over-emphasis on ‘positive elements’ when speaking of civil marriage and cohabitation,” while another group said the church should not “legitimize homosexual practices.”

Austrian Cardinal Christoph Schonbrun, considered a moderate, predicted to journalists that the synod’s final report would speak of “welcoming” gays.

In the face of this week’s outcry, Pope Francis added two bishops to the report committee—Napier, who will represent the African bishops, and conservative Australian Archbishop Denis Hart from Melbourne.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.

Advertisement

Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

The appointments are part of an ongoing effort to give a greater role to women in the work of the Roman Curia offices, the central administration of the Catholic church.
Gerard O’ConnellApril 21, 2018
Ivette Escobar, a student at Central American University in San Salvador, helps finish a rug in honor of the victims in the 1989 murder of six Jesuits, their housekeeper and her daughter on the UCA campus, part of the 25th anniversary commemoration of the Jesuit martyrs in 2014. (CNS photo/Edgardo Ayala) 
A human rights attorney in the United States believes that the upcoming canonization of Blessed Oscar Romero in October has been a factor in a decision to revisit the 1989 Jesuit massacre at the University of Central America.
Kevin ClarkeApril 20, 2018
Journalists photograph the lethal injection facility at San Quentin State Prison in California in 2010. (AP Photo/Eric Risberg, File)
In California, Catholic opponents of the death penalty are trying to protect the largest population of inmates awaiting execution in the Western Hemisphere.
Jim McDermottApril 20, 2018
Photo: the Hank Center at Loyola University Chicago
Bishop McElroy said that Catholics must embrace “the virtues of solidarity, compassion, integrity, hope and peace-building.”