Priest's Conviction Reinstated by Pennsylvania Supreme Court

Free from prison and living under house arrest since a December 2013 court ruling, Msgr. William Lynn's freedom appeared to be in jeopardy again.

The case of the former secretary for clergy of the Archdiocese of Philadelphia, the highest-ranking church official in the archdiocese convicted of a crime connected to the clergy sexual abuse crisis, took a dramatic turn April 27 when the Pennsylvania Supreme Court overturned a lower court's ruling that had released him on bail.

Advertisement

It remains unclear whether the Philadelphia District Attorney's Office will press to revoke Msgr. Lynn's bail and return him to a Northeast Pennsylvania prison pending appeals to yesterday's ruling.

Msgr. Lynn, 64, had been convicted of endangering the welfare of a child in a landmark 2012 trial. In his position, he had supervised clergy on behalf of Cardinal Anthony J. Bevilacqua including former priest Edward Avery, who pleaded guilty to sexually assaulting a 10-year-old boy in 1999 and is serving a five-year prison sentence.

After Msgr. Lynn served 18 months of his three- to six-year sentence at Waymart State Prison, his conviction was overturned by the state Superior Court in December 2013. He subsequently took up residence with electronic monitoring at St. William Parish rectory in Northeast Philadelphia.

Msgr. Lynn's defense contended he should not be convicted retroactively according to a 2007 amendment to a 1995 child endangerment law when he was a supervisor if priests. He held the position through 2004.

That argument formed the basis of the priest's defense. The 2012 trial jury said the law did apply to him, the Superior Court said the law did not, and the Supreme Court held that it did.

Supreme Court Justice Max Baer, writing an opinion in the majority 4-1 decision handed down April 27, said at issue was if the "plain meaning" of an earlier 1995 statute on endangering the welfare of a child "clearly encompassed the class of persons added by the 2007 amendment" -- supervisory persons such as Msgr. Lynn -- "and the amendment merely clarified, rather than changed, the (1995) statute's scope of liability."

The three-judge Superior Court unanimously ruled the law's scope was limited, and did not apply to Msgr. Lynn while he was a supervisor. The Supreme Court countered that he was culpable under the 1995 law.

In his 60-page opinion, Baer devoted 40 pages to recounting lurid Philadelphia grand jury testimony of clergy sexual abuse that was the basis for the 2012 trial of Msgr. Lynn, showing evidence of his responsibility as a supervisor of priests and for ensuring the welfare of children. The court agreed with the 2012 trial jury that Msgr. Lynn failed to properly supervise Edward Avery and ensure the welfare of his victim.

The opinion faulted the superior court's disregard of "plain and unambiguous" language of the 1995 statute in that "it is not the child that (Msgr. Lynn) must have been supervising, but the child's welfare, including that of (Avery's victim)," Baer wrote.

However, the law's intent was not clear to Chief Justice Thomas G. Saylor, who cast the lone dissenting vote in the decision. Despite the majority, he maintained that the 2007 amendment's language should not apply to Msgr. Lynn's case.

Saylor said Msgr. Lynn "may have been substantially derelict in his obligations," but "there were no facts placed before the jury by which it could reasonably conclude he affirmatively intended that children's welfare be endangered."

Msgr. Lynn's attorneys reportedly were considering appeal options, including a petition to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.

Advertisement

The latest from america

Boston Cardinal Sean P. O'Malley and Deacon Bernie Nojadera, executive director of the U.S. bishops' Secretariat for Child and Youth Protection, are pictured during the 2017 Catholic convocation in Orlando, Fla.  (CNS photo/Bob Roller)
“Our first job is to listen, to be empathetic,” said Deacon Bernie Nojadera, the executive director of the U.S. bishops’ Secretariat for the Protection of Children and Young People.
 In a screen grab taken from video, Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro speaks during an Aug. 14 news conference to release a grand jury on a months-long investigation into abuse claims spanning a 70-year period in the dioceses of Harrisburg, Pittsburgh, Scranton, Allentown, Greensburg and Erie. (CNS photo/Reuters video)
At least 1,000 children identified in the investigation were raped in Catholic places of worship, in schools, and in diocesan owned vehicles.
Pity and punish the powerful but take no delight in their fall.
Terrance KleinAugust 15, 2018
The state’s attorney general said that his office’s two-year investigation identified 301 priests who abused children and more than 1,000 victims.