February 15, 2010

Something’s Happening!

Re “Bishops Battle Over Spiritual Worth of Medjugorje Pilgrimages” (Signs of the Times, 1/18): I heard Pope John Paul II’s reflection on the subject. It is neither a papal secret nor a papal declaration, but at one of the luncheons with bishops that the pope regularly hosted, Bishop Jerome J. Hastrich, then bishop of Gallup, N.M., asked the pope what he thought about Medjugorje. The pope said, “Well, something’s happening there!” Miraculous appearances or not, people are finding some spiritual peace and strength there, and that’s no doubt why Cardinal Schönborn visited there and spoke positively about it.

(Most Rev.) Frank J. Rodimer

Bishop Emeritus of Paterson

Newfoundland, N.J.

Cor ad Cor Loquitur

Thank you for the extraordinary piece “Waiting for Doctor Newman,” by Nicholas Lash (2/1). In typical self-effacing Newman fashion, Professor Lash is not identified as one of the leading Newman scholars of our time. But his beautiful quotes from various sources about Newman’s significance for the Church of England and the Church of Rome reveal the depth and breadth of his research.

My next e-mail will go to as many friends as possible, to read this piece as a tribute not just to Newman but to his importance for church unity in our day. Finally, let us all hope that Pope Benedict will heed his own advice, cited by Lash, from 1990 when as Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger he said that “Newman belongs to the great doctors of the church because he both touches our hearts and enlightens our thinking.”

David Powell

Glendale, N.Y.

The Real Problem

Re “Weakened by Defense” (Editorial, 1/18): It is not defense spending that has been wildly rising and threatening to bankrupt our country, but rather the massive, exponential growth in Social Security and Medicare, in comparison with which defense spending has drastically shrunk.

Walter Mattingly

Jacksonville, Fla.

Up With Freewill Offerings

It is disconcerting that the editors focus on tax-generated revenues to solve social problems (“Weakened by Defense,” Editorial, 1/18). The primary role of government has grown over time because we have allowed it to do so. Now with so many dependent on government, the editors have little choice but to critique the defense budget. America should champion the Judeo-Christian ethic and tradition of caring for those who are in need and not put the burden on the taxpayer. Continued dependence on the tax dollar will bind those (including thousands of charitable organizations) who give by volition, ultimately securing their dollars without their voice or giving hands.

Patrick Morand

Kalamazoo, Mich.

Power and Prestige

I cannot believe the excuses that are made for our bellicose approach to living in this complex and diverse world. The sabre-rattling mindset that sees us as the bully of the world and punisher of all evildoers is simply insane. By now we could have purchased both Iraq and Afghanistan outright and given their people far more joy than air strikes ever will or can. We are spending huge sums to kill and maim and destroy. No wonder the rest of the world distrusts and disrespects America and its aims. We are not fighting for American freedom but for American power and prestige. We will, in the end, fail to win at any cost.

(Deacon) Mike Evans

Anderson, Calif.

Just War and/or Torture

The theme of Stephen Colecchi’s article “No Excuses for Torture” (1/18), that torture degrades both the victim and the perpetrator, is not only pointed but self-evident. He goes on to say that the church views torture as an “intrinsic evil” that can never be justified. This position seems difficult to rationalize, particularly in view of the church position on war. The church effectively teaches that war is not intrinsically evil by having developed the just war theory. In a “just war” tens of thousands of people could be killed, including civilians. How can war be justified under certain conditions, with thousands killed, while an extremely limited use of torture, in which no one is killed but as a result of which thousands of lives may be saved, is intrinsically evil and never justified?

Peter A. Martosella Jr.

Ambler, Pa.

Forward to the Middle Ages

“Collegiality Made Visible,” by Michael Sean Winters (1/18), is right on the mark. How sad that the vision and decisions of Vatican II continue to be ignored because of the obsession for power. The church is suffering because of the present system of appointment of bishops. Almost all other organizations are becoming more decentralized in order to be more effective. We, on the other hand, seem to be regressing more and more to a Middle-Ages model. This certainly is not what Jesus meant when he washed the feet of the apostles or what he proclaimed to be his ministry (to serve, not to be served).

Ron Patnode

Wapato, Wash.

Let’s Get on With It

For years—more than Father Ryan, I think—I have closely followed the ins and outs of the ICEL process of translation (“What If We Said, ‘Wait’?” by Michael G. Ryan, 12/14). I have reviewed the final text and find it outstanding. It is infinitely better than the sophomoric and inaccurate translation that tortured us for these 40 years with the so-called “dynamic equivalency” translation.

Father Ryan seems to look down his nose at the venerable Anglican translation of the Mass, which we will soon be able to enjoy even in the Latin rite. He also seems a bit upset by the recognitio (ratification) that the Holy See must give the ICEL translation, forgetting that the Holy See is the ancient and venerable custodian of the Latin rite. An accurate, reverent and elegant English translation is supremely important because it will be used by dozens of English-speaking countries, and the Holy See is the guarantor of orthodoxy.

So let’s get on with it. I am sure the people will love the new translation and happily use it for generations to come.

(Rev.) Gino Dalpiaz, C.S.

Chicago, Ill.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
11 years 3 months ago

The (Rev) Gino Dalpiaz, C.S. nailed the problem with the new translation when he said;" An accurate, reverent and elegant English translation is supremely important because it will be used by dozens of English-speaking countries, and the Holy See is the guarantor of orthodoxy."

When I went as a missionary to Papua New Guinea I made the mistake to taking my "Divine Office" with me. It was approved for the USA, the Antilles, "dozens of English-speaking countries", and Papua New Guinea.  Turns out I could not use it for common prayer. They were using a version approved for Australia, Papua New Guinea, "dozens of English-speaking countries" and the USA!

"Dozens of English-speaking countries" do not speak the same English any more than "dozens of Spanish -speaking countries" speak the same Spanish.

As a native son of "Eastern Pennsylvania" I grew up near a group of immigrants from Germany who are called the Pennsylvania Dutch. They kept their German grammar and just translated the words into English. This gave way to quaint expressions such as; "Throw mama from the train a kiss" and the ever popular; "throw papa down the stairs his shoes"!

It may be good German, it may even be 'keeping as close to the original as possible', and Lord knows it brings in the tourists; but it is bad English. The same can be said for the new translation of the Mass. It may be good Latin, it may even be 'keeping as close to the original as possible', but Lord knows that is bad liturgy and bad English.

Our bishops should put the entire thing on hold until they can get a good American English translation.

The latest from america

Stephen Chow, S.J. (photo courtesy the Chinese Province of the Society of Jesus) 
The diocese has been without a bishop since Jan. 3, 2019, when Bishop Michael Yeung Ming-cheung died after leading the diocese for just 17 months.
Gerard O’ConnellMay 17, 2021
Pope Francis brought consolation and hope to Catholics and countless people of other religions in Myanmar when he celebrated Mass in St. Peter’s Basilica this Sunday morning for peace in their troubled homeland, which was robbed of democracy by a military coup on Feb. 1.
Gerard O’ConnellMay 16, 2021
Pope Francis today expressed his “very great concern” at the armed clashes in Gaza and Israel and made an urgent, passionate appeal “to those with the responsibility” to bring a ceasefire and “to walk the path of peace.”
Gerard O’ConnellMay 16, 2021
I wondered if I could even be Catholic anymore, much less continue pursuing the priesthood somewhere else.
Bruce WilkinsonMay 15, 2021