It Takes a Village: Finding a place my aging mother can call home

My mother now lives in a place called The Village. It has been said that it takes a village to raise a child, but perhaps a village can be helpful at any age. It certainly seems our family requires the help of this village to care for our mother. She lives in the part of The Village labeled “assisted living,” which implies that she needs help breathing or maintaining a pulse. She does not. She does, however, need a level of intimate care that we, her six children, could no longer safely or ably provide.

My father died three years ago, and my mother lived with (and paid the mortgage for) one of her daughters. When that daughter was daunted by the daily demands of living with an incontinent, forgetful, 80-year-old woman with Parkinson’s disease, the decision was made to sell the house and use the proceeds to move my mother to The Village. This decision was not lightly made. It took a couple of years, several falls, many accusatory e-mails, a series of biting meetings and a visit from the police. My sister’s family is now an estranged branch of the family tree. You could say it did not go well.


When we visit our mother at The Village, we go to the right side of the building. The left side houses the folks who are still capable of “independent living,” although they too have no need to do any cooking or working or cleaning or gardening or driving or the many other tasks they accomplished on a daily basis when they were younger. I imagine that if you do not require the kind of assistance my mother does, living at The Village would be sort of like being on a cruise for the rest of your life, because on both sides of The Village, there are exercise classes, craft activities, poker, bingo, trivia games, an internet café, a pool, a movie theater, happy hours, special events like luaus, lectures, concerts, day trips, holiday celebrations, discussion groups and book circles—sometimes all in the same day. You can gauge an event’s popularity by the number of walkers parked just outside the venue.

Three meals a day, light on salt and sugar, are served in the dining room by waiters and waitresses, all of whom are candidates for sainthood. Several times a day, good-natured health aides bring around little cups of pills like hors d’oeuvres. On the assisted living side, the aides also dress the residents, shower them, change their soiled clothing and bedding, help them in and out of bed, bandage their scrapes, monitor their vital signs, escort them to the dining room when they get turned around and arrive promptly at the door when a summoning button is pushed. They are everywhere and unfailingly sweet. They network by walkie-talkie. The system works.

So my mother, after six months of residency, is comfortable, cared for, physically safe, mentally engaged and socially active. Her color and her mobility have improved. In some ways, she is part of an elder gang: she and her fellow inhabitants at The Village have formed a quasi-family of similarly challenged folks who exist on the edge of society. Sometimes when I visit—my mother has frequent visitors, unlike some of her new friends—I feel guilty that we did not simply absorb her into one of our homes. Three of my siblings live out of state, and the one who lives closest to our mother has two toddlers, which leaves the one who tried and failed to care for her and no longer speaks to anyone, and me.

I live about 100 miles to the north, and my mother often stated that she would not be content in my small, boring, cold-weather town—but still. I feel that I have failed to live up to the multigenerational ideal for a functional family, of providing a home where the wise grandmother enriches the daily life of her offspring’s family with wit and grace, of caring for an aging parent with the same love and attention with which she once cared for me. Instead, I have warehoused my mother.

And once again, God’s boundless sense of humor infuses my life with the last thing I had ever expected to happen: my mother, safely moved into an assisted living facility, needing help with the most unmentionable of personal tasks, has a beau. I’ll call him Jerome. The staff members are a bit flummoxed by this blossoming relationship, which they say has never come up on the assisted living side before. I infer from this that the independent living side is a regular Peyton Place. My mother and Jerome, who is a recent widower, spend a lot of time together at daily activities. She watches “Jeopardy” and “Wheel of Fortune” in his room every night. They share snacks. They embrace and hold hands, and they kiss goodbye when I pick my mother up for an outing or an errand or a doctor’s appointment. To my dismay, and knowing full well I should be happy for my mother’s newfound companionship, I secretly compare Jerome to my dad and find Jerome lacking. I have sad insight into what it might feel like to be a child of divorce.

“What do you think of Jerome?” my mother asks me coyly, as if we were eighth graders together.

“He’s nice,” I say.

“He asked me to be his girlfriend,” she says.

“Well, I’m not going to call him Dad,” I tell her, and immediately feel bad. Why would I deny her the joy of Jerome? What is my problem? If I say I want my mother to be happy in her golden years, why am I resentful when she is? I am learning to see this experience as an opportunity for new growth in my spiritual development, for new acceptance of God’s presence in all things, for new depth to my soul.

My mother’s photo regularly appears in The Village’s monthly newsletter, often at Jerome’s side, always smiling and doing something entertaining. She is becoming a fixture there, in a way that she probably would not be in one of her children’s spare rooms. It is becoming her home, a home away from any home we ever shared with her, a home where we are visitors. I also watch her shrink, in body and in mind, as she travels the road of age and illness, and I wonder if we have done the right thing. She has the funds to afford another 10 years at The Village, at least, and we will worry about where she will live after that when the time comes. At that point our family will have to become the village she needs.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
James Richard
5 years 5 months ago
Valerie, my mother went to the same thing as your mother is going through. Assisted living, followed by moving to the higher level care area for people with dementia and Alzheimer. Eventually she ended up in a nursing home, where she died last year. We had to sell her house to pay for it all, and although my four brothers and myself ended without anything for an inheritance, we knew she was comfortable and well cared for until her last day. I always felt some guilt for putting my parents into a nursing home, but the reality of the level of care they required, was beyond us. Thanks for sharing.
Mike Evans
5 years 5 months ago
And so we as a society ignore the need for long-term care insurance. We require a spend down so our frail seniors can then be supported by some form of Medicaid. Thus their entire lives end up being liquidated and then only pay for about the first 6 months of their long term care. The village is a cheap skate enterprise, shackled to a profit making system of convalescent care designed to drain every last penny from the private and public purse. The references to family guilt are too often excuses for trying to preserve an inheritance or estate while waiting for an early, merciful death to end the need. Let's be honest: long term care will be needed by most of us given the medical interventions that now save and preserve lives. Unfortunately, that advancement may mean life in diapers and a parked wheelchair for too long a time to imagine.
Winifred Holloway
5 years 5 months ago
Valerie, so many of us have been in the place where you are now. When I was a young woman, I was certain that I would take care of my parents and my husband's parents should they need it. My in-laws had short, final illnesses and my dad died in his sleep at home. My mother's decline into dementia was a nightmare. My sister lived 30 miles from her and I lived more than 3 hours away. She refused to move into a more secure situation and did not want to live in the boring small town that I lived in at the time, nor could my sister, overwhelmed with a small house and a large family, bring her into that home. My mother wouldn't have gone there anyway. Finally (yes, with a visit from the police) she was placed in a nursing home, close to my sister. It was more than 20 years ago and it saddens me still. I can't console myself, so I won't try to console you. Just want you to know that I get it. Soon after my mom died, my 50ish brother-in-law started showing signs of Alzheimer's. My sister vowed that she would take care of him at home. I did not argue. I am a nurse and knew what was ahead of her. I knew she would figure it out when life became impossible. One morning when he fell out of bed and she had to call one of her children from her job for help, it became clear to her that she could not continue caring for him at home. I tell myself, as I say to you, we feel guilty but we are not guilty. ( Seriously, I would rather be guilty than feel guilty.) This is our life. Your mom is lucky to have you, your sibs, and her boyfriend. Thank you for this posting. Always a pleasure to read your thoughtful articles.
Monica Doyle
5 years 4 months ago
Valerie, Mom will be 85 in a month, is still legally able to drive, is in good health other than forgetting recent events and repeating herself, and did not want to move out of her home. Since she had a main floor bedroom & bathroom, with two other empty bedrooms, we put an addition onto her house and moved in with her. While this decision seemed great two years ago and she was very happy at the time, it was a nightmare for her living through renovations (and our contractor was extremely attentive to her ). We have moved in, with the intentions of buying the house from her, and providing a jovial family environment as best we can. We cook all her meals for her and of course she has no more maintenance to do with the house. I work in healthcare, shift work,sometimes opposite my husband, so someone is home 9 out of 14 days for her, but those other days I am not around become boring for her. I almost wonder if the lovely social environment you described would have turned out better for her, although I could not see her adapting to any kind of move. The addition was enormously expensive, to provide multi-generational "space", so I just have to trust in Providence that we made the right decision. There are no easy answers. Thanks for your lovely article. I enjoy your columns as I have 4 adult children and one teenager. And now we both have ageing mothers too!


The latest from america

 10.17.2018 Pope Francis greets Cardinal Blase J. Cupich of Chicago before a session of the Synod of Bishops on young people, the faith and vocational discernment at the Vatican Oct. 16. (CNS photo/Vatican Media)
“We take people where they are, walking with them, moving forward,” Cardinal Blase Cupich said.
Michael J. O’LoughlinOctober 20, 2018
Catherine Pakaluk, who currently teaches at the Catholic University of America and holds a Ph.D. in Economics from Harvard University, describes her tweet to Mr. Macron as “spirited” and “playful.”
Emma Winters October 19, 2018
A new proposal from the Department of Homeland Security could make it much more difficult for legal immigrants to get green cards in the United States. But even before its implementation, the proposal has led immigrants to avoid receiving public benefits.
J.D. Long-GarcíaOctober 19, 2018
 Archbishop Carlo Maria Vigano, then nuncio to the United States, and then-Cardinal Theodore E. McCarrick of Washington, are seen in a combination photo during the beatification Mass of Blessed Miriam Teresa Demjanovich at the Cathedral Basilica of the Sacred Heart in Newark, N.J., Oct. 4, 2014. (CNS photo/Gregory A. Shemitz)
In this third letter Archbishop Viganò no longer insists, as he did so forcefully in his first letter, that the restrictions that he claimed Benedict XVI had imposed on Archbishop McCarrick—one he alleges that Pope Francis later lifted—can be understood as “sanctions.”
Gerard O’ConnellOctober 19, 2018