Click here if you don’t see subscription options
Our readersMarch 04, 2015

To Cuba’s Credit

Re “A ‘Francis Effect’ in Cuba” (Current Comment, 2/23): Having served as the pastor of two parishes in Santa Clara, Cuba, from 1994 to 1998, I think I ought to point out some errors in this commentary. The editors write that “conditions in the country first started to change after the 1998 visit of St. John Paul II.” The marked increase in religious tolerance in Cuba actually began in the early 1990s, when the Communist Party changed its statutes to allow believers to become members. Reprisals against workers for attending church services were prohibited, and the local Religious Affairs party officers were instructed to intervene in such cases. Harassment of students by their teachers for having gone to religious instruction was greatly reduced. Churches were repaired (with some difficulty), although new churches were still not permitted. University students were permitted to form Christian campus associations.

God be praised for the wonderful efforts of St. John Paul II and Pope Francis. But also give the Cuban government credit for the major self-corrections it made long before any pope came to visit. And to attribute today’s improved religious freedom to the recent resumption of diplomatic relations between the United States and Cuba is, in my opinion, a stretch. Permission to construct a new church building is a good step forward, but it is part of a continuum of improvements that have been happening for years.

Pat Sullivan, O.F.M.Cap.
Naha, Okinawa
Editor’s Note: In addition to the corrections noted in this letter, there are several more. Bishop Serpa is the bishop of Pinár del Rio; Sandino is not a diocese. Christmas has long been celebrated publicly; the change was that it was made once again a national holiday.

Restoring Justice

“Prison Addiction” (2/23), Bishop Dennis Madden’s powerful exposition about the mass incarceration of young offenders, mostly African-Americans and Hispanics, for nonviolent and drug-related offenses, sounds an alarm for all urban centers. As I read about his experience in Baltimore, I kept thinking, “This is Houston.”

Bishop Madden speaks to the failure of the juvenile justice system that contributes to a subclass of uneducated citizens who are disenfranchised from voting or have great difficulty finding gainful employment. Among the horrific social problems facing urban America, this surely ranks very high.

I hope clergy and faithful citizens will take seriously the challenge to craft solutions to the mass incarceration of our youth. A reform of the juvenile judicial system is needed, as are ways to rescue young people from becoming a permanent subclass and to restore to them their God-given dignity and confidence that they can be productive citizens in their communities.

(Most Rev). Joseph A. Fiorenza
Houston, Tex.
The writer is archbishop emeritus of the Diocese of Galveston-Houston.

Holy, Not Perfect

“Saintly Sinners, Sinful Saints,” by James Martin, S.J. (2/23), is a column well worth reading. I suspect that what has happened in the modern era is that a form of moralism has taken over the popular imagination. It is an attitude that cannot accommodate the notion that God’s love can infuse a person who is endowed with less than a perfectly agreeable personality or that someone who acts in accord with his or her own day’s standards but not ours could be deeply in love with God and human beings.

Before the 20th century, few Europeans could escape their culture’s belief systems, systems that considered Europe the epitome of high culture. In that worldview, you were doing a favor by chastising members of “less fortunate races.” Alas, we too will be judged harshly by people several centuries from now—unless misdeeds resulting from our blindness pollute the planet to an extent that Gaia does away with humanity. Serra was a good holy man, not a perfect holy man.

William Burrows
Online Comment

The Wrong Message

Should Junípero Serra be made a saint? Absolutely not. The treatment of the people of the California missions is so odious an event in the history of the church that canonizing Serra would send a deathly message and counteract any efforts to evangelize. If it were recognized, instead, that it was not Serra but his predecessors, Bartolomé de las Casas, a repentant Dominican, and Father Eusebio Kino, a Jesuit, who made California a multicultural region that is more accepting and embracing of racial, religious and cultural diversity than any place in the past—that would be a positive and evangelizing message. Missionaries like Las Casas actually struggled through their encounter with the people of the New World and came to champion their rights as human beings deserving of respect.

Chris Nunez
Online Comment

What Cannot Die

“The Annulment Dilemma,” by Msgr. Paul V. Garrity (2/16), was a good article until the last paragraph. Monsignor Garrity concludes, “The fact of a divorce should be proof enough that something essential was missing in a marriage or that the marriage has died.” This statement is, in my opinion, hogwash at best. It is like saying, “The fact that I punched my friend ‘should be proof enough that’ he deserved it.” If we use this faulty logic in reverse, we are forced to conclude that if a couple does not divorce, then their marriage must in fact be valid. I think not.

Further, based on Catholic teaching, it is not possible for a valid marriage to “die.” If a marriage could “die,” then so could a baptismal seal, a confirmation seal and an ordination—and all that would be needed for “proof” of those deaths would be a loss of faith. By this logic, we are forced to conclude that if someone loses faith, then obviously his or her baptism and confirmation didn’t “take.” Or, if a priest leaves his ministry, he must never have been ordained.

Feelings can be allowed to die. A relationship can be allowed to die. But sacraments cannot die because Christ is their guarantor, and he conquered death.

Mark Loyet
Online Comment

Synod ‘On the Streets’

As the father of seven adult children, I was dismayed by “We Have a Lot of Work to Do,” an interview with Cardinal Reinhard Marx by Luke Hansen, S.J. (2/16). So much of the focus is on reform of the Vatican, so little on change in doctrine regarding family issues, as if the church merely needs to teach so that we laypeople understand better.

The need for more involvement of women in church administration is acknowledged, but recognition of their wisdom and perspective, particularly on family matters, is overlooked. Is there no hope for substantive change regarding second marriages, premarital cohabitation, long-term loving gay relationships, birth control? These are realities families deal with day by day.

Pope Francis urges a church that is “bruised, hurting and dirty because it has been out on the streets.” Unfortunately, it seems the synod is being conducted only within the antiseptic halls of the Vatican, unable to grapple with the gritty realities families face in our fast-changing world. Happily, most are at peace with our Lord; unfortunately, many are finding little solace in our church.

Art Maurer
Rochester, N.Y.


Status Update

Readers respond to “Raising Peter: What my son taught me about my faith,” by Mary Beth Werdel (2/23).

I have a 25-year-old daughter with severe autism, and bringing her to church before age 9 was at times the hardest, most humbling thing I did most weeks. Like the author I had an episode in which, because of my daughter’s behavior, the woman in front of me at Mass refused to shake my hand at the greeting of peace. I kept my daughter away from Mass for six months following that episode. But there was another time, when a woman gave me a hug after Mass and told me I was a wonderful mother.
I feel my daughter has become a treasured and loved member of our parish as she has gotten older. Her face absolutely glows during Mass as if the angels or perhaps our Lord is speaking to her. She flaps her hands and rocks back to the pew after receiving Communion. My sweet, mostly nonverbal daughter is the happiest one at Mass, and all those years of struggling were worth it. I wish I had a platform to encourage other mothers to bring their children with disabilities to Mass.
Nancy Johnson Antonini
While our boys have been largely accepted, and their sensory issues have lessened over the years, I still recall some exceptionally difficult Sundays. I also find it frustrating that our local Catholic schools have no obligation to accommodate special needs. We have an excellent public school system that accommodates their needs most wonderfully, so they are getting a great education, but before having children, we had been committed to Catholic schooling.
Cathy Farmer Early
I was recently hired by a Friends Church in Portland, Ore., to provide inclusion services for the children’s ministry program. What I love about it is that the pastoral team has a good understanding of disability justice, and we approach inclusion as a community practice of removing barriers. As a person with a disability myself, I pray that people of faith will be liberated from ableism.
Kitt Reidy
Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Anne Chapman
9 years 4 months ago
Art Maurer - Bravo!

The latest from america

"Together with my brother bishops, we condemn political violence, and we offer our prayers for President Trump, and those who were killed or injured," said Archbishop Broglio, the president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops.
Many political and faith leaders, even as they prayed for Trump, also asked for prayers for the country as a whole, and particularly America’s polarized political landscape.
Trump’s campaign said the presumptive GOP nominee was doing “fine” after the shooting, which he said pierced the upper part of his right ear.
In an exclusive interview with Gerard O’Connell, Cardinal Jean-Claude Hollerich, one of the synod’s most influential figures, discusses the role of women, bishops and all the baptized in a synodal church.
Gerard O’ConnellJuly 12, 2024