Reply All

Similar Witness

Re “What Martyrdom Means,” by Patrick Gilger, S.J. (5/12): In so many ways, the story of the life and death of Frans van der Lugt, S.J., echoes the story of the seven Trappist monks who lived among Algerians in Tibhirine and who were kidnapped and beheaded during the Algerian civil war in 1996. The Trappists could have left when they were warned of the danger to themselves, but they stayed among the people they served and loved.

Dom Christian de Chergé’s testament, written in 1993 as the Trappists felt the growing menace, allied him with suffering Algerian people of all faiths, in the same way Father Frans identified himself with the people of Homs, Syria. Dom Christian wrote: “If it should happen one day—and it could be today—that I become a victim of the terrorism which now seems ready to engulf all the foreigners living in Algeria, I would like my community, my church and my family to remember that my life was GIVEN to God and to this country.”


He went on to ask the readers of his testament not to heap scorn on Algerians or its Muslim believers.

Thanks for a superb meditation on lives we find hard to imagine.

Catherine McKeen
Online comment

A Priest’s Family

In “Shared Sacrifice” (4/28), Msgr. Michael Heintz writes that as in a marital relationship, the availability of the celibate priest “is extended to his spouse, his flock, his community.” This comment pinpoints the special and unique identity of the celibate priest. He is available and related to his flock.

The question for me is, “How does he see himself related?” I experience this ministry not so much as “spouse” but analogously related to it.

It is most important that a priest see himself as part of a family relationship. He is part of the family before him; to the young ones as “father” or “uncle”; to men and women of his age as “brother”; and when he is much older, as “grandfather.”

The priest takes on these various “identities” from the perspective of the different age groups and experiences of his family members as individuals with God-given, unique backgrounds. It is very important for him, young or not so young, to relate sincerely from these perspectives.

William A. Beaver, O.S.B.
Latrobe, Pa.

Other Vocations

Shared Sacrifice” celebrates the complementarity of Christian love and witness in vowed celibacy and marriage. But this comparison leaves out many people who are involuntarily single, widowed or divorced. While his paean to baptismal discipleship is articulated in these two lifestyles, these other growing populations (now about half of all U.S. adults) are often seen as somehow a lesser witness value—and often without institutional or ecclesial support—in an increasingly less coupled society. And this does not even address same-sex couples or those who are not disposed toward a coupled life.

As I look around my parish on a given Sunday, I see a majority of people who serve the parish and humanity immensely and deserve more than the traditional pat on the back or benign glance that says, “You, too, have a vocation…but we don’t call it a sacrament or religious vocation as we do for your married and vowed co-parishioners.”

The church still has much to do celebrate the role of the single person in the world and not emphasize only the vowed or married life.

David E. Pasinski
Fayetteville, N.Y.

Communion Disputes

Pope Francis is allegedly rethinking the denial of Communion to divorced and remarried Catholics. The pre-history of the uses and abuses of holy Communion are interesting, as any Jesuit should know.

In 17th-century France, the Jansenists opposed frequent Communion, believing it was the reward for a holy disposition, while their Jesuit foes believed sinners needed grace and should frequently approach the altar. Indeed, the church in the 18th century adopted more frequent Communion, but in practice the clergy generally still used Communion to keep the faithful in line.

Again in France, in Vichy France, many clergy refused Communion to those who resisted the legal government of Marshal Philippe Pétain, a pro-Nazi regime, but they welcomed members of the Milice, a paramilitary group who specialized in murdering Jews and leftists, to the altar.

Is it not time to be clear that Communion is a source of grace for sinners and not a reward for Catholic Pharisees?

Norman Ravitch
Savannah, Ga.


Readers respond to “We Praise You, O God!” by Robert F. O’Connor (5/26).

The St. Louis Jesuits were my entrée into the Scriptures. They introduced me to the important passages and images in a melodic way that stuck with me more than simple words or pictures could have. When I got more serious about Scripture study, I found that their music was still valuable. Thanks to them for their work.

Juliana Boerio-Goates 

So very, very often I will hear a Scripture passage, and the first thing that happens is that I want to sing the song of that Scripture. I, too, am grateful for the contemporary composers. Thanks to these creative individuals, there is always a song in my heart. Many thanks!

Tricia Suttmann 

We had wonderful, beautiful classical music that honored the 157-year-old German heritage in our parish. We lost that in the last nine months, and the reaction of the people in the pews has not been positive. Music is to enhance prayer and should honor the heritage, tradition and culture of the parish. Contemporary music, spirituals, guitar masses, etc., might work in some parishes, but it shouldn’t be imposed on those where it doesn’t work.

Becky Lentz 

I enjoy both our traditional classics and contemporary music, depending on my current spiritual thirst. One of the things I most appreciate about being Catholic is our inclusivity and the many rich traditions we have to enjoy, learn from and embody in our spiritual practice and lived experience.

Nancy Walton-House 


Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
3 years 11 months ago
In the article The Ethics of the Exit, I feel disappointed that you did not include divorce. In my state of California, it only takes one person to divorce. And the person does not have to have a reason because this is a no fault state. It seems to me we tend to ignore divorce. It has become insidious.


Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

An official wedding photo of Britain's Prince Harry and Meghan Markle, center, in Windsor Castle, Windsor, England. Others in photo from left, back row, Jasper Dyer, Camilla, Duchess of Cornwall, Prince Charles, Doria Ragland, Prince William; center row, Brian Mulroney, Prince Philip, Queen Elizabeth II, Kate, Duchess of Cambridge, Princess Charlotte, Prince George, Rylan Litt, John Mulroney; front row, Ivy Mulroney, Florence van Cutsem, Zalie Warren, Remi Litt. (Alexi Lubomirski/Kensington Palace via AP)
A poll found that 66 percent of the British public declared they were not interested in the Windsor wedding.
David StewartMay 23, 2018
God simply is a triad of love: a going out in love, a return in love and thus, ever more, love itself.
Terrance KleinMay 23, 2018
The leaders sent a letter to President Donald Trump, administration officials and members of Congress.
Altar servers lead a Palm Sunday procession March 25 in Youtong, in China's Hebei province. (CNS photo/Damir Sagolj, Reuters)
The pope appeared to be alluding to the fact that since February there has been a crackdown by the Chinese authorities on religion in the mainland.
Gerard O’ConnellMay 23, 2018