Protests near Times Square, New York, Dec. 3 (photo by Olga Segura).

Yesterday (as reported on our site here and here), a week after a grand jury in Missouri decided not to indict the white cop who shot and killed Michael Brown, Americans were given another stunning example of the race issues in our country. In July, unarmed African-American Eric Garner was chokeholded by white NYC police on Staten Island. He died as a result of that action. The scene was captured in full on video. As Jon Stewart pointed out in a furious monologue last night, the Garner case was even more cut and dry than that of Michael Brown. Even the local coroner called it a homicide. But still, the grand jury refused to indict the cop.

What will come from these shocking decisions, the outrage throughout our country? If recent history is any indication, probably nothing. We couldn’t get even a modicum of gun control passed two years ago after twenty children were gunned down in Newtown, Connecticut. True, we had the mighty gun lobby to contend with, but still—if there were ever going to be political will on anything, you’d have thought it would have been on that.


When it comes to race, our leaders barely have the will to talk about the situation, and that’s with a black president. No doubt President Obama will have press conferences about our racial problem for the next couple months. Maybe we’ll have members of the Garner or Brown family at the State of the Union. But the question is, will anything actually come of it? Anything at all? 

Today, African-Americans from all over the country have begun to post their own stories of profiling, harassment and discrimination on Twitter under the hashtag “AliveWhileBlack”. One after another offers striking examples of the need for not just well-worded political indignation, but concrete action and change. 

“Crossing the grocery store parking lot. Cops stopped to ask me what I was doing there. I was holding grocery bags.” @Karnythia #AliveWhileBlack

“Hit over the head with a flashlight because I didn’t RESPOND quickly enough when asked a question. I was 13 at the time.” @KEFABE63 #AliveWhileBlack

“Walking to school at 12. Harassed by 2 cops every day for weeks. Complete with racial slurs.” @Karnythia #AliveWhileBlack

 “was robbed at knife point in Charlotte. When the police came, told them what was taken, they asked ‘Why wld u have a pager’” @missjia #AliveWhileBlack

“17 y/o—Drove to Kroger to get mom Nyquil. Pulled over unexplained. Asked why I was in my neighborhood. 4 backup cop cars.” @AkilahObviously #AliveWhileBlack

“Patted down on the hood of a cop car at 9 yrs old.” @daniecal #AliveWhileBlack

"was pulled over by a white cop for missing tags; he came to my door with his gun drawn, finger on trigger." @elonalone #AliveWhileBlack

“Pulled over w my mom. People think shes white, she was driving. Cops asked for my ID and license ‘for her protection’.” @ProfessorBLove #AliveWhileBlack

“Was working in retail & picked up a shift at another store. security guard profiled me over the walkie when i walked in.” @chescaleigh #AliveWhileBlack

“In HS. Cops accuse my fam of stealing a lady’s purse at JCPenney—threaten my mom—purse was in bottom of lady’s stroller.” @LaurenASands #AliveWhileBlack

 “I didn’t return ‘free lunch’ form because my dad made too much money. Teacher said loudly: ‘Oh, so you know him?’” @RLM_3 #AliveWhileBlack

“Ex bf was waiting 4 me outside my home. I come out he’s surrounded by cops while on the ground. He ‘looked suspicious.’” @iamlegend924 #AliveWhileBlack

 “Constantly asked if I’m lost or in the right room when attending committee meetings at my job.” @KeylaRosa_ #AliveWhileBlack

“they tried to charge my mom with disorderly conduct because she was pissed i got accused of stealing a bike she bought.” @CAMLAHEY #AliveWhileBlack

“My father was pulled over for speeding while he was on his way to the ER...The cop didn’t believe he was a doctor.” @StephhLane #AliveWhileBlack


Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
ed gleason
4 years 1 month ago
A closer look of how we got to this state of affairs. 1. The prosecutors in both Fergurson and Staten Island, Mc Cullagh [St Louis U] and Sullivan {Fordham] . Are these guys a shining example of Catholic education? 2. If you want to hear the only voices and a full court press on why those grand jury proceedings were just dandy, tune into Fox news. You can hear the Catholic educated anchors. O'Rielly, Cavuto, Hannity, Megan Kelly.. All have Irish/America backrounds and Catholic educations.{Cavuto has Irish/Italian backround]. 3. Does this make you hesitate to respond to your Catholic alma mater for the usual Christmas appeal?
Roy Van Brunt
4 years 1 month ago
This is not, in my view, merely a "race problem." I listened to Andrew Cuomo say that the protests after the Garner grand jury's declination to indict in the Garner case demonstrate the lack of faith of the people protesting in the criminal justice system. I think it's a whole lot deeper and far more serious than that, and I am appalled that the media and even the author of the above article do not sense the real root here. After six years of dysfunctional federal government at the Executive and particularly at the Congressional level, and after seeing even the Supreme Court (with Jesuit-educated justices like Nino Scalia - (Xavier HS / Georgetown) interpret our Constitution take such such ridiculous positions as the Second Amendment prohibits any meaningful gun control laws and "corporations are People and have the same rights," and allowing corporations to make limitless financial contribution to influence allegedly popular elections, the populace is very close to feeling totally frustrated distrust in government itself, at all levels, and its ability to be responsive to popular will. This is no longer the great democracy that we all were taught about in school, and/or that the founders contemplated, and that we are spending billions of dollars a year to foist on the rest of the world through our wars. It is instead, pragmatic chaos. No one in their right mind (except apparently the prosecutors and Staten Island grand jurors?) thinks that the homicide that took place in Staten Island should be un-indictable. The acts of the police in Furgeson may be debatable, but the act of even accidentally killing an unarmed and just overweight alleged perpetrator of a very minor "crime" by a police officer using a tactic expressly forbidden by the police HAS TO BE indictable. Probably should not even been presented to a grand jury. And that is not to argue presumed guilt - the officer may well have been able to exonerate himself. But for established government to allow police to act like this and not even be held accountable in a court of law is a very serious result and one that has to undermine in many many people - black, white or yellow - any confidence in our system of law - and it is troubling to me that neither the media nor learned counsel yet sense this reality. We are very very close to experiencing a broad level of righteous civil unrest that will mark a very troubled time for this Republic. And one that no one seems even to see coming.
John Corr
4 years 1 month ago
The Garner-Brown grand jury decisions involved issues of law and fact. These decisions cannot be effectively attacked with undocumented righteous anger.


The latest from america

In cities across the country, local activists marched in support of a progressive agenda centered on economic justice, racial justice and immigrant rights.
Brandon SanchezJanuary 20, 2019
Screengrab from a viral video showcasing a confrontation between a Native American drummer and a group of Catholic high school students in Washington, D.C. on Jan. 18, 2019. Screenshot via YouTube.
Several clips of the encounter circulating on social media show a small group of Native American drummers, who were in Washington for the Indigenous People’s March, being surrounded by a much larger band of teenagers.
Pope Francis has suppressed the Ecclesia Dei Commission, a significant decision with consequences for the Holy See’s relations with the priestly Fraternity of St. Pius X.
Gerard O’ConnellJanuary 19, 2019
Photo: IMDB
A new Netflix miniseries brings out the story’s aspects of adventure and conflict, with occasionally pulse-pounding results.
Rob Weinert-KendtJanuary 19, 2019