Click here if you don’t see subscription options
John A. ColemanApril 01, 2013

Most of my adult life, since Vatican II, at every parish I have either worshipped or celebrated Holy Thursday, the priest and others have washed the feet of men and women, boys, girls and elderly people. I have never in my life given much extra thought to this practice because it struck me that Jesus, of course, washes the feet of all those in need as a sign to us also to do likewise. That conservative and reactionary Catholics seemed aghast that Pope Francis, for the first time for a pope, washed the feet of women on Holy Thursday took me by surprise and stunned me! It literally stunned me in showing how out of touch so many in our church can sometimes be. But maybe I have not been paying attention. I now know that a number of "self-referential" bishops and priests (Pope Francis' great term about those who do not meet people where they are in their struggles, real lives and, as he puts it, "in the streets"), including the bishop of a neighboring diocese of mine, have forbidden the washing of women's feet on Holy Thursday. I saw a recent right-wing Catholic blog expressing disdain and disgust at the pope for washing the feet of women and Muslims and conjecturing that, perhaps, next year he would wash the feet of cats and dogs! This may be a harbinger of Catholic conservative back lash on our pope.

I am saddened by such narrow and not terribly theologically informed ecclesial theology. I suspect that they think that, because Jesus washed the feet of his disciples at the last supper, if we wash the feet of women soon they will want to consider themselves also disciples and want to be ordained! Actually, I have never imagined that there were no women at the Last Supper, if indeed it was held on the Passover. Jewish ritual assumed that the seder at the Passover was not legitimate if there were no women present. In the patriarchal society at the time of Jesus, who else would have served the meals? Jesus had, himself, just been anointed by a woman in costly nards and said something that, in fact, the church has largely ignored through most of its history: "Amen, I say to you, wheverever the gospel is proclaimed in the whole world, what she has done will be spoken of, in memory of me" ( Matthew 26:13). In point of fact we have very rarely heard of this act of the woman proclaimed far and wide about her washing Jesus' feet with her tears.

Hurray for Bishop of Rome and also Pope Francis for washing the feet of women and few Muslims in the detention facility on Holy Thursday. Of course, they would have felt left out if their feet could not be washed. What a breath of fresh air—so necessary after such a long period of overly self-centered church activity—this pope represents. Let all of us call narrow, self-referential bishops and priests who do not allow the washing of feet of women in our parishes on Holy Thursday to some kind of ecclesial accounting and conversion. We need to address their narrow ecclesiology which slights women and the role of the whole laity--and the inclusive ministry of Jesus. At a time when people lament the narrow roles allowed to women in the church, what does it symbolize if you can not wash their feet on Holy Thursday?

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Theresa Maccarone
11 years 3 months ago
" At a time when people lament the narrow roles allowed to women in the church, what does it symbolize if you can not wash their feet on Holy Thursday?" A seriously outdated Church and a fear of women.
Mark Burke
11 years 3 months ago
"It literally stunned me in showing how out of touch so many in our church can sometimes be." It literally stuns me that Fr. Colemen should be so out of touch with how contentious and fractious the contemporary Church has become that he's surprised by the controversy. Clearly, as he admits, he's not been paying attention. I hope the pope thinks, now, to change the liturgical law governing Holy Thursday. Otherwise, next year, parish priests are going to find themselves between a rock (the pope's example) and a hard place (the liturgical norm promulgated under his apostolic authority).
ed gleason
11 years 3 months ago
", [some few =my edit ] parish priests are going to find themselves between a rock (the pope's example) and a hard place' Yes they will, and they may gain some sensitivty about where we Vat II progressives have been for thirty years. But I would never ask them to leave.. "where would we go Lord'
James Sullivan
11 years 3 months ago
I left a Jesuit church in Manhattan last week and said to the celebrant outside church, " I am praying for Fancis." and he responded, "Aren't we all!" I am a gay man and I love my parish. I am not looking for Pope Francis to have the politically correct position on every current issue--and agree with ME! Francis' emphasis on service to the poor makes me quite happy--and his reaching out to the marginalized ( washing of the feet of the Muslin woman) was enormously inspirational. Let us now continue the work of John XX111.
Bob Newbury
11 years 3 months ago
Individual deviation from prescribed ritual at an expense
sheila dierks
11 years 3 months ago
It is fascinating, the world of thought and possibility that has been in existence for a long long time, but is now being talked about publicly with the arrival of Francis in our midst in his role as Bishop of Rome. John Coleman makes an interesting point "Of course, they would have felt left out if their feet had not been washed." So I would, continuing with that line of thought, remark that YES we feel left out, we ARE left out, we have been left out for centuries, we have had theology used against us because we are female, we have borne the burden of Augustine and his millennial confreres who "ivory-towered" their view of creation while others, probably women, washed their clothes and cooked their food. John Coleman states what is obvious to females from the time they are seven. He sounds as if this is a surprise, a discovery, an announcement, even an empathy. Welcome, John, to the reality of our church. May your discovery, your "of course" be echoed in every episcopal palace and every rectory around the world.
Charlie Cahill
11 years 3 months ago
Oh for the good old days when the Sisters went about cleaning around the sanctuary and washing the altar cloths preparing all for the next Mass.Perhaps the CWL or its equivalent could take up that practice today. Perhaps Francis could so mandate when he changes the mandate re washing of the feet? Just a suggestion gievn in charity.
Charles Starr
11 years 3 months ago
You've given me a great idea! In October on Francis's feast day we will wash the feet of the animals. Thanks.

The latest from america

"Together with my brother bishops, we condemn political violence, and we offer our prayers for President Trump, and those who were killed or injured," said Archbishop Broglio, the president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops.
Many political and faith leaders, even as they prayed for Trump, also asked for prayers for the country as a whole, and particularly America’s polarized political landscape.
Trump’s campaign said the presumptive GOP nominee was doing “fine” after the shooting, which he said pierced the upper part of his right ear.
In an exclusive interview with Gerard O’Connell, Cardinal Jean-Claude Hollerich, one of the synod’s most influential figures, discusses the role of women, bishops and all the baptized in a synodal church.
Gerard O’ConnellJuly 12, 2024