We Have Papabili!

Irish bookmakers have ranked Cardinal Angelo Scola of Italy, Cardinal Peter Turkson of Ghana and Cardinal Marc Ouellet of Canada as favorites among the papabili (literally “pope-ables”). Has Cardinal Turkson already blown his chances by saying that he would be happy to take the job? Is New York’s Cardinal Timothy M. Dolan out of the running because he is, well, an American? Such are the speculations of “papabili watching” as the conclave that will elect the new pope approaches in March.

If you would prefer to let your reason, rather than an Irish bookie, be your guide, here are some short bios of the leading candidates for the job.


Cardinal Angelo Scola (Italian, born Nov. 7, 1941). Archbishop of Milan since 2011, Cardinal Scola, a respected theologian, was patriarch of Venice, where he earned a reputation as an energetic pastor, raising the church’s profile in the civil arena. He was created a cardinal in 2003. In 2004 he started Oasis, an international foundation that serves as a forum for dialogue and a bridge of support for Catholics in the Middle East.

The son of a socialist truck driver, Cardinal Scola took to his assignment in Venice with relish, visiting local communities in an effort to help restore the parish as a spiritual and social meeting ground. Cardinal Scola has argued that if the church wants to reach people where they live, it has to move out of the sacristy and into all sectors of civil society. “As Christians,” he said, “that means we must have the courage to show our face, to say what freedom really is...and to propose to civil society an ideal of the good life.”

Cardinal Odilo Pedro Scherer (Brazilian, born Sept. 21, 1949). Archbishop of São Paulo since 2007, Cardinal Scherer was born of German ancestry in São Francisco, Cerro Longo, Brazil. He studied philosophy and theology at Rome’s Pontifical Brazilian College and the Pontifical Gregorian University and worked as an official for the Vatican’s Congregation for Bishops from 1994 to 2001. Ordained in 1976, he served as pastor in the Diocese of Toledo in Brazil. He taught and served as rector at a number of seminaries and religious institutes in southern Brazil. Cardinal Scherer has expressed concern about a “silent flight of the faithful” because of a lack of religious formation and instruction about the church.

Cardinal Peter Turkson (Ghanaian, born Oct. 11, 1948). Cardinal Turkson was born in Western Ghana to a Methodist mother and a Catholic father who worked as a carpenter, the fourth child among 10 children. He attended a seminary in New York State and was ordained in 1975. In 1992 Turkson was appointed archbishop of Cape Coast by Pope John Paul II and served as president of the Ghana Catholic Bishops’ Conference from 1997 to 2005. He was created a cardinal, Ghana’s first, at John Paul II’s last consistory in October 2003. In 2009 Pope Benedict XVI appointed him president of the Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace. That position has afforded him prominence but also led him into some controversy.

In a council document released in October 2011, Cardinal Turkson called for solidarity between rich and poor nations, a global authority to govern international finance and for the taxation of global transactions that could produce revenue to help alleviate poverty. He has called on Wall Street financiers to “do business differently...because this is not leading to our welfare and our good.” An accomplished polyglot, Turkson speaks English, Fante, French, Italian, German and Hebrew, in addition to understanding Latin and Greek.

Cardinal Christoph Schönborn, O.P. (Austrian, born Jan. 22, 1945). Archbishop of Vienna, Cardinal Schönborn studied at Regensburg, Germany, under then Father Joseph Ratzinger after joining the Dominican order in 1963. Cardinal Schönborn succeeded Cardinal Hans Herman Groer in September 1995 after Groer’s resignation amid allegations of sexual abuse. Born the second of four children in a noble family, Cardinal Schönborn has not shied away from controversy. In 1996 he said in an interview on Austrian television that a person with AIDS might use a condom as a “lesser evil,” and in 2009 he criticized the pope’s lifting of an excommunication order on Bishop Richard Williamson, a Holocaust denier, of the traditionalist Society of St. Pius X. In March 2010 his spokesman had to issue a clarification after Cardinal Schönborn called for priestly celibacy to be re-examined in the light of recent abuse scandals. In 2011 he grappled with an Austrian priests’ initiative that urged women clergy, “priestless eucharistic liturgies” and Communion for non-Catholics and remarried divorcees.

Cardinal Marc Ouellet, S.S.P. (Canadian, born June 8, 1944). The former archbishop of Quebec, Cardinal Ouellet has headed the Congregation for Bishops, the powerful Vatican office that oversees the appointment of the world’s bishops, since June 2010. Cardinal Ouellet is a disciple of Pope Benedict’s theological views and is considered a top advisor to the pope. Most recently he was called to help out in the wake of the “VatiLeaks” scandal related to the release of documents that detailed corruption and incompetence in the running of the Roman Curia. He once said becoming pope “would be a nightmare.” In June 2012, representing the pope, Cardinal Ouellet met with Irish survivors of clerical sexual abuse; and in February of that year, he led a solemn penitential service with 10 other bishops in which they asked forgiveness for failing to protect children and for serving instead as an “instrument of evil against them.”

Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle (Filipino, born June 21, 1957). If elected, Cardinal Tagle, now archbishop of Manila, would be the youngest pope in centuries. He impressed many of his fellow bishops during the 2012 Synod on the New Evangelization in Rome when he called for a more humble church that put more effort into listening to its flock. Cardinal Tagle has also taken a strong approach to the sexual abuse crisis, warning his fellow bishops from Asia that they must not dismiss it as a Western phenomenon. At a conference in Rome in 2012 on the crisis, he advised fellow bishops, “We do not need to wait for a bomb to explode. Preventing it from exploding is the best response.”

Other papabili include: Cardinal Gianfranco Ravasi of Italy, president of the Pontifical Council for Culture; Cardinal Leonardo Sandri of Argentina, head of the Congregation for Eastern Churches; Cardinal João Braz de Aviz of Brazil, prefect of the Congregation for Institutes of Consecrated Life and Societies of Apostolic Life; Cardinal Timothy M. Dolan of the United States, president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops; Cardinal Oscar Andrés Rodríguez Maradiaga, S.D.B., of Honduras, the archbishop of Tegucigalpa and head of Caritas Internationalis; and Cardinal Francis Arinze of Nigeria, prefect emeritus of the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments.

This article has been revised to reflect the following correction:

Correction: February 24, 2013

An earlier version of this article misidentified the country of Cardinal Oscar Andrés Rodríguez Maradiaga. He is from Tegucigalpa, Honduras, not Guatemala.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Jim Lein
6 years 2 months ago
I like Sean O'Malley of Boston. For what its worth, which is very little. But, at least for this moment I have some voice, faint and distant as it is.
6 years 1 month ago
I am a Capuchin Friar for over 57 years and I have known Sean Cardinal O'Malley most of those years and he is a wonderful human being . He has been an example to all of us Friars as an exemplary model of Holiness Capuchin and Administrator dedicated to all people as a great Pastor. His special assignment has been dealing with the major crisis in the Church the "Sex-abuse issue" well documented the work he did in the Archdiocese in Boston Ma. Our church needs a Leader who can deal with this very difficult issue which has been the main problem issue facing the church today.
David Sharland
6 years 2 months ago
Does America really believe that Cardinal Dolan is a possibility? He is a gregarious American. Just what Rome dislikes. He is excellent, and very holy, but not a fit for Rome. A previous poster had it correctly. O'Malley is the one. A man for the world, a saint in our day.
Tim O'Leary
6 years 2 months ago
We have had a remarkable string of holy Popes if one goes by the formal canonization process (including venerables and blesseds). In all likelihood, Pope Benedict XVI will be included, making a continuous streak of 74 years! One has to go back to the fifth century to get a longer streak of recognized holy leaders of the Church. However, holiness does not always mean excellent governance (such as Pope St. Celestine V). Pope Benedict will most probably be the last pope of the VC II age, the last one to have actually played a role at that Council. I think several of the Cardinals above have interesting backgrounds (and remarkable linguistic and academic strengths), however, I wonder who would be best for this post-European age we are entering. Maybe, the Electors will take the lesson of humility from Pope Benedict and pick someone outside the College of Cardinals?
John Wotherspoon
6 years 2 months ago
My hope is that the next pope will have a politburo papacy! See http://www.v2catholic.com/johnw/2013/2013-02-18a-politburo-papacy.htm
Carolyn Disco
6 years 2 months ago
Angelo Scola wrote a book in 2006 called "The Nuptial Mystery" which was reviewed in Commonweal http://commonwealmagazine.org/body-beautiful-0 Luke Timothy Johnson remarked on "John Paul II’s lead being followed by Scola ... in the condemnation ... of feminism, of homosexuality, and of cultural traits Scola associates with feminism and homosexuality, namely individualism, libertinism, relativism, narcissism, and even nihilism. The cardinal’s logic, in fact, seems to be that feminism is responsible for homosexuality, because the more women act like men, the more men are likely to want to have sex with other men." This is startling to me as a cardinal's opinion. How do you deal with that level of ignorance at that level of the hierarchy?
William Allison
6 years 2 months ago
Correction: Óscar Andrés Rodríguez Maradiaga is archbishop of Tegucigalpa in HONDURAS, not Guatemala.
Luke Hansen
6 years 1 month ago

Thank you. We've made the correction.

Jim McCrea
6 years 2 months ago
Turkson, Scola and Ouellet are truly retrograde throwbacks to the worst appointments of JPII and B16. Diarmuid Martin is the right man for this job. Mary McAleese is the right WOMAN for this job.
Tim O'Leary
6 years 1 month ago
Jim - your top 2 choices come out of Ireland? That's a bit parochial, isn't it? The Irish Church has been falling apart recently, and is a center of gravity of the child abuse crisis. Maybe, you should recommend Cardinal Mahony?
Drew Pritt
6 years 1 month ago
I am an American. My personal favorite is Jorge Mario Cardinal Bergoglio as my choice for Holy Father. He would be an inspired....divinely inspired choice if you ask me. He is humble and I believe yet would be remarkable as a Holy Father. I believe his legacy would be one as a missionary Pope and one who calls all back to the premise of Christ's ministry, which to love God with all our heart, all our soul, all our mind AND TO LOVE our neighbor as ourselves.


The latest from america

Cardinal Malcolm Ranjith of Colombo, Sri Lanka, looks at the explosion site inside a church in Negombo April 21, 2019, following a string of suicide bomb attacks on churches and luxury hotels across the island. (CNS photo/Reuters)
Prime Minister Ranil Wickremesinghe claimed he and other top government officials were not told about a possible threat and told local media “we must look into why adequate precautions were not taken.”
I believe that Jesus Christ rose from the dead on the first Easter Sunday. And I do not see that as any sort of parable or metaphor.
James Martin, S.J.April 23, 2019
Sri Lanka’s Christians have a long history that reflects the dynamics of colonialism as well as present-day ethnic and religious tensions.
Mathew SchmalzApril 23, 2019
Medical “advances” have made the simple act of human reproduction bafflingly complex, and inconsistent vocabulary adds to the difficulty of debating pro-life issues. Here is a guide to essential terms.
Ellen K. BoegelApril 23, 2019