Do we have to choose between ‘Black Lives Matter’ and ‘All Lives Matter’?

As a citizen of this country, as a Catholic priest and bishop and as an African-American, I am deeply distressed by the recent violent eruptions of the racial divide in the United States. I recently served as the Catholic chaplain during week three of the nine-week summer session at the historic Chautauqua Institution. “Moral Leadership in Action” was the week’s theme. There could not have been a more urgent topic considering the presidential election, the slaughter of young people in an Orlando club, the killing of people of color in encounters with law enforcement and the assassination of police officers by deranged gunmen.

As the Republicans and Democrats hold their conventions to nominate their candidates for the office of president, the American people are reaching the point when they must decide for whom they will cast their ballots in November. They surely want moral leadership in action. But, for many, this is a very difficult decision, since neither candidate enjoys enormous popularity with the electorate. One way of simplifying the decision is to focus on a single issue and say, “I will vote for the candidate who shares my views on immigration, or national security, or abortion, or racial justice, or international trade, or terrorism, or health care, or Supreme Court appointments, or raising taxes. Period! Even if I dislike or disagree with a candidate, I’m a single issue voter.” For those who are not, the decision may be more difficult.

Advertisement

In a similar way, the American people are confronted by the daily reminder that the racial divide in the United States is widening. A recent New York Times/CBS News poll concluded that 60 percent believe the relationship between people of different races is becoming worse, an increase of 38 percent since last year. In the face of the long list of African-American men who have died in altercations with police and the growing list of police of both races who have been killed or wounded by African-American men, one way of simplifying a difficult and emotionally stressful situation is to focus on a single idea or mantra. “Black Lives Matter!” “White Lives Matter!” “Blue Lives Matter!” “All Lives Matter!” Critics of “Black Lives Matter” have called the movement “cop killers” “racists” and “domestic terrorists.” Critics of “All Lives Matter” have branded this as an effort to turn attention away from the unique traumatic suffering of African-American people. But, must it be either one mantra or the other? Can it not be both?

A Pattern of Pain

Alton Sterling was shot and killed in front of a store by police officers in Baton Rouge, La., on July 5, leading to loud complaints of police brutality and excessive use of force. The next day, July 6, Philando Castile was shot and killed by a police officer in his car in Falcon Heights, Minn. The very next day, July 7, shots rang out in Dallas, Tex., during a peaceful protest and a sniper slaughtered five officers. On July 17, three more officers were murdered in Baton Rouge. Both murderers, African-American men, were killed by police.

We know the vast majority of police are fair minded and respect the human dignity and worth of all citizens. Some, however, are not. There is documented evidence that bias and racial prejudice influence the attitudes and actions of some police officers. We also know that the work of police officers is very difficult and very dangerous. They leave their homes each day not knowing if they will return unharmed. They deserve our respect and gratitude. Their lives matter. The heartbreaking images of blood-stained scenes of death, grieving relatives, multiple funerals, overwhelmed civic leaders and prayers for healing and reconciliation have become commonplace. It is a grief that cannot be spoken and a pain that does not end.

President Obama, his face and voice revealing his personal anguish in the face of yet another mass murder of police, said after the Baton Rouge shootings: “An attack on our police is an attack on all of us. There is no need for inflammatory language. We need to lower our voices and open our hearts to each other!”

DeRay Mckesson, 31, has given voice to the racial divide as a leader of Black Lives Matter. He was arrested during a peaceful protest in Baton Rouge, following the shooting death of Alton Sterling and was unable to be with us at Chautauqua. In his absence, former United Nations Ambassador Andrew Young; Atlanta’s Ebenezer Baptist Church’s pastor, the Rev. Raphael Warnock, and his wife, Ouleye Ndoye; and journalist Bill Moyers engaged in an energetic debate about the Black Lives Matter movement.

Ambassador Young, 84, an elder statesman of the civil rights movement, expressed serious concerns about Black Lives Matter. With his usual candor, he said Black Lives Matter was self-centered, disorganized and lacked a clear focus. He argued that no one really knows what the movement supporters want. When the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. staged a protest march, he said it was always for a specific purpose and city officials were informed in advance. This is essential for safety, which Black Lives Matter ignores, he said. This can lead to violence and deadly accidents.

The Rev. Warnock and Ms. Ndoye responded that the movement is young and unstructured and will grow and mature over time. But it should not be dismissed. Nor should it be blamed for the violence against police. They asserted that Black Lives Matter is concerned about many of the same issues that concerned Mr. Young in his youth. “When Dr. King said that the negro will not be satisfied until police brutality is ended, that was his way of saying Black Lives Matter.”

After the ambush and murder of three Baton Rouge officers, Mr. Mckesson said:

My heart goes out to the families of the police who were killed in Dallas and Baton Rouge. The movement began as a call to end violence and that call remains true today as we fight for a living, breathing justice. We want to live in a world where people don’t die by gunfire. And we want to live in a world where police don’t have militarized weapons and the public doesn’t have access to these militarized weapons either.

When asked if the “Black Lives Matter” mantra should be changed to “All Lives Matter,” he said: “People are frustrated that black people are focusing on the unique trauma that black people are facing in this country. But who would ever go to a breast cancer rally and yell out colon cancer matters?”

Lives in Peril

I do not believe that “Black Lives Matter” and “All Lives Matter” are necessarily incompatible. “All Lives Matter” is not necessarily a way to divert attention from the urgent concerns of African-American people. In order for there to be some compatibility between the two expressions, however, it is necessary to acknowledge the legitimacy of the particular concern for the lives of people of color. This is not something all Americans recognize.

If I am secure in my comfortable home with my family on a cold winter night with the fireplace burning and more than enough to eat, my life matters. But then the doorbell rings and there is a shivering, starving homeless family at the door in dire need of food and shelter. I tell them to find a shelter. They respond, “Our lives matter.” I say, “So does mine and my family’s.” But I quickly realize that, in that instance, it is their lives and not mine that are in peril.

If you simply say “All Lives Matter,” there is a danger of falsely implying that every group of Americans is facing the same degree of peril, which then makes it possible to ignore or deny pressing issues like the frequent violent and fatal treatment of African-Americans in the face of minor or suspected misconduct. They seem to be tried, convicted and sentenced to death on the streets. Aggrieved individuals and groups feel that those who say “All Lives Matter” do not really mean it. They point to George Orwell’s Animal Farm. In the novel “All animals are equal” became “All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others.” The point of Black Lives Matter is that many in the African-American community face existential threats that must not be ignored.

This should also mean that “Black Lives Matter” should not be silent about the significant number of young African-American males who die at the hands of other African-Americans, or the alarmingly high number of abortions that bring abrupt ends to nascent black lives that matter. There also must be a repudiation of any form of violence against white people—specifically, police officers. Ultimately, there must be at least a tacit recognition that there are other vulnerable, marginalized groups in the country whose lives also matter.

Elie Wiesel, 87, died on July 2, 2016. The Nobel Laureate and survivor of Buchenwaldand Auschwitz is best known for his tireless efforts to call the world’s attention to the horrors of Jewish suffering during the Holocaust. “Jewish Lives Matter!” At the same time, he was a champion of the human rights of suffering and oppressed people around the world.

On July 8, the day after the Dallas shootings, Officer Montrell Jackson of Baton Rouge, 32, an African-American and one of three officers slain in the ambush on July 17, left the world this moving message:

I’m tired physically and emotionally…. I swear to God I love this city but I wonder if this city loves me. In uniform I get nasty hateful looks and out of uniform some consider me a threat. I’ve experienced so much in my short life and these last three days have tested me to the core.… I personally want to send prayers out to everyone directly affected by this tragedy. These are trying times. Please don’t let hate infect your heart.

Servant Leaders

Every Catholic knows from the life, death and resurrection of Jesus Christ that all lives matter. A hasty assertion of this universal truth, however, obscures the sad truth that people of color have often not been included as a part of “all lives.” Tragically, this goes back to the Declaration of Independence, which makes no mention of people of color because Thomas Jefferson’s tortured, complex and contradictory paragraph on the “buying,” “owning” and “selling” of free human beings was deleted from the final draft.

Moral leadership in action: We need this not only from the sitting and future president of the United States. We need it from every citizen. We need it from law enforcement, gun legislation supporters, protest groups, the media, civic and religious leaders—including in the Catholic Church—educators, mental health specialists, businesses, coaches, parents and extended families and parish communities. To provide moral leadership in action, we must all think, listen, learn, pray and act in order to exercise what Robert K. Greenleaf has aptly called “servant leadership.”

In a time of the breakdown of a sense of togetherness among people, there is an acute need for a new authenticity. The moral authority needed to bring fragmented factions together can only come about if those in diverse positions of leadership are open to an attitude of genuine service to individuals and groups holding divergent points of view. When individuals bring the openness, understanding, humility and compassion to their positions of leadership, the potential for establishing or re-establishing community is significantly increased. This, in turn, makes it possible to move toward consensus and conversion of hearts. It may be that it is only by committing ourselves to praying, listening, learning, thinking and acting in the presence of the Holy Spirit that we will be able to demonstrate moral leadership in action as servant leaders showing, without ambiguity, that all lives really do matter.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Robert Klahn
1 year 3 months ago
"“All Lives Matter” is not necessarily a way to divert attention from the urgent concerns of African-American people." "All Lives Matter is nothing but a way to divert attention from the urgent concerns of African-American people." Anyone who tries to deny that, please tell me, how many times did you say those words, how many times did you hear those words, before people started saying "Black Lives Matter". My bet is never.

Advertisement

Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

A 14-year-old boy receives medical treatment at Suez Canal University hospital in Ismailia, Egypt, Friday, Nov. 24, 2017, after he was in injured during an attack on a mosque (AP Photo/Amr Nabil).
The pope described the attack as a “wanton act of brutality directed at innocent civilians gathered in prayer.”
Gerard O’ConnellNovember 24, 2017
“The Senate proposal is fundamentally flawed as written and requires amendment,” said Bishop Frank J. Dewane in a Nov. 22 letter to senators.
Pope Francis greets people at the “Regional Hub,” a government-run processing center for migrants, refugees and asylum seekers, in Bologna, Italy, Oct. 1. (CNS photo/L’Osservatore Romano)
Although he named no countries, Vatican observers believe he is referring especially to political leaders in several western and eastern European countries.
Gerard O’ConnellNovember 24, 2017
For Thanksgiving, we give you an inside look into what Jesuit basketball teams to watch out for this season.
Olga SeguraNovember 24, 2017