Dioceses, other groups file suit over New York state abortion mandates

The Albany and Ogdensburg dioceses, Catholic Charities agencies and other groups have filed a lawsuit against a branch of the New York state government and several health insurance companies challenging the constitutionality of making religious and other employers cover abortions for their workers.

Two mandates from the New York State Department of Financial Services have been placed on insurers—without any legislative or regulatory enactment—that have the effect of forcing religious and other employers to pay for abortions in employee health plans.


In a complaint filed May 4 at the New York State Supreme Court in Albany County, the plaintiffs charge that the requirements represent "an invidious governmental coercion of religious institutions, employers and individuals, and, if unchecked, will result in further dangerous incursions on religious freedom and liberty of conscience."

"Anyone of goodwill who values religious liberty or our country's cherished freedoms should be deeply concerned by the actions of the state," said Albany Bishop Edward B. Scharfenberger. "The Department of Financial Services, without any authority by the Legislature, has taken it upon itself to force religious organizations and individuals with strong conscientious objection to abortion to fund this procedure which, in every case, kills a developing unique human person.

"We simply cannot live with this policy, and unfortunately have been left with no choice but to bring this action," he said in a statement. "I am proud to stand with my brothers and sisters in an ecumenical expression of unity in challenging this unconstitutional infringement on religious faith and practice."

The suit refers to two distinct mandates on insurance providers. In one, the Department of Financial Services, which regulates the insurance industry, issued "model language" to insurers that requires their individual and small group health plans include coverage of so-called "therapeutic" and "nontherapeutic" abortions.

The suit charges: "The model language abortion mandate directly coerces religious employers, religiously affiliated employers, objecting secular employers and individuals to fund, provide and cooperate with the morally offensive procedure."

A second mandate, which was previously undisclosed by the financial services division, came to light only during plaintiffs' communications with that department objecting to the "model language" mandate.

In the undisclosed mandate, plaintiffs charge, abortion coverage "is encrypted in health insurance contracts under the rubric of 'medically necessary' surgery. This hidden coverage was never disclosed to plaintiffs or other employers who may have conscience, moral or religious objections to abortion."

In his May 12 column in the Albany diocesan newspaper, The Evangelist, Bishop Scharfenberger wrote: "What is objectionable in the mandates is not only that they force us to fund and participate in actions that are gravely immoral and contrary to our religious beliefs and conscience, but also that they were promulgated and enforced under color of law, without our knowledge and in clear violation of the law."

He also noted that some dioceses and religious agencies in New York state are self-insured and not currently affected by such a mandate. But, he said, there is no guarantee that "the mandates currently being dictated by one regulatory agency might not be coerced through some other state action."

The plaintiffs seek judicial intervention for both declaratory judgment on a number of state and federal constitutional grounds, as well as injunctive relief.

All of the plaintiffs hold strong religious and moral objections to abortion. Some are religious organizations, while one is a lay employee of a religious organization -- Renee Morgiewicz, who works for the Catholic Diocese of Albany -- and one is a privately held business, Murnane Building Contractors in Plattsburgh.

Other plaintiffs include the Catholic Diocese of Ogdensburg; the trustees of the Episcopal Diocese of Albany; the Sisterhood of St. Mary, which is an order of Anglican/Episcopal women religious; the Catholic Charities agencies of the dioceses of Brooklyn, Albany and Ogdensburg; St. Gregory the Great Roman Catholic Church Society of Amherst; First Bible Baptist Church in Rochester; and Our Savior's Lutheran Church and Teresian House Nursing Home, which are both in Albany.

The defendants are Maria T. Vullo, acting superintendent of the Department of Financial Services; Capital District Physicians Health Plan; Blue Shield of Northeastern New York; UnitedHealthcare of New York; MVP Health Care; Excellus Health Plan; and the Independent Health Association.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Mike Escril
2 years ago
Yup, the religious liberty argument is totally bogus. I read that on another AMERICA story with 100+ comments. Here, there are none. What a surprise from all those 'liberals' who assured is the HHS mandate and similar legislation was not about abortion. Catholics don't have to wait for the gas chambers to open to see where this is headed.


Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

The news from Ireland and the United States reminds us of Herod, of Pharaoh. What culture betrays its children?
The EditorsMay 26, 2018
A woman religious casts her ballot May 25 in Dublin as Ireland holds a referendum on its law on abortion. Voters went to the polls May 25 to decide whether to liberalize the country's abortion laws. (CNS photo/Alex Fraser, Reuters)
The repeal of Ireland's Eighth Amendment, which guarantees the right to life of the unborn, is passing by a 2-1 margin with most of the votes counted.
Education Secretary Betsy DeVos testifies at a House Committee on Education and the Workforce, Tuesday, May 22, 2018, on Capitol Hill in Washington. (AP Photo/Jacquelyn Martin)
The Secretary of Education stirred up controversy when she said it was up to schools to decide if an undocumented student should be reported to authorities.
J.D. Long-GarcíaMay 25, 2018
Thousands gathered in Dublin May 12 to say "Love Both" and "Vote No" to abortion on demand. They were protesting abortion on demand in the forthcoming referendum May 25. (CNS photo/John McElroy)
“Priests and bishops get verbal abuse by being told, ‘How can you speak for women? You don’t know what it’s like!’”
America StaffMay 25, 2018