Letters to the Editor: Join the Conversation

The Greatest Profession

Re “Teacher, Heal Thyself,” by Raymond A. Schroth, S.J. (1/18): Father Schroth has captured the nuts and bolts of the teaching vocation and the spirit of its mission. As I read his words, I was reminded of William Watters, S.J., the founder of St. Ignatius Prep in Baltimore. As with many Jesuits, he shared first and foremost a passion for people and carried out that passion in his ministry.

Many have bemoaned the lack of value of the high school diploma, as so many with that document lack sufficient skill to read at the college level or to write persuasively. The Jesuits are again testimony to the fact that this just does not have to be so. Yes, they teach the “privileged” in a good number of schools (and there they do an unmatched job of disturbing the privileged to action on behalf of others). But the Society has also made a solid commitment to the less fortunate with its Cristo Rey program, another ministry spearheaded by Father Watters.


My experience of 40 years in Catholic schools has been one of meeting students where they are and pushing them beyond that point—all the time loving them as Father Schroth’s novice master advised. Without the “openness and sincerity” of our students this endeavor lacks all meaning. But with it—no greater profession exists.

Barry Fitzpatrick
Online Comment

Homework Hell

In “Teacher, Heal Thyself,” Raymond Schroth, S.J., quotes a young teacher who wrote to him, “I think it is wonderful that a 17-year-old girl from the upper West Side and a 17-year-old from Bed-Stuy would both be entitled to read and explore in class a treasure like Jane Eyre.” Does Father Schroth seriously think Common Core is about reading Jane Eyre? Here is what a five-step assignment on Jane Eyre would look like under the Common Core: 1) Read Jane Eyre; 2) Explain how you read Jane Eyre; 3) Calculate the number of letters in the title of Jane Eyre; 4) But not by counting them; 5) Explain how you calculated the number of letters in Jane Eyre. Common Core homework assignments are pure torture for parents. Father Schroth should have done his homework before calling on readers to “support the Common Core.”

Paul Conlin
Lake Zurich, Ill.

Irreverent Reference

I was reading “City Under Fire,” by Judith Valente (1/18), and was struck by the lines, “Susan Johnson, an American Baptist minister, heads Chicago Survivors. Ms. Johnson was pastor at a church....” Why does the author not refer to her as the Rev. Johnson? Is she not ordained? I wondered if it had been a reference to a Catholic priest, would America not have printed “Father so and so”? I only needed to read a few more lines to get my answer: “David Kelly, a Precious Blood priest, is one of those who are trying to walk that walk. Father Kelly....”

I find the references here denigrating to the Rev. Johnson. I spent four years in study after college, just like most Catholic seminarians. I am fully ordained to the ministry. Why should references to me and my fellow Lutheran colleagues be different from references to my Roman Catholic friends? When Pope Francis seems open to the possibility that all of us are headed for the same goal, and we are all members of the one holy catholic and apostolic church, this seems very backward.

(Rev.) Christine Miller
Online Comment

Substitute ‘Catholic’

In “Saudi Suffragettes?” (Current Comment, 1/4), the editors conclude, “There is a long way to go before Saudi women can claim the rights that men have in running the affairs of their country.” It is thought-provoking how effectively that final sentence invites the reader to substitute “Catholic” for “Saudi” and “church” for “country.”

Tom Kilcoyne
Online Comment

Wife, Mother, Feminist

I enjoyed Sidney Callahan’s review of Keeping the Vow, by D. Paul Sullins (“For Better or Worse," 1/4). I find her definition of feminism limited, however. She states, “These marital models [priest’s wife, corporate business leader’s wife] were not much influenced by feminism.”

I can attest from personal experience that I have drawn on all my Notre Dame and Harvard education, feminism and Catholic faith in my chosen vocation to nurture my husband’s and my marriage, raise our children, manage our home and serve the community in a variety of ways. And yes, I have also supported my husband’s vocation as a lawyer, just as he has supported my vocation as described above and now, with our children grown, the second career I am building.

Michelle Berberet
Online Comment

Solidarity Without Borders

In “The Rights of Refugees,” by David Hollenbach, S.J. (1/4), there is no mention of the hundreds of thousands of migrants who have fled from violence and poverty in Central America. Families and children, many unaccompanied, have made the dangerous journey from El Salvador and Honduras through Mexico and then crossed into the United States. A comprehensive, compassionate immigration policy and the closing of detention centers are responsibilities of the White House and the U.S. Congress. Solidarity has no borders and it should never be forgotten that people who are forced to cross borders because of threats to their lives should be welcomed across the borders of the United States not as strangers but as our sisters and brothers.

Roger Yockey, O.F.S.
Yakima, Wash.

Not the Worst Thing

I am grateful for “A Vibrant Vocation,” by Karl A. Schultz (1/4). My hope is that one day we in the church come to truly value the preciousness of life in everyone, not only in the married person. Marriage and procreation have been glorified and held up as examples of God’s favor far too persistently and ubiquitously to the exclusion of other states in life. The result for many single people, as well as for many married people without children, is feeling diminished, judged, condemned, unwanted. Salvation for them can be found outside the church only.

Recently, I saw a post on my Facebook page with the picture of the actor Robin Williams saying: “I used to think the worst thing in life was to end up all alone. It is not. The worst thing in life is to end up with people who make you feel all alone.” I can relate to his words. In my case, I have been able to listen to a God who keeps convincing me that I am wanted and loved even though I have not been able to conceive children, even though I may find myself with people “who make me feel all alone.” So I have stayed in the church and cherish it, but it is not surprising to me why so many people have left. They feel like lepers. I pray that one day we can welcome and listen to one another with love, without conditions and without expectations.

Maria Costa
Online Comment

Single, Not Sidelined

I want to thank Karl A. Schultz for his well-considered and timely article, “A Vibrant Vocation” (1/4). In my practice of spiritual direction, I often hear from those in the single life a desire for “more” from their local church community. These singles are not sideliners; they are well-educated, generous, contributing members looking for a missing piece. America is to be commended for noticing and affirming the too often overlooked vocation of the single life—permanent or temporary. My next step is to send this article to several of these beautiful people.

Cynthia Sabathier, C.S.J.
Baton Rouge, La.

Taking Notice

Re “An Unnoticed God,” by Benjamin John Wilson (12/21/15): As I was walking once to Mass at the campus where I lived, there on a banister I spotted a praying mantis in its usual position, kneeling as if in prayer. Feeling dank because of a period of apparently fruitless prayer, and seeing the praying mantis apparently always at prayer, the following words of Jesus came to mind: “Pray always and do not lose heart.” Immediately my spirit lifted and I recognized Jesus speaking to me in my need, through a humble insect, the work of his hand! Yes, Jesus is an equal opportunity provider, clueing all to the workings of the unnoticed God, which he truly is! We all like to be noticed—God, too—and paradoxically he does unnoticed things to catch our attention.

Bruce Snowden
Online Comment

On God’s Team

Thanks for printing “On Being and Becoming,” by William J. O’Malley, S.J. (11/16/15), an awesome article that I’ve pondered much. I would add to Father O’Malley’s parallels between natural and divine attributes that scientific discovery today is a team enterprise. For example, the Atlas and C.M.S. collaborations (experiments into the Higgs boson particle) at the Large Hadron Collider amount to medium-size universities. It is similar, I think, with discovering and understanding Yahweh. It takes at least a village, perhaps even a whole church, to approach some understanding. Could another divine attribute be that God gets, revels in and may even need such relationships?

John Metzler
McLean, Va.

Disingenuous Denunciation

In “Abortion and its Critics” (Current Comment, 12/21/15) it seems highly ironic and disingenuous that the editors contend such a direct correlation between the attacks at a Planned Parenthood clinic and the “need” for additional gun regulation. The assumed correlation is no more factual than the assumed correlation between pro-life advocacy and domestic terrorism. Their advocacy for additional gun regulation may be well-intended, but they are guilty of the same blame-shifting rhetoric denounced in the comment.

Phillip Johnson
Online Comment

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
MS Marie Therese LIDDY
2 years 8 months ago
To the Editors, America J. Michael Byron’s article, “What’s Catholic About It” (2/8) questioning the validity of the field of Catholic Studies, could benefit from some important methodological distinctions. Bernard Lonergan in Method in Theology emphasized that important distinctions be made between the theological specializations of research, interpretation, history, dialectic, foundations, doctrines, systematics and communications. While current seminary theology tends to focus on historical, doctrinal and systematic theology, all these specializations are in vain if they do not bear fruit either in the world of pastoral activity or in communication with the other disciplines in the academic world. It is in the latter area where Catholic Studies has emerged, for one of its major aims is to link the rest of Catholic theology with the various specializations in the university: the natural and human sciences, business, law, healthcare, etc. Just as there are fields of Jewish Studies, Buddhist Studies, etc., there is no reason in the world why there should not be the field of Catholic Studies. The academic world in general would be significantly poorer without the emerging field of Catholic Studies that links the fact of Catholicism with all the fields in the university. Courses such as Catholicism and Art, Catholicism and Business, Catholicism and Healthcare, are beginning to enrich many students’ lives. Indeed, ultimately it is largely from these interdisciplinary conversations that many questions for the rest of Catholic theology will emerge. Indeed, unless theology responds to real questions arising outside of theology, theology itself is in danger of becoming irrelevant – answering questions that people are not asking. Catholic Studies, infused with excellent Catholic theology, aims at being open to questions in the academy that even secularists and atheists are asking. Byron’s article sounds more like “I’m for Paul” and “I’m for Apollo” without appealing to the need for interdisciplinary collaboration that mirrors all the parts of the Body of Christ working together for the good of all. In Lonergan’s words, distinguishing the various functional specializations within an overall view avoids “totalitarian pretensions.” In my judgment, an institution with “Catholic” in its mission statement needs to be infused with the spirit of Catholic Studies. Anyone who thinks that a theology that interacts with the disciplines is not needed in our classrooms has a naively optimistic idea of what the name “Catholic” in the mission statement actually accomplishes. I write from twenty-two years of teaching in Catholic seminaries and eighteen years in a university Catholic Studies program. Sincerely, Msgr. Richard M. Liddy University Professor of Catholic Thought and Culture Seton Hall University


The latest from america

Venezuelan migrants walk across the border from Venezuela into the Brazilian city of Pacaraima. (CNS photo/Nacho Doce)
About 5,000 people leave Venezuela every day. According to the U.N. Refugee Agency, at least 1.9 million Venezuelan citizens have left the country since 2015, fleeing from the economic and political crisis that the country is experiencing under President Nicolás Maduro.
Filipe DominguesOctober 22, 2018
Sexual orientation by itself is irrelevant to child sexual abuse. The risk factors include impulse control problems and substance abuse, and offenders take advantage of situations in which they are trusted.
Thomas G. PlanteOctober 22, 2018
“Jesus finds people where they are, but he never leaves them where they are.”
Gerard O’ConnellOctober 22, 2018
Paddy Considine in ‘The Ferryman’ (photo: Joan Marcus)
In the fallen world of “The Ferryman,” conflict and compromise poison everything.
Rob Weinert-KendtOctober 22, 2018