War Profits

I have read numerous articles in America on the war in Iraq. These articles have been well written and based on fact and Catholic teachings. None supported the war. In the Dec. 24 issue, an article by John F. Kavanaugh, S.J., continued the fine journalistic tradition of the magazine. Three pages later I found a full-page ad to recruit military chaplains.

Such magazine advertisements serve as more than notices to priests. They say something about the validity of war. The issue of military chaplains is a complicated one that would be a good topic for America to investigate and report.


I doubt if the ad in America changes the opinion of any editor of the magazine, but it gives a mixed message to its readers. Accepting money from special interest groups, in this case the military, carries a message beyond the ad. I hope America will reconsider its policy of accepting money through advertising from any branch of the U.S. military.

Patricia McCarthy, C.N.D.

Wilton, Conn.

Mirror Image

The interview with Klaus Dietz, S.J., “Christ and Secular Sweden” (12/24), by Jim McDermott, S.J., made me check the map, thinking for sure we must be in Sweden! Youngsters leaving the church, immigrants arriving but later buying into another Gospel (here we call it the American dream)—we have it all here in the States. Individualism there, as here, must be countered one heart at a time.

(Rev.) Fred Close

Washington, D.C.

Further Questions

In “Church Teaching and My Father’s Choice,” (1/21), John J. Hardt invites us to ask big questions. By using his father as an example, he puts a face on the questions, but he also makes it difficult to criticize his argument without seeming heartless.

But his article seems to steer us rhetorically toward answers that bring us another step closer to what John Paul II called a culture of death. Perhaps in future articles he can ask questions that invite us to build up the culture of life. They could be questions inviting us to courage in the face of possible future failing of mind and body, encouraging answers in which unconditional love of parents takes for granted ensuring their care even in the face of personal heartache or recognizing that part of parents’ responsibility to God in their twilight years is to teach their children to live such love by letting them practice it on their parents.

(Rev.) Thomas Schliessmann

Edinburgh, Ind.

Simple but Elegant

I found it somewhat unsettling that John J. Hardt’s “Church Teaching and My Father’s Choice” (1/21) needed to be written at all. It seems that these end-of-life issues are becoming more complex when they need not be. Do we all need to become moral theologians to make family decisions such as these?

My Catholic education took place in the 1940s and 50s, when the rather simple but elegant guide was that “extraordinary” means did not have to be used to prolong life. Ordinary people like me can understand and make these distinctions. The church need not worry, because people like me can also understand the clear difference between allowing someone to die naturally and euthanasia.

A few years ago, when my mother was in the terminal stage of Alzheimer’s after a long decline, she was unconscious and could no longer be fed. My mother had much the same religious outlook John Hardt’s father has. When I was asked about a feeding tube, I said no, because I thought that was an “extraordinary” means at that stage. Would that decision now be deemed inappropriate?

John Hrastar

Silver Spring, Md.

Good News, Bad News

I found “The Conversion of Tony Blair,” by Austen Ivereigh, (1/7) disappointing. In general, the article did a good job describing Blair’s background, interests in Catholicism and the complexities of his becoming a Catholic as the British prime minister and, now, a former one.

But the problem was the use of the word “convert” as a noun and a verb about Tony Blair and others who are received into full communion. This word carries ominous overtones of triumphalism and communicates the notion that we are the “one, true church” and those other churches are “less” than we are. The author never intended such triumphalism, yet the word remains.

Moreover, the U.S. Bishops’ National Statutes for the Catechumenate (No. 2) reads: “The term ‘convert’ should be reserved strictly for those converted from unbelief to Christian belief and never used of those baptized Christians who are received into the full communion of the Catholic Church.”

Personally, I find the word to be an oxymoron, for I fail to grasp how Christians can “convert” to something they already constitute—the body of Christ.

While the word “convert” may seem like a minor point, it treats our brothers and sisters in Christ as at best inferior to us Catholics. At worst, it scorns their baptism. Yet I find great hope in the fact that we do not rebaptize and that we celebrate this commonality.

Jay Freel Landry

South Bend, Ind.

The Almighty Dollar

“American Catholics in the New Gilded Age,” by Daniel J. Morrissey, (1/7) is a great commentary on the state of the culture in the United States these days. It shows an epidemic of lying and dishonesty in the areas of economics, banking, Wall Street and the mortgage industry to boost housing values artificially so that investors can make greater profits. Greed and materialism are being exalted to new levels. It seems there are new meanings in economic affairs to the saying that “the end justifies the means!”

Joe Trevors

Hercules, Calif.

Justices for All

Daniel J. Morrissey writes in “American Catholics in the New Gilded Age” (1/7) that the Bush administration has only these tangible achievements: “its tax reductions and deregulatory schemes.” I disagree. Two tangible and significant achievements of this administration are the appointments of Justice Roberts and Justice Alito. The expectation that George W. Bush would get to appoint one or more justices to the Supreme Court was the main reason I voted for him.

Mary Moritz

Jacksonville, Fla.

A Prophetic Voice

Archbishop George Niederauer’s “Flannery O’Connor’s Religious Vision” (12/24) was a wonderful gift to subscribers. It was encouraging to read his reminder that even though O’Connor died during the Second Vatican Council, she already knew what the council would proclaim: that the church is the body of Christ, the people of God; that laypeople are its flesh and blood; and that the clergy and its religious orders are its servant-leaders. So many of us ordinary Catholics long to hear our spiritual leaders express the spirit and vision of the Second Vatican Council.

I also wish that Flannery O’Connor were alive today to write of Jesus’ saving action among us now, as people of faith try so desperately to counter corporate greed, high-level political corruption and increasing poverty and injustice. But Flannery O’Connor left us with more than enough evidence to believe that as we make Jesus present in the world, we shall overcome.

Jim Crosson

Fair Lawn, N.J.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
10 years 10 months ago
The letter (2/11) of Patricia McCarthy, C.N.D. very deftly expresses the dilemma that many of us feel: the belief that this war in Iraq is in no way a just war. And yet because it is such a bloodstained and traumatic conflict it calls out for compassionate chaplaincy to our soldiers. Your recruitment ads for military chaplains may address the needs of soldiers, but not of those readers seeking discernment. If the editors of America have persuasive reasons for continuing these ads, let them be published in a format that invites open discussion.
10 years 10 months ago
I found the letter (2/11) of Patricia McCarthy, C.N.D. to be disturbing. I looked for some scriptural support of the position which she appears to support, i.e. not having chaplains for our service members. I found what I was looking for in Matt. 28:19 "Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, except for the military of the USA. They are to be thrown into the darkness outside, and deserve nothing from us." What a shame that she has such a limited grasp of the reality of the lives of those serving in the military.
10 years 9 months ago
I write in support of your advertisements for chaplains in the U.S. military. Having served in military health care for many years, I know that this ministry has served crucial spiritual needs of our brothers and sisters who find themselves in harms way. With Iraq in mind, it is no less crucial to have chaplains available now, as these brave citizens struggle to reconcile personal, moral, religious and patriotic aspects their assignments. Rather than rejecting such ads as support for war...this one or any other, I can also see value in calling for more ads and support for more chaplians. God knows they're needed.


The latest from america

The act of planting a garden is the easier part: It’s the small daily acts of caring over the long haul that can be a challenge.
Elizabeth Kirkland CahillDecember 15, 2018
So what is it about these cheesy, mass-produced films that make them so irresistible?
Colleen DulleDecember 14, 2018
Last year, 'America' published “An (unconventional) Advent Playlist.” This is my (much more conventional) Advent playlist.
Molly MattinglyDecember 14, 2018
Jeff Daniels in ‘To Kill a Mockingbird’ (photo: Julieta Cervantes)
Two starry new Broadway productions have no qualms about speaking their mind.
Rob Weinert-KendtDecember 14, 2018