Click here if you don’t see subscription options
Matt Malone, S.J.February 04, 2014

Justin Bieber has gone from North American idol to tragic cliché in less than a year. It’s all very sad. It’s also very familiar. Countless others before him have endured this third act. The most disturbing part of Mr. Bieber’s story, however, is not what it tells us about him but what it says about us. Truth be told, if I’d had his money, his talent and his phenomenally bad parenting when I was 19, I probably would have done precisely what he’s doing. Not a few of us would, I’m sure. What disturbs me more than the well-known fact that 19-year-olds make bad choices is the fact that many people seem to derive some satisfaction from watching them do so.

Michael Jackson, Britney Spears, Macaulay Culkin—the list goes on and on. We pay these kids millions of dollars to entertain us. We celebrate them, emulate them, sometimes even stalk them. (Those prowling photographers outside Mr. Bieber’s hotel—some of whom undoubtedly would have chased Princess Diana into a Parisian tunnel—work for us) We then buy those photos and plaster them on billboards and T-shirts. Justin and his friends become our vicars to a world of glamour, money and celebrity that we ourselves cannot inhabit. Through them, we learn what it’s like to be them. Their triumphs become our triumphs: We glow with self-satisfaction when they tell a reporter: “Really, all that I have achieved I owe to my fans.”

The relationship changes, however, when the inevitable fall begins. The celebrity transforms from model citizen to shunned scapegoat just as quickly as TMZ can post the mug shot. The very person we all aspired to be the day before is now the “other,” a pathetic laughingstock. And the photographers and yellow journalists on our payroll now go to work crafting a narrative in which the celebrity does nothing right. The irony, of course, is that we shun and scapegoat the celebrity just at the moment when we realize that he or she is really just like us, a sinner, a fellow exile from Eden. We take no comfort in that, of course, because in a perverse way, deep down in places we don’t like to talk about, we enjoy the tragic spectacle. For in addition to everything else, we secretly resent their glamour, their money and celebrity, and we quietly delight in seeing them get their comeuppance.

This sounds really harsh, I know. But if this weren’t at least partially true, then why would we pay $226 million to watch “The Wolf of Wall Street”? After all, this sex- and drug-fuelled orgy “doesn’t end with the ‘lesson,’ the moral of the story,” as Jim McDermott, S.J., writes in this issue. The main character “does indeed lose pretty much everything, but he’s still got a room full of strangers hanging on his every word. Two crowds, in fact: the one onscreen and the audience.”

And isn’t the disassociation between love and sex that Anna Nussbaum Keating writes about in this issue also an attempt on our part to emulate the lives of our celebrities? One of the privileges of celebrity, after all, is the power to determine who matters and who doesn’t.

Perhaps I’m being too hard on us. But Justin Bieber is only the latest in a long line of broken young performers. My hope is that he will not become the latest in a long line of dead ones. In order to prevent that, Mr. Bieber needs to take a good hard look at his life.

But we also need to examine our role in all of this. And our role is subtler and much more powerful than you might think. As Father McDermott concludes in his film review: “Real temptation is a lot more attractive; it hides its victims and its consequences, and for a long time it’s usually a lot more fun.”

The fun, however, inevitably comes to an end.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Julie McElmurry
9 years 3 months ago
Hagiographies of women typically depict them as having always been "pure as the driven snow" (or, as we say in Florida, "pure as the sugar sand"). On the other hand, those of men depict their tussles with sin in oft glorious detail and the 180* conversion to holiness comes as a shock and relief to the reader. With The Biebs, we've all (and I mean all of us but those lucky few) "known" him since he was a lil' kid. His story has been finely tuned and crafted by men in their 30s and 40s who really ought to be doing something more productive like working on a community garden. They have orchestrated every moment of his story arc including this latest one where we see him becoming a Bad Boy (stay tuned for his appearances at MMA fights, motorcycling if his insurance provider approves it, larger bicep tats and more brushes with Johnny Law-Juan Ley in Puerto Rico). Since he has been in our consciousness since he was but a wee lad, we never got to see a 180* change. There are no detailed tussles with sin which he overcame on his journey to becoming pure and good. His story writers were scratching their heads and wondering where to go next. I doubt they are punk enough to kill their idols (even metaphorically since it would come as a great financial sacrifice to them). It is not that the world is hungering to see the downfall of this guy, its that his writers are not creative enough to imagine something creative and productive. My suggestion is that somebody send him an application to Jesuit Volunteer Corps, quick. Imagine the cool story that could come out of his year of service, living in a poor area of Hartford and serving at a men's wet shelter. I admit I have become a bit of an expert on The Biebs since 10 days ago I made a mistake when I clicked on an article about him on my new news reader app and the app "thinks" I need to receive every update about him now. Yeah, I've read just about all of them.
Paul Stolz
9 years 3 months ago
Catholic guilt is simply amazing. Somehow the collective 'We" have some blame for celebrity" train wrecks". Here is who is to blame for Justin Bieber...Justin....the end. At some point he's not even going to get to blame his parents. I am not condeming Justin, you're right at his age in those circumstances I might have done the same. Lord knows what I was able to do with limited funds and opportunity. And Lord knows I still make stupid selfish hurtful decisions now (hows that for ingrained Catholic Guilt Fr. Matt) so I dont judge Justin. I sincerely hope he gets his stuff wrapped tight before he gets his ticket punched. But I'll be darned if I have to own my stuff and his too. Maybe Justin needs to put himself under the moral authority of a mentor, I would highly recommend Bono or Clooney....Penn as a distant third. These are men who somehow have been able to do good with their fame and money. In typical Catholic guilt fashion we got blame for the celebrity train wrecks but no Kudos for the Celebrity do-gooders. Just as an aside are "we" going to be constantly blamed and held accountable for all the woes in this world?

The latest from america

A building burns after being bombed
The pope’s refusal to cheer either side in this war gives him credibility as mediator.
A Homily for the Solemnity of the Most Holy Trinity, by Terrance Klein
Terrance KleinMay 31, 2023
A Reflection for the Visitation of the Blessed Virgin Mary, by Kerry Weber
Kerry WeberMay 31, 2023
pope francis speaks from his chair at the general audience, he gestures with his hand and smiles as he talks
In his general audience, Pope Francis discusses the apostolic zeal of Matteo Ricci, the Jesuit who successfully taught and spread the Gospel in China in the 1500s.
Pope FrancisMay 31, 2023